AID organisations are frustrated at being denied access to detained Rohingya boat people in Thailand, raising fears for their health after a young refugee died in custody.
The death of a teenage boy has focused attention on the plight of his 77 surviving companions. All males, aged as young as 14, they were arrested on a boat in January.
This was the first group of boat people to escape the notorious "push-backs" orchestrated by the Thai military, which saw hundreds of boat people die when forced out to sea in wooden vessels without motors.
The practice was abandoned after the consequences and inhumane nature of the practice were exposed by Phuketwan and the South China Morning Post newspaper in Hong Kong.
The future of the detained Rohingya refugees, and hundreds of thousands of others who remain stateless and persecuted in northern Burma, Bangladesh and Malaysia is likely to be raised this week when Asean foreign ministers meet on Phuket.
During April at a ministerial conference of the so-called Bali Process on Human Trafficking, Burma's national police chief, Brigadier General Khin Yi, refused to accept the Rohingya as Burmese citizens and denied any persecution.
But he did offer Burma's co-operation with international efforts to provide aid and development in northern Rakhine state, where many Rohingya come from.
Any proposal for a solution will come too late for 18-year-old Abdul Salam, who died in hospital in the Thai-Burma border town of Ranong on June 30.
Thai officials said he had been sick for some time and died from cardiac arrest.
Because the Thai authorities have refused access to aid organisations, the health of the surviving boat people in custody remains unclear.
"Lack of access and information about the detainees in Ranong have been my main frustration," an official at one aid organisation said.
"My research partner interviewed Rohingya detainees in India, Indonesia and Sri Lanka, but was unable to talk to those in Ranong."
Another aid organisation confirmed it had also been denied access, as have Phuketwan reporters.
Last month, 29 of the detainees claimed Bangladeshi citizenship and have since been transferred to Bangkok, where they were to undergo background checks.
Access has also been denied to that group.
''I have concerns about Bangladesh's procedures,'' the NGO official said.
''Hundreds of Bangladeshis have been detained for a long time in Malaysia and Bangladesh never pays for the costs of their repatriation.''
A proposal for a meeting of the countries most affected by the exodus of Rohingyas is likely to be considered at this week's Asean meeting.
"What have Asean and other affected countries done to address the plight of the Rohingya people since the crisis?" the aid official said.
"It is clear to me that they are putting in place deterrence mechanisms, rather than addressing the root causes."
If nothing is resolved, a new wave of fleeing Rohingya could pick up again in November - the next sailing season - as people smugglers entice them to seek a better life.
A version of this article appeared in the South China Morning Post of July 19.
Aid Groups Alarmed at Isolation of Rohingyas
Latest Two aid groups are alarmed because they have been denied access to a group of Rohingya boat people for six months. One has died, raising concerns about the health of survivors.
Aid Groups Alarmed at Isolation of Rohingyas
MediaWATCH: Clinton Blasts 'Modern Slavery'
News Digest Hillary Clinton is coming to Phuket. The key issue: people trafficking; Rohingya arrested; stopping unwanted cellphone messages; world's worst airline food; H1N1 scan call.
MediaWATCH: Clinton Blasts 'Modern Slavery'
Phuket Still Linked to Slavery and Trafficking
Latest The release of a brochure on people trafficking highlights the part Phuket played in a notorious smuggling incident. Not a lot has changed since then.
Phuket Still Linked to Slavery and Trafficking
Immigration Nabs 'Phuket-Trail People Smuggler'
Photo Album Immigration officers say they have arrested a leading people trafficker as he prepared today to smuggle more than 30 Burmese laborers to Phuket.
Immigration Nabs 'Phuket-Trail People Smuggler'
Burma's Secret Exodus: The Illegal Road to Patong
Latest News Phuket and Patong especially rely on large numbers of Burmese workers. Now, as a registration deadline draws near, authorities are cracking down on secret voyagers.
Burma's Secret Exodus: The Illegal Road to Patong
Thailand's UN Pledge: No More Boat People Deaths
Photo Album No more pushing back the boats: that is the guarantee extracted from Thailand by the UN as an international body looks at human trafficking and its tragic outcomes.
Thailand's UN Pledge: No More Boat People Deaths
Human Trafficking: Suffocation, or Solution?
LatestDesperation drives Rohingya, Burmese and others into the hands of human traffickers, putting their lives on the line. The Bali Process this week may provide answers that Thailand needs.
Human Trafficking: Suffocation, or Solution?
The death of a teenage boy has focused attention on the plight of his 77 surviving companions. All males, aged as young as 14, they were arrested on a boat in January.
This was the first group of boat people to escape the notorious "push-backs" orchestrated by the Thai military, which saw hundreds of boat people die when forced out to sea in wooden vessels without motors.
The practice was abandoned after the consequences and inhumane nature of the practice were exposed by Phuketwan and the South China Morning Post newspaper in Hong Kong.
The future of the detained Rohingya refugees, and hundreds of thousands of others who remain stateless and persecuted in northern Burma, Bangladesh and Malaysia is likely to be raised this week when Asean foreign ministers meet on Phuket.
During April at a ministerial conference of the so-called Bali Process on Human Trafficking, Burma's national police chief, Brigadier General Khin Yi, refused to accept the Rohingya as Burmese citizens and denied any persecution.
But he did offer Burma's co-operation with international efforts to provide aid and development in northern Rakhine state, where many Rohingya come from.
Any proposal for a solution will come too late for 18-year-old Abdul Salam, who died in hospital in the Thai-Burma border town of Ranong on June 30.
Thai officials said he had been sick for some time and died from cardiac arrest.
Because the Thai authorities have refused access to aid organisations, the health of the surviving boat people in custody remains unclear.
"Lack of access and information about the detainees in Ranong have been my main frustration," an official at one aid organisation said.
"My research partner interviewed Rohingya detainees in India, Indonesia and Sri Lanka, but was unable to talk to those in Ranong."
Another aid organisation confirmed it had also been denied access, as have Phuketwan reporters.
Last month, 29 of the detainees claimed Bangladeshi citizenship and have since been transferred to Bangkok, where they were to undergo background checks.
Access has also been denied to that group.
''I have concerns about Bangladesh's procedures,'' the NGO official said.
''Hundreds of Bangladeshis have been detained for a long time in Malaysia and Bangladesh never pays for the costs of their repatriation.''
A proposal for a meeting of the countries most affected by the exodus of Rohingyas is likely to be considered at this week's Asean meeting.
"What have Asean and other affected countries done to address the plight of the Rohingya people since the crisis?" the aid official said.
"It is clear to me that they are putting in place deterrence mechanisms, rather than addressing the root causes."
If nothing is resolved, a new wave of fleeing Rohingya could pick up again in November - the next sailing season - as people smugglers entice them to seek a better life.
A version of this article appeared in the South China Morning Post of July 19.
Phuketwan on Human Trafficking
Aid Groups Alarmed at Isolation of Rohingyas
Latest Two aid groups are alarmed because they have been denied access to a group of Rohingya boat people for six months. One has died, raising concerns about the health of survivors.
Aid Groups Alarmed at Isolation of Rohingyas
MediaWATCH: Clinton Blasts 'Modern Slavery'
News Digest Hillary Clinton is coming to Phuket. The key issue: people trafficking; Rohingya arrested; stopping unwanted cellphone messages; world's worst airline food; H1N1 scan call.
MediaWATCH: Clinton Blasts 'Modern Slavery'
Phuket Still Linked to Slavery and Trafficking
Latest The release of a brochure on people trafficking highlights the part Phuket played in a notorious smuggling incident. Not a lot has changed since then.
Phuket Still Linked to Slavery and Trafficking
Immigration Nabs 'Phuket-Trail People Smuggler'
Photo Album Immigration officers say they have arrested a leading people trafficker as he prepared today to smuggle more than 30 Burmese laborers to Phuket.
Immigration Nabs 'Phuket-Trail People Smuggler'
Burma's Secret Exodus: The Illegal Road to Patong
Latest News Phuket and Patong especially rely on large numbers of Burmese workers. Now, as a registration deadline draws near, authorities are cracking down on secret voyagers.
Burma's Secret Exodus: The Illegal Road to Patong
Thailand's UN Pledge: No More Boat People Deaths
Photo Album No more pushing back the boats: that is the guarantee extracted from Thailand by the UN as an international body looks at human trafficking and its tragic outcomes.
Thailand's UN Pledge: No More Boat People Deaths
Human Trafficking: Suffocation, or Solution?
LatestDesperation drives Rohingya, Burmese and others into the hands of human traffickers, putting their lives on the line. The Bali Process this week may provide answers that Thailand needs.
Human Trafficking: Suffocation, or Solution?
Well done phuketwan for exposing human rights abuses in your region. Governments must not be allowed to get away with this type of behaviour.
Posted by david on July 19, 2009 18:56