Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Burma Court Sentences New Zealander to Jail Over Buddha Image Promoting Bar

Tuesday, March 17, 2015
PHUKET: A New Zealander and two other men held responsible for improperly displaying a Budhha image promoting a bar in Burma have been sentenced to two-and-as-half years in jail.

Philip Blackwood, who managed the VGastro Bar in Yangon, was arrested in December along with bar owner Tun Thurein and colleague Htut Ko Ko Lwin. The Facebook image that cost them their freedom depicted Buddha wearing headphones and surrounded by psychedelic colors.

The verdict is the latest evidence that Burma's version of democracy is deeply flawed by the continuing ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya and repression of free speech.

In the wake of the harsh sentences, Human Rights Watch said that ''freedom of speech is under greater threat than ever in Myanmar (Burma) just as the country heads into a pivotal election year.''

The International Press Institute is scheduled to hold its World Congress in Yangon later this month.

Having invited Phuketwan journalist Chutima Sidasathian to speak about the treatment of the Muslim minority Rohingya and the Royal Thai Navy's criminal defamation action against she and an Australian colleague, Alan Morison, the IPI withdrew the invitation at the last minute.

It is believed that the organisation, which claims to represent journalists and publishers from more than 120 countries, may have been concerned because the word ''Rohingya'' is banned in Burma.

The government pursues a policy of obliterating the presence of Rohingya in Burma, driving men, women and children to seek sanctuary by setting sail in boats, delivering thousands into the hands of human traffickers.

Of the Buddha poster jail sentences, Phil Robertson of Human Rights Watch had this to say:

''That these three men acted in a culturally insensitive way by posting the Buddha with headphones image on Facebook is obvious, but that is nothing they should have been hauled into court for, much less sent to prison.

''What this shows is freedom of expression is under greater threat than ever in Burma (Myanmar) just as the country heads into a pivotal election year.

''The authorities should accept the heartfelt public apology of the three men, vacate the conviction, and order them to be released immediately and unconditionally, and the Religion Act should be amended to bring it into compliance with international human rights standards.''

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

You're confusing freedom of speech with freedom to insult. Using common sense and common decency can go a long way in the world, but unfortunately seems to disappear more and more under more polarized and outspoken, quite often hateful, opinions.

Posted by stevenl on March 17, 2015 15:07

Editor Comment:

I'm not sure who ''you'' is, stevenl, but the point is that two and a half years' jail is an excessive penalty for an unintended insult. Perhaps you think it's fair and reasonable. Perhaps ''you'' missed the point.

gravatar

[quote]
That these three men acted in a culturally insensitive way by posting the Buddha with headphones image on Facebook is obvious
[/quote]

Obvious yes, but not apparently to these three, naive 'idiots'. The New Zealander could possibly claim ignorance of Buddhist sensitivities, but surely not the 2 Myanmar nationals.

I hope the sentences are reduced and the foreigner kicked out of the country.

Posted by Simon Luttrell on March 17, 2015 17:17

Editor Comment:

To call people ''idiots'' probably warrants three years, Simon, if insults are banned and the crime is worse if the insult is intended. I'd prefer not to appear in a court where you are the judge.

gravatar

stvenl

Freedom of speech actually DOES includes freedom of insult, to the degree unless it is a hate speech - in Europe this threshold is lower, a lot of things can fall under culpable offence, in the US fewer. Overall, "symbols" etc. are not protected, but human rights is relatively new branch of law, and may countries just recently moved off feudalism, or still in the process - so, some rudiments does exist and will stay for some time for sure.

Freedom of speech is not about paying respect etc.

Posted by Sue on March 17, 2015 21:08

gravatar

religion and laws don't need to go hand in hand.

Posted by mike on March 18, 2015 02:17

gravatar

Naturally countries like the EU embraces criticism which is a form of freedom of speech, but many countries elsewhere do not enjoy these rights. Burma is an example of one of them, which I'm sure all three knew at the time.

Posted by reader on March 18, 2015 02:24

Editor Comment:

The question is not whether ''they knew'' but whether a jail sentence is appropriate punishment.

gravatar

"Je suis Charlie" is also needed in many Asian countries. There is no such thing like freedom of speech in all Asia except maybe Japan.

Posted by Dominik on March 18, 2015 13:20

gravatar

IF you want to live and work in a country understanding the laws of that country is important
NO excuses for these people who don't it's not their home country and the same rules do not apply

Posted by peter allen on March 18, 2015 19:41

Editor Comment:

Appropriate punishment is the issue, in Burma and everywhere, pa. Your comment is a cop-out.


Tuesday November 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter