Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations


Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here


A happy Chutima Sidasathian leaves court, followed by her mother, Krissana

Why Good Journalism Matters

Tuesday, September 1, 2015
UPDATING All Day, Every Day

PHUKETWAN'S coverage has been suspended awaiting a judgement in the criminal defamation and Computer Crimes Act case brought against journalists Alan Morison and Chutima Sidasathian by the Royal Thai Navy. The verdict is due to be delivered on September 1.

Original Report

I BEGAN my career in journalism about the same time as Alan Morison, half a century ago at the afternoon newspaper, The Herald, in Melbourne, Australia.

It sold more than half a million copies a day. It was a force in the city. It was listened to by politicians, by businessmen, by judges and lawyers, and was loved and respected by its readers.

Its journalists did not set out consciously each day to seek that approbation of its readers, who comprised about one in five of Melbourne's population.

They simply, like blind Justice, did their job - to discover and bring to the public the news of the day, whatever that news happened to be.

Nor did we concern ourselves much with what public reaction might be to what we wrote. We knew we had the support of our journalistic seniors and the public.

We were part of what was then called the Fourth Estate, a term born in eighteenth century Britain to describe the huge influence of newspapers in the life of the nation.

Originally the Press - the Fourth Estate - ranked with the other three Estates. These were the British parliamentary Estates known as the Lords spiritual, the Lords temporal and the members of the House of Commons.

That is, the Press and its journalists ranked alongside the unelected members of the British House of Lords, both churchmen and the nobility, and the elected members of the Commons. The Press had - and wielded - the power to bring down governments, to change government policy, to rein in government power.

Generally it used this power responsibly.

That was the environment in which young journalists learned their trade. Alan has continued to do that throughout his working life, in the finest traditions of the Press.

He now publishes his news in the new medium of the world wide web. He is part of the new fabric of news dissemination.

He, and his very impressive colleague, Chutima Sidasathian, have published news on their Phuketwan website that is certainly not to the taste of everyone who reads it.

News has been defined as ''something that someone, somewhere, does not want published. All the rest is advertising.''

Alan and Chutima do not deal in advertising, or seek to please their readers. They simply seek out the truth and disseminate it. The consequences in the case of their reporting of people smuggling in Thailand have been very serious indeed. Both face the possibility of jail.

For what? Has anyone challenged the truth of their reporting? No. They have been faithful to the best centuries-old traditions of their calling. They are in the legal position they face because their facts have annoyed people in power in Thailand.

These facts meet the classic definition - they were something that some people did not want printed. They were embarrassing, they were seen to diminish the standing of powerful people in a powerful social institution, the Royal Thai Navy - which was not mentioned in the report against which they took offence.

The facts were not challenged - Alan and Chutima's resolve to publish them, and therefore to shine a spotlight on a great and deeply troubling social issue, was under challenge. They were to be crushed as an example to others for their bold impertinence.

The original publisher of the words that drew the navy's response were not sued. They were too big and powerful. Shame on Reuters for abandoning Phuketwan to its fate.

In the long term such facts must - must - be published. The public has a right to know. All around the world, journalists daily pay for this demand on them with their freedom, sometimes their lives.

Thailand needs more journalists, and more media proprietors, who will take the risk of a backlash from powerful people and institutions in what they present to the community, whatever the risk and consequence.

It is vital to strong democracies for this to be done. It is vital for Thailand's future that its powerful institutions respect the Fourth Estate and its practitioners for doing their job.

The nation will never develop into a strong democracy without letting the facts - diligently gathered and responsibly reported - from being freely disseminated. It is the test every governing regime faces, and must pass.


Comments have been disabled for this article.


We won't have to visit you in the Phuket jail and bring you decent food, because you won't be going there.

But we will if we have to.

All the Best

Posted by farang888 on September 1, 2015 07:29


@David Harrison

Totally agree with you, but as we know, unfortunately the truth is not the point of the computer crimes act. Whether it was true or not is irrelevant for what happens today.

Best of luck to both at PW, let's pray common sense prevails.

Posted by Discover Thainess on September 1, 2015 07:44


I had the pleasure of meeting David Harrison a day before the trial commenced .

We endured those hard court benches for three days along with the small crowd of supporters who packed courtroom 4 at Phuket Provincial Court.

It was a real pleasure spending time with David, Alan, Chutima and so many of their supporters.

David flew from Melbourne to Phuket for the trial and returned for the verdict. He is an absolute gentleman and I am sure that Alan feels honored to count him as a life long friend.


Posted by Ian Yarwood on September 2, 2015 00:18

Editor Comment:

You're so right, Ian. When an old friend emerges from the mist of your past and says ''I'll help you'' then you know you stand a chance. Harro is a hero.

Thursday July 18, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa


Facebook Twitter