Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

John Cohen is questioned about the shooting after his arrest in Patong

Phuket Shooting: Patong Police Face Heat Over Disappearing Charge Against Aussies

Sunday, May 11, 2014
PHUKET: Police on Phuket who failed to provide evidence linking two Australians to a shooting in Patong are likely to face dereliction of duty counts and possibly further serious charges, an investigating officer says.

Colonel Pravesana Mulpramook, Secretary-General of the Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission, told Phuketwan that officers from Kathu Police Station had failed to present ''substantial evidence'' to the Phuket prosecutor over the widely reported case.

Australians John Cohen and Mark Shea allegedly fired a handgun at a person they thought was a Danish man, Dennis Knudsen, riding past on a motorcycle taxi in January last year in Patong's Soi Sansabai.

The shots hit two German tourists instead, inflicting wounds.

''The police investigators failed to provide the prosecutor with evidence from witnesses or all of the security camera footage,'' Colonel Pravesana said. ''As a result, the Australians were only charged with possession of an unlicenced firearm in public, not attempted murder.''

In April 2013, Cohen and Shea had jail sentences of six-and-a-half months and six months suspended for two years, and were ordered to pay fines of 7500 baht and 7000 baht respectively.

''The accounts of witnesses and other security camera footage told a more complete story to what was presented in court,'' Colonel Pravesana said yesterday.

''The witnesses' statements and the security camera footage was not presented by the police. There is a clear difference between what happened and what was portrayed in court.

''We have accepted the case. It appears the investigating officers did not do their jobs.''

Colonel Pravesana said the police involved will now be interviewed. PACC officials expected to have a summary of the case prepared and ready to present sometime between the end of May and mid-June.

He did not say whether, if the charge of dereliction of duty was upheld against the police, charges of attempted murder would then be pursued against Cohen and Shea.

Colonel Pravesana said that the Australian embassy initiated the examination of the case by complaining to the PACC. Ambassador James Wise is on record as saying he would like authorities on Phuket to remove all guns and knives from the holiday island.

Former Australian honorary consul for Phuket, Larry Cunningham, who retired in September last year and has yet to be replaced, told Phuketwan yesterday that he only knew what had been reported in the media about the case.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Why did the Aussies have to tell the Thais to investigate it when the outcome was widely reported in the Media?

Posted by geoff on May 13, 2014 10:03

gravatar

My comment was deleted? moderated? Sure I did speculate "why" the evidence was conveniently not presented.....I guess that's NOT allowed?? but the rest of my post was poignant and timely so why delete-moderate-edit that?

Tom

Posted by Tom on May 13, 2014 10:51

Editor Comment:

Anonymous claims have no value in law, even if ''everybody knows.'' If you have evidence of corruption, please take it to the appropriate authorities. Best not to say anything that you can't prove. We have to obey the law just as you expect others to obey the law.

gravatar

Tom, rest assured, you are not alone when it comes to Ed's moderating, but his own comment is also misleading, he won't always publish evidence given, especially if it contradicts his own opinion/beliefs. Freedom of speech... lol forget it. Even in law you are entitled to your opinion, just don't state it as fact.

Posted by Laurie Howells on May 13, 2014 11:24

Editor Comment:

Your guesswork is worthless, Laurie. So, for that matter, are your online manners. Voltaire is a hero of mine. You are not. Voltaire understood the concept of free speech. You do not. In law just about everywhere, you are not entitled to make allegations that you can't prove, and in some places, even if you can prove it, you still can't say it. You are entitled to your opinion, but once you try to publish it on this site, you actually have to start thinking first.

gravatar

At least the Germans were not charged for body bullet thieving.

Posted by Lena on May 13, 2014 12:57

gravatar

ED: comment noted and I understand and appreciate that in this current light making "accusations" that are published can be liable....as you are sorely aware "Freedom of Speech" has its price.
Its such a difficult line to tread especially when we see so much blatant corruption and are pretty much powerless to do anything about it. You guys are on the front lines of this and are facing criminal action because of it. I wouldn't want to jeopardise PW's ability to report the truth by posting my personal theories or suppositions. I've been following this story since the beginning and all I know is that it STINKS from top to bottom !

Tom

Posted by Tom on May 13, 2014 13:38

gravatar

Ed, I have never considered myself to be your friend, as I am sure I do not wish to be a friend of yours. You now accuse me of guess work.. well Ed, when faced with the truth, you still refuse to publish it, re: powers and responsibilities of the governor, you, I'm afraid, have lost credibility. As I have said before, karma, is a very funny thing.

Posted by Laurie Howells on May 13, 2014 15:29

Editor Comment:

There is nothing funny about karma either, Laurie. But then you seem to have the capacity to laugh in all the wrong places. The governor seems to be your scapegoat for all the ills that assail the island, and that's pure guesswork on your part.

gravatar

anybody ever come up on these charges or just swept under the carpet??

Posted by another steve on March 11, 2015 18:38


Saturday November 30, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter