Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Are jet-skis banned from Phuket's beach sands or not?

Phuket Private Meeting to be Held With Beaches Decision in the Balance

Wednesday, August 19, 2015
PHUKET: An important review by a university of what the various stakeholders want for Phuket's beaches is to be handed to the Governor of Phuket in a private meeting this week, Phuketwan has learned.

The stakeholder survey by the island's Prince of Songkhla University was originally scheduled to be disclosed at a meeting with other interested officials on Thursday.

However, the results of the investigation will now be conveyed to the governor at a private meeting on Friday, Phuketwan has been told.

The future of Phuket's beaches has been debated since sunbeds and most other commerce were cleared from the sands soon after the military took control of Thailand on May 22 last year.

Even sunbeds, beach chairs and umbrellas that sun-loving tourists bring themselves have remained banned.

To placate beach vendors and find a compromise, Governor Nisit Jansomwong created a scheme where 10 percent of all of Phuket's beaches could be used for mats and umbrellas and commercial services.

However, a visit this week by a Phuketwan journalist to Phuket's main beach at Patong showed umbrellas scattered along the beachfront - and jet-skis beached on the sand.

Despite the ban on commercial activities at all Phuket beaches, jet-skis have been given greater space along the Patong beachfront.

The noisy, polluting machines are supposed to be banned from the sand - but it appears that is no longer the case.

Local council municipal authorities - especially in Patong - have said it is beyond their capacity to enforce the governor's suggestion of giving just 10 percent of beaches over to commercial activity.

All commercial activity is supposed to be banned on public beaches - the reason why the military cleared the sands and the foreshores of vendors and illegal restaurants and beach clubs in the first place.

Phuketwan believes the banning of commercial activities on Phuket's beaches is a good idea that gives the island a chance of being seen by tourists as a ''natural'' destination.

But that is not likely to happen if scores of jet-skis are still allowed to operate.

Locals at Patong say the jet-ski operators control the beachfront and do as they please.

Jet-skis, however, have for a long time been banned in Phuket's neighboring provinces of Phang Nga and Krabi, where tourist numbers are increasing.

Meanwhile, without sunbeds, elderly European tourists still complain about being banned from bringing their own beach chairs and umbrellas.

Officials appear to have listened much more carefully to the views of local beach businesspeople, and less carefully to the desires or the tourists - the customers who actually bring the money to Phuket.

Most of the world's best-known beach destinations do not ban tourists from bringing their own equipment.

A decision by Governor Nisit could draw European tourists back to Phuket or turn greater numbers of them away.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

First the study was "delayed", possibly because the outcome was not favorable. Now it's being presented privately only to the person who came up with the 10% idea.

Have the opinions of beach users suddenly become a state secret ?

Why not publish the study in public for everyone to read ?

After all, there are not many people on Phuket, residents or visitors, who's lives are not impacted one way or another by what happens on and to the beaches.

Posted by Herbert on August 19, 2015 23:59

gravatar

You made your point. You hate sunbeds. Accept that a lot people likes them very much.

Posted by beach on August 20, 2015 04:27

Editor Comment:

If you are talking to me, I don't ''hate'' sunbeds. What's to ''hate'' about a sunbed? Sunlovers should be free to bring their own. But the law clearly bans commercial activities on the beach. And for a very long time, that law was broken. I see no reason now why it should be ''10 percent broken.''

gravatar

Certainly the beaches should remain untouched by commercialisation. It is by far the last reminance of the 'paradise' Phuket we all remember, and enjoy.

Posted by reader on August 20, 2015 11:07

gravatar

Doing this is private will only add to the speculation of the real motives behind what the report will say.

Such a shame that certain people in Thailand still believe that hiding is the best policy (like the road casualties information for example).

Hopefully one day Openess will be the best policy.

Posted by Discover Thainess on August 20, 2015 13:18

gravatar

The sunbeds were the "natural" of the Phuket beaches, all this about "bring their own" will not make it more attractive to come back once the tourist, has found other destinations!

Posted by yoki on August 20, 2015 14:06

gravatar

I always thought that a publicly funded study would be, well, public.

Posted by Herbert on August 20, 2015 15:39

gravatar

Sun beds are a necesity, for people like me, old and disabled, I cannot lie on the beach like a young backpacker.
Parasols are a necessity, for people like me, with skin cancer and others who wish to prevent skin cancer.
Jet skis are just a noise, air and water polluting pain in the posterior!

Posted by Sandy Shores on August 21, 2015 10:58

Editor Comment:

You have skin cancer, and you go to the beach, Sandy? What does your specialist say about that?

gravatar

PROBED fraction,just FYI:

the official Centara Krabi picture of sunbeds,actually of the lack thereof,on beaches of Krabi:

https://twitter.com/MyCentara/status/634634985325006848

Where you go to whine about sunbeds,to swimming pools of Bali,where there are no swimming beaches,or to nicely furnished,so far,fabulios beaches of Pattaya..?

The reason why sunbeds can't be on Phuket beaches is that there are simply too many tourists nowadays in Phuket, who goes to a beach.
Khun Paying Mayor brought her own calculation on an occasion of declaration of 10% zone - which bears certainly downward risknof assessment of a number of beachgoers - those figures showed that if every beachgoer on Patong would be given a sunbed,you would need to cover a beach twice.

So,if you are one who creates that problem - by appearing in person on Phuket beaches,then don't expect that you would have sunbed.

Ratio legis(a goal of the law) of that legal norm that prohibits commercial activity on the beach,naturally civer s now also ecological aspects of preserving Phuket beaches from mechanical overuse - even if orginial ratio legis of that law didn't cover that - it is natural that laws and their interpretations develops over the time,along with development of society,incl.new socioeconomic facts on number of tourists.

Greetings from PROSAND!

Posted by Sue on August 21, 2015 15:33

gravatar

The 10% idea IMO was rubbish to begin with. Now a possible loss of face forces a private discussion & no doubt decision (probably another compromise). Why not give tourists what they want? After all it can't be any worse what with the jet-skis & parasails already @ Patong in particular. Let's face it, commercial biz will ALWAYS be here, whether on the beaches or in the streets. If the laws aren't enforced, then "Mai bpen rai" rules. Allowing jet-skis etc 10% of the beach & tourists 90% would have been a simpler answer surely! (BTW, like your legal jargon Sue!)

Posted by Sue Yu on August 21, 2015 17:01

Editor Comment:

''Why not give tourists what they want?''

Because that would be against the law, and not in the best interests of the people of Thailand. The beaches are public. They belong to all Thai citizens, not just a greedy few. The best beaches in the world don't ''give the tourists what they want.''

The jet-skis are a separate issue. Like Phang Nga and Krabi, Phuket should ban them.

gravatar

Sue,
what is a "probed fraction"? It sounds painful!

If the mayor used calculations as you have stated she needs you to advise her of the definitions of 'diversity' and 'transient' as a situation never exists where people having the same interest are engaged in it at the exact same time.

Second thought, better if you dont try to explain this to her.

Posted by MoW on August 21, 2015 19:02

gravatar

When I said "tourists" I was also including Thais. Why not? There should be no discrimination between locals & foreigners but I fear that this will never be the case. The discrimination firstly comes from the Thais themselves as they are taught from an early age to treat foreigners as outsiders. Until this mindset changes there can never be a proper solution in my opinion.

Posted by Sue Yu on August 22, 2015 03:00

gravatar

Against the law? Which law? Is there in Khao Lak a law different from Phuket? Or in Pattay, or in Hua Hin?

Posted by beach on August 22, 2015 05:12

Editor Comment:

It's against the law to use Thailand's public beaches for private profit. Whatever the outcome on Phuket, it's likely to become a ''Phuket model'' for use elsewhere in Thailand. The problem is the compromise that means the law can be broken on 10 percent of every beach.

gravatar

Yes Ed, I have a mild form of skin cancer. What do you expect me to do live in a box? I always use sunscreen when outdoors. This is why we need the parasols, this is why at present I do not go to the beach!

Posted by Sandy Shores on August 22, 2015 08:53

gravatar

@ Sandy Shores, I hope you attended the excellent seminar on Skin Cancer at the Bangkok Hospital Phuket yesterday? You would have learnt a lot from it. You are not missing much by not going into the sun here.

Posted by Robin on August 22, 2015 13:09


Sunday November 24, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter