Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Hannah Witheridge and David Miller: the Thai media says DNA matches

UPDATE Burmese DNA Matches With Thailand Murder Victims, Says Media

Friday, October 3, 2014
Updating All Day, Every Day

ABOUT 200 special police are to be used to keep angry residents away from the murder scene on Koh Tao while a Burmese witness to the killings - allegedly by two other Burmese - explains to officers what he saw that night. It's a reenactment of the kind usually conducted in Thailand.

Original Report

PHUKET: Thai media outlets claim today that the DNA of two Burmese matches DNA found on the bodies of murdered British tourists Hannah Witheridge and David Miller. Police have yet to confirm the claim.

Three Burmese are being held on the Thai holiday island of Koh Tao and are likely to be charged today if the reports emanating from several sources in Thailand prove true.

The Commander of the Royal Thai Police, General Somyos Pumpanmuang, has travelled to Koh Tao and is expected to announce today that investigators believe they have solved the September 15 murders.

Witheridge, 23, and Miller, 24, were savagely bludgeoned to death in a small rocky beach cove.

Since the discovery of their bodies, police have pursued several fruitless leads and only days ago focused on the three Burmese.

Named today in the Thai media were Win, 21, Sor, 21, who worked at a pub bar restaurant on the holiday island and Mao, 23. Win was arrested on the mainland in Surat Thani town. Sor and Mao were held on Koh Tao.

Win has allegedly confessed to the killings. He has allegedly told police, according to the Thai media, that he saw the British couple making love.

According to Thai PBS, the other two Burmese have also subsequently confessed.

The Burmese were being questioned extensively yesterday and migrant worker activists fear any confessions could have been extracted under duress.

Mao told police he was playing a guitar under a tamarind tree on the night of the murders. He said a butt found near the bodies was from a cigarette that had been smoked by him.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Reading through British press it's obvious this "confession" is viewed with a high degree of suspicion and some openly talk about using Burmese as scapegoats. Despite what the police will present as "evidence", they will have a very tough time convincing the international public unless they let British investigators have full access to the case files, suspects and evidence. That will never happen though. Can you imagine the position Thai police would be put in if British investigators came to a different conclusion ?

Posted by Herbert on October 3, 2014 09:18

Editor Comment:

The less reliable sections of the British media, like some tabloids in Thailand, usually run with the most sensational material then offer a 'clarification' that allows two bites at the cherry. As we have reported, the most thorough test of the Thai investigation will come in a British coroners court on January 6. The British media is probably more splintered and mixed than the Thai media.

gravatar

Well there you go - the media says it matches so case closed. Maybe better for the police to confirm or deny the match. Given the handling of the case so far evidence will speak volumes compared to alleged 'confessions'.

Posted by Mister Ree on October 3, 2014 09:44

Editor Comment:

Unwise to jump to any conclusions.

gravatar

ed ...are you serious ? (moderated)

Posted by chris on October 3, 2014 10:28

Editor Comment:

We're very serious journalists. It's our readers who put on makeup and play circus clowns, chris.

gravatar

@ Editor

I understand and agree with what you say but I would not consider The Guardian to be one of the Tabloids. I don't read British media on a regular basis so I'm no expert though.

Posted by Herbert on October 3, 2014 11:00

gravatar

I do not believe for one minute that these are the "killers".Thai media outlets have become judge and jury now, BUT police have yet to confirm the claim.
What happened to the policeman who said he would be the only one to confirm or deny reports? Been posted to lavatory duty has he? No I still can't say I believe any of this confession bit. The Burmese have become throw-away people.

Posted by Duncan B on October 3, 2014 11:16

gravatar

Lie detector anyone!!

Posted by Sharp on October 3, 2014 13:22

gravatar

I don't believe one iota of this. I wonder how much "persuading" it took before the confession was given

Posted by sky on October 3, 2014 14:00

Editor Comment:

We'd prefer to wait to see rather than have judgements made in advance.

gravatar

RIP.

A cliche come true. Crime of arousal by Burmese at a Thai beach at night.

Posted by Lena on October 3, 2014 14:03

gravatar

Oh. Only now read the comments.
While it is funny, that the three come up so late, DNA from the victims is pretty damning. If the police confirms everyone should be happy these three are off the streets.
I thought of the unresolved murders on Phuket beaches, were blond tourists were killed some years ago.
This looks like finnaly good work by Thai criminal police.

Posted by Lena on October 3, 2014 14:10

Editor Comment:

Was there an unresolved case on Phuket? I don't believe there was. Your memory could be defective.

gravatar

Blond (swede?) tourist at the airport beach, or nearby beach, and killed after walking there alone near or at dark. Never heart it was solved. But if, then great.

Ok, thank you google, yes it was a swede. The woman, identified as 27-year-old Hanna Charlotta Backlund. 2008. Never heart it was solved.

Posted by Lena on October 3, 2014 23:21

Editor Comment:

Yes, it was solved. The man was mentally disturbed, if I remember rightly, without google. That was the case where the suggestion was made that female tourists arriving at Phuket airport should be issued with whistles.

gravatar

Given recent events on breaches of human rights, I am somewhat suspicious of the Thai authorities. In order to satisfy curiosity, then surely they could consider a more transparent and independent approach. Otherwise questions of doubt will be surely raised, particularly by the foreign media.

Posted by reader on October 4, 2014 08:23

gravatar

So many "Farangs" think they can do a better job than the police. Probably have been watching too much Sherlock Holmes. Every case and crimes solved by the Thai police are always filled with doubts and theory of conspiracy even when the media is presented with clear cut evidence. Your opinion doesn't represent "international public"

Posted by Thai in Phuket on October 4, 2014 09:11

Editor Comment:

The ease with which people can express an opinion these days leads too many people to think their opinion is of value.

gravatar

It's disheartening to learn of such tragedy, regardless of being Thai or not.... but tourists (even the locals) need to be constantly reminded that Thailand isn't Singapore or Switzerland which have the lowest crime rates in the world...we are probably in the 100th place on this chart. To put yourself at risk by going to such desolated wilderness and remote area especially at night or early morning is simply what you should never do. The same goes for public displays of wealth or valuables.

Posted by Thai in Phuket on October 4, 2014 09:29

gravatar

The most dangerous liars are those who think they are telling the truth. My own gut feeling is telling me these are not the guilty persons. Karma will come to haunt those persons who are the killers.

Posted by Robin on October 4, 2014 10:10

Editor Comment:

On the other hand, the gut feeling may have been caused by something you ate, Robin.

gravatar

Were these matches made with the results from swabs of the Burmese and sent to Singapore and compared with DNA collected from the victims? Were any results obtained from outside the country?

Posted by Paul on October 31, 2014 15:03


Thursday November 28, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter