Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Sunbed heaven at Paradise: It's on a private Phuket property

Paradise on Phuket Comes at a Price, But It Does Have Sunbeds

Wednesday, July 30, 2014
PHUKET: A line of sunbeds on Phuket's Paradise beach appears to be among the last of its kind following the island's beach clearances - but the sunbeds are actually on private property.

Is this Paradise lost, or Paradise regained?

Free access to all of Thailand's public beaches - mandatory throughout the country - became an issue yesterday at the small but popular beach, south of Patong.

Because the beach is backed by a private property, to get to the beach you can either arrive by sea, as some people do from Patong, or come through the property owned by Amphean Theanthin.

You will be charged 100 baht. This is not for entry, which is free, but for a sunbed.

What if all the sunbeds are taken? Then the fee is for use of the excellent toilet and shower facilities.

What if you don't want to use the shower and toilet? Er . . .

Paradise Beach appears to have been regained by the National Peace and Order Council and cleared properly of sunbeds and umbrellas, which are now banned.

The row now sits back on private property, so the 100 baht fee is also permissible. But the beach, just a few metres away, is supposed to be free . . .

All the so-called ''private'' beaches on Phuket are supposed to be accessible even if backed by a large, intimidating resort.

Some resorts obey the law and make sure there's access to members of the public.

Others avoid the issue, and it's probably only a matter of time before the NCPO gets around to making sure that all people have access to all beaches.

In the past, disputes have reached courts.

There's a roadway that actually passes beneath the Royal Phuket Yacht Club building at Nai Harn so people can get to tiny Ao Sane beach, illustrating the historic nature of this struggle.

Paradise Beach owner Khun Amphean charges 100 baht and also asks for a parking fee for vehicles.

He told Phuketwan back in 2008 that he grew up on Paradise and wants to preserve it as it is, not sell out to some resort.

''I am like a pier,'' Khun Amphean said. ''Businessmen who come to Phuket are like boats. They go everywhere and stop in the places that make them rich.

''But that's not for me. I'm a local person. I was born here and one thing is for sure, I'm going to die here. So I have to stand by my island. I do everything because it's my home.''

Paradise appears to be a good place to do business and, with its good facilities and a restaurant, attracts more and more tourists.

Down the road at TriTrang beach, the ''owner'' of the Windsurf restaurant at the southern end was given three days to remove all internal equipment and ordered to be demolished within 10 days.

He signed an agreement with the Kathu Police Superintendent, an Army representative and the Patong council lawyer.

Another signature was added to another document when the clearance force moved up the beach to the large TriTrang Restaurant, where the owner also signed off.

He had previously told officials that if his restaurant was doomed, then whatever construction lay behind a large section of corrugated green screen should be moved off the beach, too.

However, with the green screen gone, it was revealed yesterday that the resort under construction appears to be well back from the high tide mark.

The beaches of Phuket are rapidly changing but with his rare row of sunbeds and his attitude to life, Khun Amphean is bound to attract more strangers to Paradise.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

I had exactly the same argument on Paradise Beach many years back when I drove there in my car with my friend to dive off that beach.

I was told I have to pay to use the sunbeds, which I said I'm not going to. Then the tack switched to charging for showers and toilets, which I said I'm not going to use either.

Finally she tried to charge me for parking, at which point I drove my car off the property and walked back.

The lady who appeared to be in charge was irate and abusive but we stood our ground and had a very nice dive.

The stupid thing is if she had not immediately attacked us with demands for fees, we would have been more than happy to shower, sit and eat there too after our dive and pay for it all.

Instead we never went back.

Posted by ThaiMike on July 30, 2014 09:07

gravatar

This was the same scenario at Laem Sing Beach. Charged to park at the side of the (public) road or have your tires slashed then allowed to transit private property down to the Beach. The tax/taxi hut has disappeared at the moment though I'm sure some sort of entry tax is being applied. Another one of Phuket's Pearls eaten away by greed.

Posted by Mister Ree on July 30, 2014 09:29

gravatar

I often go to paradise for lunch. Never had to pay for parking or entry fee, just smile and say we have come to eat when passing through the gate. Can always use the loungers as well. It's all very friendly as long as you are friendly first in my experience.

Food portions are a bit small for the price though in my experience, but they do serve the rice in little bear shapes which amuses my other half.

Posted by Amazing thailand on July 30, 2014 09:55

gravatar

100 baht is about $3.00 US. It that a big deal to a Westerner expat or a tourist. I think not. I happy Paradise found away around the sun bed issue. Nothing like laying out reading a book. with a coconut, and a beautiful beach. That road used to dirt and now it is paved quit you bitching.

Posted by capealava on July 30, 2014 11:03

gravatar

- Amazing Thailand

You are comparing apples with oranges. You came there to eat at their restaurant, which sits on property they own.

We came to dive off a public beach but were met with aggressive demands to pay all sorts of fees the moment I opened my car door.

Surely you are smart enough to tell the difference.

It had nothing to do with us being friendly or polite. If anything, her demeanor was very confrontational.

Posted by ThaiMike on July 30, 2014 11:39

gravatar

May the Thai army provides the same energy to tear down all large resorts owned by influential people and encroaching inside Sirinath national Park; then we will say they are sincere to crackdown on illegal businesses in Phuket.

Posted by Whistle-Blower on July 30, 2014 12:44

Editor Comment:

If the evidence is there, WB. Otherwise it's just another lynch mob.

gravatar

@capealava obviously you have to much money remember some people have saved money for a long time for there holiday too thailand so I'm sure 100baht is a big deal to them.

Posted by Andrew wattson on July 30, 2014 12:59

gravatar

If they are allowed to charge for access to Paradise Beach, then ALL resorts that block or have limited access to the beach should also be abke to block or charge for access to the beach.

Of course that would be counter intuitive to the law that states all beaches are public and access must be given to the public.

If the parking or road is an issue, then the public should have walking access without a fee.

The government should inspect where the sewage from the toilets is discharged. Also, the Revenue Department should ensure that taxes are being paid on the admission and restaurant sales. If the owner truly is for a better Phuket he will have no problem paying the taxes to help support the government and community (schools, roads, police, etc.)

Posted by Tyler on July 30, 2014 13:13

gravatar

I love they are cleaning up the beaches but not sure why people are upset about paradise beach charging to go through their property. They have every right to close their property and not let anyone in. The fact they are asking for 100 THB per person is very nice. The road is a private road, not public. What they should do is charge at the gate so that people understand it is private property. You go to any developed country and park near the beach and dive and they charge you. I agree with Capealava. If it was pubilc land then I would have an issue if blocked. The easy thing is if it is illegal then we will know very quickly.

Posted by jiminkata on July 30, 2014 13:31

gravatar

I don't think there will ever be agreement on some of these matters. I love Paradise Beach and am happy to pay THB100 to be there. I will let others determine the legal side and am happy to adhere to whatever is fair. Think I may need to get there early to get a sunbed though. On the fee, can't you arrive by water, which would cost a lot more for a long tail anyway? As I said I doubt there will ever be agreement.

Posted by Davemc60 on July 30, 2014 13:33

gravatar

It is his property. He put in paved road and has a restaurant. It hard for me to understand you complainers concerning Paradise Beach. In the USA if someone owns the access he can regrets a few bucks. Actually I commend the guy for putting in the road. Ok take boat how much will that cost you more than 100 baht. How much did the airfare cost you to come here??

Posted by capealava on July 30, 2014 14:16

gravatar

There's a couple of things people forget here.

First of all Thai law stipulates that public access must be provided to all beaches for free, even if surrounded by private property.

All land 40m inland from high tide mark is public.

He has no legal right to charge admission to cross land he controls to access the beach. He circumvents this by claiming the charge is for sunbeds or other facilities.

Secondly a representative of K. Amphean family - K. Amtien reveals in another interview that they have actually rented the land (3 Rai) around the beach for Bt 5000 per month which is supposed to be SorKor 1 land.

He was unable to produce the title and refused to reveal who the real owner is.

Investigation into the legality of such a title is ongoing.

There's a lot more to this than meets the eye.

- capealava

You are quite obviously a tourist who views issues here through rose-tinted glasses.

Things rarely are as they appear to be at first glance in Thailand.

You comparisons to the US are without any merit since Thailand is not the 51st State.

You pull an even more ridiculous comment by asking what the airfare cost to get here.

Posted by ThaiMike on July 30, 2014 15:21

gravatar

For those posters that are sticking up for Paradise Beach being able to charge 100 ??? access fee, please note: "Free access to all of Thailand's public beaches is mandatory throughout the country." As for capealava's assertion about the USA, try to restrict public access to a beach in California and you will end up in court! It has been tried by the very wealthy and they lose every time!

Posted by Jim McGowan on July 30, 2014 15:43

gravatar

- jiminkata

You could not possibly be more wrong.
Not a single statement you made was even remotely correct.

Not only does he NOT have the right to "close the property and not let anyone in" but by law he is OBLIGATED to provide free, public access to the beach, which has to be clearly signposted.

Obviously there are countless activities in breach of the laws ongoing on Phuket and this is just one of them.

Perhaps you don't consider the US to be a developed country but your claim of being charged for beach access, regardless of recreational activity, is just total rubbish.

As Jim McGovan already pointed out, you could not be further from the truth. Even more striking than in California is this subject in Hawai'i where countless beachfront properties owned by the superrich have tried and failed to block such access.

Posted by ThaiMike on July 30, 2014 16:42

gravatar

We tried to go ashore there from a boat we had chartered from Boat Lagoon. This man's staff prevented us wading ashore and threatened to become physically violent.

Posted by Barry on July 30, 2014 17:02

gravatar

McGovern. I know about that case in California. Yes he would not let anyone in. Is Paradise restricting the beach ??? No. The surfers in California would probably pay a couple of bucks to go to that beach. The owner did not give that option. Looks like I am in the minority here. OH well off to my subbed at Pardise which I will gladly pay 100 baht AND THAIMIKE get off your horse I have been here for 13 years

Posted by capealava on July 30, 2014 18:13

Editor Comment:

capealava, don't let me interfere with your debate but when someone says ''I have been here for 13 years'' it has absolutely no meaning. Even if you've been here for just a week, the point is, can you tell right from wrong?

gravatar

Sometimes I think things get blown way out of perspective. I used to go to Paradise beach all the time and can't ever remember being charged any money.

Sure he charges for a sunbed but they cost money and some lackey has to put them out and take them back in daily.

His prices for food used to be extremely reasonable and I always found the people there friendly and easy going.

People here are getting bent out of shape about a guy who was just trying to earn a crust. 100 baht a sunbed isn't exactly gouging people either.

Putting in that road would of cost a lot and you couldn't even get there except by boat in the old days.

If people want to talk about being gouged I'll talk about the Melbourne airport. Up to 400 baht per hour for parking and 120 baht for a luggage trolley. The toll way to the airport is 150 baht to use just the city to airport link and about 400 baht to use the whole freeway.

Then you've got to get there without being caught on a speed camera or red light camera which will cost you anything up to 9000 baht.

Posted by Arun Muruga on July 30, 2014 19:56

Editor Comment:

I've been to Paradise - but not for a while. The car park was free back then. Surely everyone has to be allowed in, at no cost. That's what the law says.

And if later, they wish to use a sunbed, or the toilet block, then they should be charged at the point of usage, not at the entrance. Otherwise it's plainly a scam.

gravatar

Dear editor, I was responding to the remark of Thaimike. So butt out

Posted by capealava on July 30, 2014 20:49

Editor Comment:

Then follow convention and put @Thai Mike. Otherwise I will butt in.

gravatar

Dear Editor, Sorry for the sharp remark. But Thaimike's remark was idiotic. You should point that out. Do not bother posting my last to messages. I am done here with this subject. The Army controls everything anyway so why are we arguing.

Posted by capealava on July 30, 2014 21:11

Editor Comment:

Because we can?

gravatar

- Ed,
You have teased as I commented yesterday and proposed that the rental of sunbeds and umbrellas must be managed by the local Municipality by an e-receipt. The title of your article is the best response to your inappropriate response.

Posted by James on July 30, 2014 21:20

Editor Comment:

I didn't respond to your comment about receipts.

gravatar

- capealava

You may or may not be in minority but that's irrelevant. You are just plain dead wrong.

- Arun Muruga

You are twisting the facts. He is charging everyone Bt 100 regardless of if they wish to use his sunbeds, toilets or whatever else he has set up.

He cannot block or even try to control access to a public beach, no matter what his connection to the surrounding land is.

Since he went out to rent the adjacent land, he clearly had the intention to cash in on access to the beach.

In a rare moment of agreement with the Ed and me, he is spot on by stating the charges this man wishes to levy should be collected when facilities he provides are about to be used.

Btw, when my incident there happened, they were asking for Bt 200. This was maybe 7 years ago.

Out of curiosity I tried to enter the beach at Le Meridien Hotel around the same time asking for public access.

I was told it's only available if I purchase their daytime entertainment package for Bt 500. No specifics were forthcoming when I asked what does that include and why I cannot have the legally stipulated free, public access to the beach they are located at.

Would be interesting to know how they react today to such access requests.

Posted by ThaiMike on July 30, 2014 21:34

gravatar

Arun - just trying to earn his "crust"?!
Really? He is quoted in other news sources as claiming he pays 5,000 baht per month rent for the beach area.
In the high season there is easily 400+ people per day coming to Paradise Beach. That is 40,000 baht per day - 1.2 MILLION baht per month! That is some mighty good "crust".
That does not include the massive amount of income that is generated by the restaurant and rental center and shop. Seems like pure greed to me. They would make a very decent income just from the restaurant and rentals and shop.
I have personally watched them stop every person arriving at the front booth and refuse to even let them look at the beach or even just take a photo at the beach without paying 100 baht.

There is what looks like a government weather station on the hill above the beach, which must have access. I remember a long time back the dirt road/trail was the access point. It appears that they paved over it, which would mean that this should still be the public access.

A fair compromise for all would be to charge for parking on their private property. Access to the beach is free by passing to the right of the charge booth direct to the beach. Use of the toilets require payment or are included with a meal at the restaurant.

They will still make a small fortune off the restaurant, as it will be one of the last beachside restaurants on the island. Unless the Sorkor 1 is fake....

Posted by Tyler on July 30, 2014 22:19

gravatar

Hmm 100 Baht wow that really gets you bankrupt why dont we all swim around it :o) at least Thai people CLEAN THE BEACHES! like i do....

Posted by ThailandFan on July 30, 2014 23:10

gravatar

Has anybody tried using the beach at Le Meridian since the Crackdown? If so how do you enter this beach. It was wonderful years ago park bike at top of hill walk down to nice beach. But that trail long since grown over. Was never bothered by Le Meridian staff as we always stayed away from the paying customers..great beach

Posted by Jimmy B on July 31, 2014 04:59


Friday November 29, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter