Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Persuasion not violence will put airport bus services on Phuket's roads

Phuket Tuk-Tuk, Taxi Drivers Must Be Won Over by Logical Persuasion

Sunday, November 13, 2011
News Analysis

PHUKET: A decision about whether Phuket will gain bus services from Phuket International Airport to the west coast beaches and the island's south will be made in Bangkok, and probably announced in February.

Phuket Transport Director Terayout Prasertphol made it plain yesterday that the solution to Phuket's transport needs is still some time off, that a lot of work still needs to be done, and that the real answer lies with a collective approach.

Once Bangkok approves the request from Phuket for two new bus routes - one from Phuket airport through Surin, Kamala and Patong, and the other from Phuket airport to Chalong Circle and Rawai - the process of seeking a bus service operator can begin.

There will be no buses running with armed guards, and no special request to Phuket's Police Commander, Major General Pekad Tantipong, to somehow ensure the buses and their passengers arrive safely.

If all goes well, the new Phuket bus services could be operating about this time next year. As everyone knows, a few obstacles have to be overcome first.

One of the biggest obstacles is the lack of a master strategy for Phuket public transport.

It may come as news to readers that the first survey of Phuket's transport needs by consultants reported that no light rail link was necessary between Phuket International Airport and Phuket City.

Why not? Well, it's unnecessary, the consultants said. Phuket people already all have their own transport, therefore, no need for public transport

The link between the high number of people killed and maimed on their own motorcycles and the safe alternative offered by public transport appeared to have escaped these ''experts''.

Phuket is killing and maiming its children in large numbers, largely thanks to the selfish and thoughtless monopoly of the tuk-tuk and local taxi drivers.

Phuketwan reckons that each and every one of the tuk-tuk and taxi drivers probably has a child, a relative or a friend who has died on a motorcycle.

Almost certainly, all of them know people who have been seriously maimed or crippled for life, because riding a motorcycle on Phuket is always dangerous.

Who is to blame for this sad carnage? Some of the blame surely rests with the tuk-tuk and taxi drivers.

They charge extortionate rates that residents cannot afford, and yet they refuse to accept that Phuket needs modern, efficient alternatives.

The public transport debate is not just about the future of tourism and sensible transport alternatives but also about the simple cost of old and young lives, especially the lives of the children of Phuket.

Phuket Transport Director Terayout is right when he says that fingers should not be pointed at him or at Phuket Police Commander Pekad to somehow take responsibility for solving this problem.

It's everybody's problem, and that includes the tuk-tuk and taxi drivers.

The tuk-tuk and local taxi drivers have to be persuaded that the time has come to cast off their shallow selfishness for the good of Phuket.

What Phuket needs as well as a bus service to the popular Phuket beaches and Phuket's south is a taxi service that meets international standards, a service that provides metered taxis to anywhere on the island through a single call centre, a service that delivers good standards at reasonable fares.

Between now and February, when the two new bus routes are likely to be approved, Phuket's leaders across every field should begin the process of change by doing something they don't usually do - talk to each other.

Once the leaders of Phuket have formulated a plan, then they need to start talking to the tuk-tuk and taxi drivers.

It's time to stop ducking for cover. It's time to stop pointing the finger and saying: ''This is your job (ie, not mine).''

Talk to the tuk-tuk and taxi drivers.

Remind them that Phuket's future rests on stopping the needless deaths and the crippling. Phuket's future rests on providing safe and inexpensive alternatives.

Remind them too that any island where driving a vehicle is among the best-paid jobs distorts and ignores the logic that people with an education and real skills deserve to be paid a whole lot more than humble taxi drivers.

Should the drivers be encouraging their children to get to school safely in a bus, to study to be doctors or teachers?

Or is the message they want to keep sending to the youth of Phuket - those that manage to avoid being killed or maimed - all about aspiring to be an overpaid, underworked taxi driver?

In the broader context, Phuket needs an overall transport strategy that delivers a safe island-wide network of buses and metered taxis.

The worst outcome would be for the long-awaited Phuket International Airport extension to go ahead, without sensible provision for buses. The worst outcome would be for nothing to change.

The time is right now for a period of intelligent persuasion to begin. The time is right now to bring the drivers in from the cold, and achieve a consensus.

Phuket has until February.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Talk to the tuk tuk drivers!!!! Why??? This has been tried over and over. Nothing has come about.

The proper solution is public transportation all through out island. Allowing choices.

Why does anyone need approval from the tuk tuks?

I still firmly believe the consulates need to put a travel warning out to all its citizens. The consuls have said they would. Consuls your hand has been called!!!

Put the warning out. When you see results and action and not more lip service then you can retract the warning.

Posted by john s on November 13, 2011 13:00

Editor Comment:

Red-neck reaction, john s. To do what? The aim is not to scare the tourists away. The aim is to find a peaceful solution.

gravatar

Simply mind-boggling nonsense from these consultants, though i do actually agree with Phuket NOT needing a light-rail system. It would take years if not decades to build. A thorough and reliable bus service, including routes that no light rail system would go near, could be up and running in a matter of months at a fraction of the price and benefiting far more people. K. Paiboon and his pink buses seem to be working well in town. Come on guys. No need to even consider the tuk-tuk jokers in this decision. The tuk-tuk cartels ALLOW illegal black-plate taxis to ply for trade, not noticing the blindingly obvious fact that THEY are STEALING trade from legitimate tuk-tuks and taxis. When and if the taxi cartels get their own houses in order should the powers-that-be consider consulting them on public transportation policy. Until then, bring on the buses!

Posted by Mr Man on November 13, 2011 13:49

gravatar

A lot of good points here, but debate with the tuk-tuk drivers - they have already proven several times how they want to contribute to the welfare of society here, why should suddenly change that attitude?

Posted by Sherlock on November 13, 2011 15:08

Editor Comment:

If they are told why they have to change their attitude, by a Deputy Prime Minster perhaps, along with a General or two, then they may see the light. But the effort does need to be made. Nobody is suggesting further debate.

gravatar

I would rather use the 1960's 'NAM T-Shirt Moto of " Let us win your hearts and minds OR we'll burn your huts down".
That's my 2 quarters worth of saying.

Posted by Robin on November 13, 2011 18:34

gravatar

John is right. It is up to the authorities to plan transport service to the benefit of society. There is no need for approval of tuk tuks or others who take advance of the current situation.

Posted by sherlock on November 13, 2011 20:31

Editor Comment:

Any action without an attempt first at ''logical persuasion'' with the drivers will lead to violence. Some commenters seem to prefer this. Those of us who are seriously concerned about the island's future would rather avoid any obvious confrontation. So would most peace-loving Phuketians, both residents and expats.

gravatar

No where else in Thailand does this madness go on with tuk tuks.
The local govenment officials will not do their jobs and enforce the law and look out for the best interests of all the people of Phuket. The public officials need to look at themselves in the mirror.
The tuk tuk drivers don't care whats good for Phuket. They care whats good for them only.
The hotel,resturants, bar, tour company, owners and workers need to put hard pressure on the government officials.If the government officials can't or won't do their jobs, then they need to be fired.
The tuk tuks are hurting everyone on Phuket.
This is not hard problem to fix. Put people in jail for a long time if they break the law and impound their tuk tuks.
Sadly Thailand has very few good honest leaders.

Posted by Billy on November 13, 2011 22:17

gravatar

Phuket Transport Director Terayout is right when he says that fingers should not be pointed at him or at Phuket Police Commander Pekad to somehow take responsibility for solving this problem.


Pray tell me why he is right !!

Sorry but that is just laughable. I think you'll find the primary job of the police in most countries is to uphold the law, something in which it has failed time and time again to do with the tuk tuks and taxis.

Posted by Spam on November 13, 2011 22:50

gravatar

Police should do their job and enforce the law, if they refuse, then the Governor should ask for Major General Pekad Tantipong to resign, I am sure the new police commander will see things change quickly, or he to will be replaced.

Posted by Laurie Howells on November 15, 2011 10:52

Editor Comment:

Laurie, the numbers speak for themselves: 1100 police, more than 5000 tuk-tuk and taxi drivers. The problem has been on Phuket for many years before Major General Pekad arrived. A new police commander will face the same predicament, and realise that confrontation and violence should be avoided - always. Much better to solve the issue by logical persuasion.

gravatar

A light rail system would be the go, on the ground though not elevated, very quick to build.

Posted by coxo on November 15, 2011 12:24

gravatar

I will never visit Phuket again. I dislike phuket taxi drivers so much. Rude, insolent, dangerous and ultra expensive with very poor service. Visit Malayisa, much nicer

Posted by tuked off on November 15, 2011 23:37


Friday April 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter