Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Phuketwan covers human trafficking in Thailand and the journalists have said:  ''The Royal Thai Navy will have to kill us to stop us''

Insider's Perspective on Phuketwan Case

Wednesday, November 4, 2015
PHUKET: As many readers know, I have been an intern at Phuketwan for the past five weeks.

As part of my Master of Journalism studies at the University of Melbourne, students can elect to complete a month-long internship at a news agency of their choice.

I chose to come to Thailand and complete my internship at Phuketwan.

I had never met Alan Morison or Chutima Sidasathian before. They weren't my friends, my colleagues or my family.

I paid my own way: flights, accommodation, food and a hire car. The internship was unpaid.

Why would I do this when I could have taken a much easier path and stayed in my home town of Melbourne?

Well, it's quite simple really.

I wanted to work with a team of journalists who, through adversity and challenge, had already shown themselves to be the type of journalist that I aspire to be.

I wanted to learn about journalism, as it should be, not what it is often today.

For more than two years I have followed the Royal Thai Navy's prosecution of Alan and Chutima for criminal defamation and computer crimes offences.

As a former Australian Federal Police officer for almost 20 years, a police anti-corruption investigator for six years and an officer in the Australian Army Reserve for over 10 years, to say I was appalled by the actions of Thai Navy, police and Prosecutor's office, would be an understatement.

I was equally stunned by most of the Thai media's lack of interest in a case that clearly went to the heart of press freedom in this country.

In my time at Phuketwan I watched Alan and Chutima work relentlessly and passionately at least 14 hour days, every single day of the week, chasing and verifying stories, interviewing and challenging officials and writing stories that most of Phuket's other media outlets ignored, or refused to follow.

Both Alan and Chutima remained focused and dedicated to their work, never letting the uncertainty of the Navy's extended appeal period dampen their desire to report the news.

Then last Friday, when the Navy rang to tell Alan and Chutima they wouldn't be appealing the case, I watched as they looked at each other and smiled.

My words can never adequately describe the look of relief and joy on their faces.

Then yesterday, Alan and Chutima were told that the police had attended at their office and that the Prosecutor was seeking another extension to appeal their case.

I was confused and asked Alan if this was the same Prosecutor's office that hadn't bothered to turn up for two of the three days of their trial?

Yes, apparently so.

I don't know much about the Thai justice system. But in any country that professes a belief in justice, this case was wrong in the first instance, now it's just simply press persecution and abuse of the judicial process.

For the readers of Phuketwan this is, yet again, time to show your support for these two incredible journalists.

For the Thai media, especially the Phuket media: When will you finally show some courage, stand by your colleagues and actually start defending freedom of the press in this country?

*And for the cynical people out there that may be questioning my motives in writing this story: I've already passed my internship and nothing I write here changes that.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Excellent ..., Nice Words....

Posted by Robert on November 4, 2015 13:20

gravatar

As a fellow external observer, and operator within Victoria's justice system, it beggars belief that such basic standards of natural justice and freedom of expression are wantonly disregarded. Write on Phuketwan, and stay courageous.

Posted by Hugh on November 4, 2015 14:36

gravatar

Write on PW and fight.

Posted by Robin on November 4, 2015 16:09

gravatar

Hi Keryn

Great little story.

One could write volumes about the Thais' attitude to criminal defamation and free speech.

Best of luck for your career in journalism.

Cheers
Ian Yarwood
Solicitor
Perth, Western Australia

Posted by Ian Yarwood on November 4, 2015 16:17

gravatar

Excellent article about two exceptional people. Injustices, intolerance, must be reported or basic freedoms will be suppressed. Thank you PW and best of luck to all associated with PW in the future.

Posted by Leigh on November 4, 2015 17:03

gravatar

Hi Keryn and Ed

I noticed on Keryn's twitter that the Phuket Provincial Court actually granted a second extension of time in which to appeal - to 30 November 2015.

I chatted with Khun Chutima this afternoon to get a few more details.

She said that she found out today and that the judge made the decision on 2 November. She further confirmed that the Royal Thai Navy decided on 30 October 2015 that it did not wish to appeal.

Hope this all comes to a final, final, final end soon.

Cheers
Ian Yarwood

Posted by Ian Yarwood on November 4, 2015 17:24

gravatar

Excellent article Keryn, you guys (Chutima, Alan and you) are the type of journalists that make me want to read news everyday. Those journalists who report or write stories without being afraid to "disturb" some people and really CONGRATULATIONS for your work. I sincerely hope that the case will end soon and these 2 great journalists and persons (met them personally once) will finally be able to continue their great work (or just stop and enjoy life too). All the best to all of you and long live to PW.

Posted by Phuket119 on November 4, 2015 19:37

gravatar

Nice to know that people like Keryn are coming to journalism, late but with a lot of experience under the belt.I declare an interest because Alan's a friend of nearly 50 years standing (groan!), but the article captures his doggedness and sense of justice. He's lucky to have Chutima alongside. They're a team Australians and Thais should be be very proud of.

Posted by Rod Usher on November 7, 2015 02:09

gravatar

G'day Keryn.

I know where you're coming from mate. I'm still in the job (20 years) but will soon be retiring to Samui.

I've been watching the goings-on in Thailand for many years now and Alan an I have not seen eye-to-eye on a few issues but his committed actions on people smuggling and the subsequent opening up of the filth and corruption has really shown me how bad the "legal" structure is in Thailand.

I am right behind him and can only admire his tenacity.

The directions and investigations into this whole affair and the subsequent persecution of Alan and Chutima has horrified me - even to the final point that the associated judges still want to give an extra 30 days for appeal in a case that has been so completely buried by the defense.

What is the real reason for this? Certainly not a legal or morally justifiable one. How far does the embedded hatred of "farang" go? I see this everywhere I go.

National Parks entry - 20 baht. 200 baht for farangs.

Taxis who refuse to turn meters on for farangs Even if one negotiates a price first it is many time more than what a local pays - even to the point of a recent case of a tourist being beaten because the driver wanted more than the negotiated price.

Restaurants that have 2 menus - one for locals and one for farang.

It goes on and on - - - - - -

I have a wonderful partner on Samui who clearly knows what goes on. We shop together and see this "entrepreneurial opportunity" constantly applied until we jointly tackle it.

I only hope that Thai people will divest themselves of the belief that corruption and abuse of visitors to their beautiful country and learn that tourists can be a valuable asset.

All it will take is honesty and respect - - - -

Posted by Lenny Jones on November 7, 2015 08:59

Editor Comment:

You should note that a Thai and a non-Thai are both still awaiting the time for appeal to pass in the Phuketwan case, so there's no discrimination in the judicial system here. In the case of national parks, PW has often said there are good reasons why two prices should be charged. You will find all non-Thais are charged the higher price, not just ''farangs.'' Don't confuse double-pricing with opportunism. It's the same everywhere - tourists are gouged in Australia, you won't be surprised to learn, Lenny.


Saturday November 23, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter