Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Life on a traffickers' boat is survival of the fittest with children most at risk

Struggle to Stay Alive Turns Stranded Boatpeople Into Killers

Sunday, May 17, 2015
PATTANI, Southern Thailand: Survivors of a boat that sank off Indonesia have described a bloody struggle for dwindling supplies of food on board, as thousands of illegal economic migrants and asylum-seekers remain perilously adrift at sea in the Malacca Strait and Andaman Sea.

People were thrown overboard as Rohingya and Bangladeshis fought for their survival, according to accounts of one of the grimmest episodes to emerge in a spiralling humanitarian disaster in south-east Asian waters.

"They were killing each other, throwing people overboard," said Sunarya, a police chief on the Indonesian island of Sumatra where around 900 people were rescued on Friday.

Mahmud Rafiq, a 21-year-old Rohingya man who left Myanmar a month ago, said people on board the boat agreed to leave the little food that was left to women and children.

"They then started hitting us. They took the food," Rafiq said.

"They pushed many of us overboard. They beat us and attacked us with knives," he said. "I was hit with a wooden plank on the head and on my legs."

Another survivor, Muhammad Koyes, said before the boat sank it had been turned away by both Indonesia and Malaysia in a round of maritime "ping pong" that has been criticised by the United Nations, the United States and other countries.

Photographs and video of people stranded at sea show distressed and emaciated men, women and children, many of them reportedly in need of medical treatment.

The UN has appealed for regional nations to launch urgent rescue operations to bring the boats ashore.

"We're not seeing any such moves from any governments in the region even though we're calling on the international community to take action because people are dying," said Jeffrey Savage from the UN refugee agency.

The crisis unfolded last month when Thailand began cracking down on human trafficking networks backed by powerful political figures, local officials and police after the discovery of mass graves and smuggler camps in remote areas near the Thailand and Malaysian borders.

The crackdown prompted traffickers to abandon asylum-seekers who had made the dangerous journey across the Bay of Bengal from Myanmar and Bangladesh.

The crisis has shattered the notion of co-operation within the 10-member Association of South-East Asian Nations as Thailand and Malaysia urged Myanmar, the country also called Burma, to act to stop a mass exodus of Rohingya from its western Arakan State.

More than 25,000 people attempted the journey in the first three months of this year with an estimated 300 dying from starvation, disease or beatings by boat crew and people smugglers.

However Myanmar has rejected a call to attend a Thai hosted regional summit on May 29 to discuss the crisis.

Malaysia's prime minister Najib Razak on Saturday said he would seek help from Myanmar to help address what he called a "humanitarian catastrophe".

"I hope they will give a positive response as the refugees are due to internal problems that we cannot interfere with, but we want to do something before it gets worse," he said.

For years Malaysia turned a blind eye to the arrival on its shores through human trafficking networks of tens of thousands of Rohingya who provided cheap labour and lived quietly among Malaysians.

But since the Thai crackdown Malaysia has declared Rohingya unwelcome and pushed boats back out to sea.

The UN and refugee advocates estimate there could be as many as 8,000 people still stranded on overcrowded boats while more than 2,000 have managed to come ashore in Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia in recent weeks.

The US State Department said Secretary of State John Kerry has phoned his Thai counterpart to "discuss the possibility of Thailand providing temporary accommodation for them".

But Thailand's military leaders have said they could not host camps without help from other countries and international agencies.

They also said they are worried that establishing camps could provoke a wave of new arrivals from Myanmar, where 1.3 million Rohingya are effectively stateless, refused citizenship and basic rightsalthough Rohingya have lived in the country for generations.

They have often been the target of Buddhist mobs and tens of thousands live in squalid camps.

The Bangladeshis are believed to be mainly illegal economic migrants.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Both Thailand and Malaysia are more than happy to exploit undocumented migrants in virtual slavery but this episode also makes it crystal clear neither nation gives a damn about what happens to these people.

To claim Thailand is just a transit nation is total rubbish. Even according to the official Thai government statistics they estimate there are over 2 million undocumented migrant workers in Thailand.

Even worse, there is no public outcry in either nation to step in and help these people. On the contrary - all we read is "not in my back yard" while their Burmese "helpers" toil away in their garden.

Posted by Herbert on May 17, 2015 10:52

gravatar

not sure about thailand,i dont live there,so my knowledge is limited,but illegal immigrants as slaves in malaysia...you are not completely correct on this matter.sure,cheap labor,human trafficking,sure,but do you know why they,rohingya's,keep trying to get into malaysia,refusing thailand's offer?you've heard of the american dream,but here is the case of the malaysian dream. Do you know why illegal immigrants from other countries like bangladesh,pakistan,myanmar,vietnam,or even china and india immigrate here? Just another transit? Nope.They had a bigger chances of success,compared to other asian countries. Our laws are more relaxed,lack of enforcement,sympathisers towards them,ie muslims among muslims,hindus among hindus,etc. Poor foreigners easily live a comfortable life compared to back home. Quite a number turned their fortune around. Some are really wealthy and had acquired citizenship,or spouse visa(which is abused for jobs,which is illegal)Do you know illegal immigrant receive the same privilage as citizens themselves? Google it.Many of whom started as illegal immigrant who later becomed citizen,a popular method is spouse visa,which only take 10-15 years,while breaking the law working in malaysia,being underpaid at first,later on getting more with their permanent residence status. Many,albeit being illegal immigrant,opened shop,stall,etc and acquired a sum of money. Some immigrants used coercion,threat,intimidation to scare local competitors,just google kedai pakistan illegal,read the comment too. Causing social problem. Some acquired quite the wealth and success. Like the pakistani dato hanif,who acquired the dato title from the malay royalty. Last year, kuala lumpur topped over all other cities,over abu dhabi,beijing as the city with the most millionaire. Malaysia is the hub of the Islamic world banking,muslim banksters. Also the second majority by race is chinese,many who are great businessman,entrepenuer and traders,like the sugar king,robert kuok and owner of shangri la hotel chain,jho low etc. Malaysia might also been trying to save them from revenge killing by myanmar nationals in malaysia,just google penang myanmar murders and you see what i meant,even if the goverment take them in,malaysia might be not that safe anymore for them,among the reason the goverment is reluctant to receive them.

Posted by malaysianpov on May 17, 2015 23:28

gravatar

and Aung San Suu Kyi is Silent As Rohingya Crisis Worsens

Posted by mike on May 17, 2015 23:51

gravatar

First save the vulnerable boat people and provide temporary shelter .Waiting the response from heartless government of Burma is killing valuable times. The humanitarian crisis should be finish within weeks if Burma killers government announce to return all the STEALING RIGHTS OF ROHINGYAS .Please bring all floating boat people to the shore first .We are ardently requesting to the powerful country to come forward for the help of nearly dying boat people immediately .Boat people die around the clock .We don't like to blame any neighboring countries except the Refugees and IDP producer Burma.

Posted by Maung Kyaw Nu,BRAT on May 18, 2015 03:09

gravatar

I always wonder why life is considered so cheap in (South East) Asia.

It must be a perfect storm of culture, overcrowding, ignorance, corruption and God knows what else..

Whatever the ingredients - it's a toxic brew..

Posted by farang888 on May 18, 2015 05:41

gravatar

do you know malaysia had saved how many thousands of rohingya before this?they had communities here,some for generations,not just rohingya muslims,but the karen tribe,palestinian and others too,and why the goverment is now reluctant?illegal immigrants,some faking as refugees then steal jobs from the poorer malaysian,steal the local woman hands in marriage to manipulate them for permanent residence status,this despite having a shelter and food provided.if you helped someone,but they take your things without permission,flirt with your daughter,wouldnt you be reluctant too,and there are 2 others that can help them.not saying immigrants are all crooks,but some of them do act as such,rohingyas are highly religious,the reason local woman are attracted to them,local men are not that religious,but you could see another problem here.religious fanatism.

Posted by malaysian on May 18, 2015 10:57

Editor Comment:

There is nothing to indicate the Rohingya are fanatics. Quite the opposite.

gravatar

"Editor Comment:

There is nothing to indicate the Rohingya are fanatics. Quite the opposite."

My understanding of the comment by malaysian(pov) was that the local Malaysian women were the "religious fanatics" and were attracted to the "more religious" Rohingya Muslims.

But maybe I got it round the wrong way.

Posted by Smithy on May 18, 2015 14:46

Editor Comment:

''rohingyas are highly religious,the reason local woman are attracted to them,local men are not that religious,but you could see another problem here.religious fanatism.''

Yes, you did.


Monday November 25, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter