The selection of full-moon party destination Koh Phangan, near Samui in the Gulf of Thailand, probably says more about the habits of some readers of TripAdvisor than reflects a genuine ''Top 25'' candidate.
However, the Trip Advisor site is a powerful source for research by travellers and its selection of ''World's Best beaches for 2011 as chosen by millions of travellers'' is bound to affect the choices of thousands of beach holiday customers.
Anyone who has compared Phangan with the best beaches of Phuket and the Andaman is unlikely to vote for Phangan - unless they are under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Bali also misses out, along with most of Asia and all of Australia.
The beaches closer to the top of the list may be a more accurate reflection of the best the world has to offer in terms of sun, sand and sea - but from a perspective that seems skewed towards American travel destinations.
Here's what TripAdvisor says:
''Inhabited since the year 1000, Aruba is an island rich in history and culture. Eagle Beach is an idyllic Caribbean beach, with white sands and turquoise waters.'' Palm/Eagle beach, Aruba, at number three.
''At only 4.5 miles long, Boracay is small enough to navigate by rented bicycle or motorbike. But don't let its small size fool you'' Boracay, Philippines, ranks number two.
''White-sand beaches, calm clear water and a bountiful barrier reef make the Turks and Caicos island of Providenciales a hot spot for families, snorkelers and divers . . .'' the site says of Providenciales, in top spot.
Jamaica, Mexico, Florida and elsewhere along the US coast figure strongly in other picks.
Breaking News A giant pool beside Karon beach has been discussed as a possibility for the 'Kata Karon Heaven on Earth' project, to be announced on the weekend.
Phuket Giant Pool May Be Part of 'Heaven' Project
Phuket Hillside Restaurants Grow in Triplicate
Photo Album Sunsets on Phuket are so popular that bars and restaurants continue to be built to view them. Above Kata Noi beach, a new development is being constructed.
Phuket Hillside Restaurants Grow in Triplicate
Patong Guesthouse Can't Stop Disco Music
Latest A Patong disco continues to operate despite attempts by a neighboring guesthouse owner to have the music stopped and two appeals to local authorities.
Patong Guesthouse Can't Stop Disco Music
Phuket Helping Thai South Floods Victims
Latest Donors who give to help the victims of floods in southern Thailand may benefit from a stay at a leading Phuket resort under a scheme run by the Phuket Tourist Association.
Phuket Helping Thai South Floods Victims
Update: Phuket Standoff as Taxis Blockade Cruise Liner
Photo Album/UPDATE Local Phuket taxi drivers take the law into their own hands and again blockade cruise liner passengers as Phuket's public transport crisis escalates.
Update: Phuket Standoff as Taxis Blockade Cruise Liner
Why would a Phuket Beach be even CONSIDERED in the world's top 100?
Ocean litter. Drains and filthy klongs emptying directly into the sea.Ripoffs and greed.Beach-chair congestion.Loss of natural environment. Eye and ear infections in sour water.Over-development and lack of access to public beaches.Parking hassels with businesses and Tuk-Tuks who "own" positions nearby.
Need I go on!!??!
Posted by Hugh Jarse on April 7, 2011 12:31