Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Young women continue to visit Phi Phi despite four mystery deaths

Four Deaths on Phi Phi Shows Forensic Need

Sunday, September 21, 2014
PHUKET: It should come as no surprise to anyone that police in Thailand do not have the same high technology available to them as Britain's Scotland Yard or the FBI in America.

Thailand remains a developing country with standards that need to improve further and it will be some time before a comparison can fairly be struck with developed countries.

Because Thailand is less developed and because society's rules are less clear cut is precisely the reason why many young people come to Thailand.

For the moment, the deaths of Hannah Witheridge and David Miller on Koh Tao this week can be filed with the deaths of four young women on Phi Phi since 2009 under ''Unresolved Mysteries.''

The one point that should be made is that rules and regulations and the law sit uneasily on rites-of-passage islands such as Phi Phi, Phangan and Tao, where the 20-somethings of the world come to party.

Back in 2009, American Jill St Onge and Norwegian Julie Bergheim died convulsing on Phi Phi and there was still no clue to what killed them when Canadians Audrey Belanger, 20, and her sister Noemi, 26, died in similar fashion in 2012.

Thailand's police did not have the forensic capacity to come close to determining a cause and it was left to a team of investigative journalists from Canada to conclude that the women probably were killed by the inappropriate use of industrial strength pesticides.

The deaths of the women were shocking but only now, with the hunt on for a killer or killers on two legs, does the question of lack of sophisticated methodology and equipment among police in Thailand's south become relevant again.

Region 8 commander Major General Panya Mamen, who oversees Phuket, Phi Phi, Koh Tao, Samui, Phang Nga and the southern mainland, is an astute officer who has given his backing to better standards of policing in his jurisdiction.

Without the forthright approach of Major General Panya and his quest to help Phuket meet international standards, it's doubtful if the transformation now taking place in the holiday island's taxi industry would have been started.

He gave his unqualified backing to Major General Paween Pongsirin, who conducted an undercover operation for months that led to the arrests of almost 200 drivers and the busting open of nests of thugs for whom threats and intimidation had become standard business practice.

Major General Panya has said that the international-standard gathering of evidence before charges are laid is a technique, pioneered by Major General Paween, that he would like to see more widely used in Thailand.

Out on smaller rites-of-passage islands that are further from mainland thinking than Phuket, the local businesses usually manage to persuade neighborhood police to turn a blind eye to many of the problems that come with rites-of-passage tourism.

Binge drinking and drug-taking are just the start. If the aim is to make tourists safe in Thailand, some of the tourists who take delight in being unsafe will be heading elsewhere.

As for Mr Miller and Ms Witheridge, their savage murders are unlikely to be forgotten.

One of the big differences between developing and developed countries is that many developed countries - Britain included - hold inquests into the circumstances surrounding the deaths of citizens overseas.

At some time in coming months, Thailand's police will be invited to make a submission to a British coroner about the investigation of the killings of Ms Witheridge and Mr Miller.

Whatever the outcome of the pursuit of the killer or killers, it will the content and the quality of the submission to the British coroner by Thailand's police that will mark whether the nation's concerns about tourist safety are real or not.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

If, as has been pointed out elsewhere, the media circus of TV crews and reporters as well as tourists and other onlookers were kept well away from the crime scenes, and the pier had been blocked to arriving and departing passengers by police, they might have caught the perpetrators. Now with not even basic methodology, knowledge and equipment plus contaminated crime scenes the police cannot do the job they were supposed to be trained to do. Police speaking to the media must be stopped and information that is not sound should not be released till the truth is known. It has been a botched job from the start, not helped by the remarks made by the PM and other senior officers 'confiding anonymously' to certain reporters that this was a crime of passion. The reputation of the Royal Thai Police is already one of ineptitude and corruption so I'm afraid the phrase that Thailand is safe is ineffectual when the police are unable to act in a professional manner in such important cases.

Posted by Pete on September 21, 2014 12:32

gravatar

Although there would, no doubt, be many detractors,being that we are ALL "in the system" perhaps it is time that all ID should include DNA. All convicts and suspects,all Thai males, being required to serve time in military,..good places to start...Just one small step beyond fingerprinting for many forms of licenses and ID?
Thai policing certainly needs an overhaul and a "wake up call" for sure!

Posted by david on September 21, 2014 13:53

Editor Comment:

There was the senior police officer who figured there was no point in chasing the British man who killed an American on Phuket because it was unreasonable that Thailand would have to pay for his jail time . . . apart from that, we've found murder investigators to be reasonably efficient.

gravatar

The CBC sent a crew over to investigate on behalf of the Belanger sisters and the country - the toxic cleaning substance is still highly in use in India.

Way more Canadians go to Mexico than Thailand - but whenever a Canadian is killed in Thailand - it is a very big deal in the media..

Canadian fatalities in Thailand pale in comparison to British and Australian citizens - as Mexico is a 5 hour flight for Canucks - as compared to a 13 hour flight to Hong Kong (from Vancouver) - then 2.5 hours to Thailand ( there are no direct flights from Canada to Thailand, pity that )

Posted by farang888 on September 21, 2014 21:41

gravatar

Bangkok Post Sunday editorial criticizing a work of police on the case is so much to the point, also if makes a sad reading as one these there is obviously wrong, that change should and will come fast.

Another blow is a report by The Telegraph that on the same beach a day before 2 British girls have been robbed by 4 members Thai bike gang.
Local police seems to be unaware or wished to be unaware about it.

Last bar - AC bar - where victims were seen so apparently didn't get timely attention from the police as if they simply categorized the bar as the people whom they now too well and whom them like... Not surprisingly giving a haul that was discovered later.

Nearby beach is not closed or sealed, making finding any new evidence or clue that has been missed before virtually impossible.

Posted by Sue on September 22, 2014 01:02

Editor Comment:

Lax policing and a too-close affiliation with local businesses is a problem on all of Thailand's holiday islands, including Phuket.

gravatar

I place my bets on fishermen, swimming in from their moored fishing boats.

Posted by Nobama on September 22, 2014 09:00

gravatar

They're foolish, but then why would farang women come to Thailand anyway? If not for Thai women, almost none of us would be here either. Living in a Country where adult men are allowed to behave like children gets quite tiresome, but then if they were not such losers there would not be so many available Thai woman.

Posted by Robert on September 25, 2014 06:17

Editor Comment:

Total nonsense, Robert. Your mind must be a cesspool. Oh, that's right . . . I remember. You're from Pattaya.


Wednesday October 9, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter