Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations


Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here


Rohingya Boatpeople Cannot Be Left to Battle Unfair Odds

Wednesday, March 13, 2013
ONE FAILS to understand the unperturbed attitude with which regional and international leaders and organisations are treating the unrelenting onslaught against Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar, formally known as Burma.

Numbers speak of atrocities where every violent act is prelude to greater violence and ethnic cleansing. Yet, western governments' normalisation with the Myanmar regime continues unabated, regional leaders are as gutless as ever and even human rights organisations seem compelled by habitual urges to issue statements lacking meaningful, decisive and coordinated calls for action.

Meanwhile the 'boatpeople' remain on their own. On February 26, fishermen discovered a rickety wooden boat floating randomly at sea, nearly 25 kilometers off the coast of Indonesia's northern province of Aceh.

The Associated Press and other media reported there were 121 people on board including children who were extremely weak, dehydrated and nearly starved. They were Rohingya refugees who preferred to take their chances at sea rather than stay in Myanmar.

To understand the decision of a parent to risk his child's life in a tumultuous sea would require understanding the greater risks awaiting them at home.

Reporting for Voice of America from Jakarta, Kate Lamb cited a moderate estimate of the outcome of communal violence in the Arakan state, which left hundreds of Rohingya Muslims dead, thousands of homes burnt and nearly 115,000 displaced.

The number is likely to be higher at all fronts. Many fleeing Rohingya perished at sea or disappeared to never be seen again. Harrowing stories are told and reported of families separating and boats sunk.

There are documented events in which various regional navies and border police sent back refugees after they successfully braved the deadly journey to other countries - Thailand, Indonesia, Bangladesh and elsewhere.

The UN refugee agency (UNHCR) reported that nearly 13,000 Rohingya refugees attempted to leave Myanmar on smugglers' boats in the Bay of Bengal in 2012. At least five hundred drowned.

But who are the Rohingya people?

Myanmar officials and media wish to simply see the Rohingyas as ''illegal Bengali immigrants,'' a credulous reading of history at best. The intentions of this inaccurate classification, however, are truly sinister for it is meant to provide a legal clearance to forcefully deport the Rohingya population.

Myanmar President Thein Sein had in fact made an ''offer'' to the UN last year that he was willing to send the Rohingya people ''to any other country willing to accept them.'' The UN declined.

Rohingya Muslims, however, are native to the state of ''Rohang,'' officially known as Rakhine or Arakan. If one is to seek historical accuracy, not only are the Rohingya people native to Myanmar, it was in fact Burma that occupied Rakhine in the 1700s.

Over the years, especially in the first half of the 20th century, the original inhabitants of Arakan were joined by cheap or forced labor from Bengal and India, who permanently settled there. For decades, tension brewed between Buddhists and Muslims in the region.

Naturally, a majority backed by a military junta is likely to prevail over a minority without any serious regional or international backers. Without much balance of power to be mentioned, the Rohingya population of Arakan, estimated at nearly 800,000, subsisted between the nightmare of having no legal status (as they are still denied citizenship), little or no rights and the occasional ethnic purges carried out by their Buddhist neighbors with the support of their government, army and police.

The worst of such violence in recent years took place between June and October of last year. Buddhists also paid a heavy price for the clashes, but the stateless Rohingyas, being isolated and defenseless, were the ones to carry the heaviest death toll and destruction.

And just when ''calm'' is reported - as in returning to the status quo of utter discrimination and political alienation of the Rohingyas - violence erupts once more, and every time the diameters of the conflict grow bigger.

In late February, an angry Buddhist mob attacked non-Rohingya Muslim schools, shops and homes in the capital Rangoon, regional and international media reported. The cause of the violence was a rumor that the Muslim community is planning to build a mosque.

What is taking place in Arakan is most dangerous, not only because of the magnitude of the atrocities and the perpetual suffering of the Rohingya people, who are often described as the world's most persecuted people.

Other layers of danger also exist that threaten to widen the parameters of the conflict throughout the Southeast Asia region, bringing instability to already unstable border areas, and, of course, as was the case recently, take the conflict from an ethnic one to a purely religious one.

In a region of a unique mix of ethnicities and religions, the plight of the Rohingyas could become the trigger that would set already fractious parts of the region ablaze.

Although the plight of the Rohingya people has in recent months crossed the line from the terrible, but hidden tragedy into a recurring media topic, it is still facing many hurdles that must be overcome in order for some action to be taken.

While the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) has been making major economic leaps forward, it remains politically ineffective, with little interest in issues pertaining to human rights. Under the guise of its commitment to ''non-interference'' and disproportionate attention to the festering territorial disputes in the South China Sea, Asean seems unaware that the Rohingya people even exist.

Worse, Asean leaders were reportedly in agreement that Myanmar should chair their 2014 summit, as a reward for superficial reforms undertaken by Rangoon to ease its political isolation and open up its market beyond China and few other countries.

Meanwhile, western countries, led by the United States are clamoring to divide the large Myanmar economic cake amongst themselves, and are saying next to nothing about the current human rights records of Naypyidaw.

The minor democratic reforms in Myanmar seem, after all, a pretext to allow the country back to western arms. And the race to Rangoon has indeed begun, unhindered by the continued persecution of the Rohingya people.

On February 26, Myanmar's President Sein met in Oslo with Norway's Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg in a ''landmark'' visit. They spoke economy, of course, for Myanmar has plenty to offer.

And regarding the conflict in Arakan, Jens Stoltenberg unambiguously declared it to be an internal Burmese affair, reducing it to most belittling statements. In regards to ''disagreements'' over citizenship, he said, ''we have encouraged dialogue, but we will not demand that Burma's government give citizenship to the Rohingyas.''

Moreover, to reward Sein for his supposedly bold democratic reforms, Norway took the lead by waving off nearly half of its debt and other countries followed suit, including Japan which dropped $3 billion last year.

While one is used to official hypocrisy, whether by Asean or western governments, many are still scratching their heads over the unforgivable silence of democracy advocate and Noble Peace Prize recipient Aung San Suu Kyi.

Luckily, others are speaking out. Bangladesh's Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus, along with former Timor-Leste president Jose Ramos-Horta had both recently spoke with decisive terms in support of the persecuted Rohingya people.

''The minority Muslim Rohingya continue to suffer unspeakable persecution, with more than 1000 killed and hundreds of thousands displaced from their homes just in recent months, apparently with the complicity and protection of security forces,'' the Nobel laureates wrote in the Huffington Post on February 20. They criticised the prejudicial Citizenship Law of 1982 and called for granting the Rohingya people full citizenship.

The perpetual suffering of the Rohingya people must end. They are deserving of rights and dignity. They are weary of crossing unforgiving seas and walking harsh terrains seeking mere survival. More voices must join those who are speaking out in support of their rights.

Asean must break away from its silence and tediously guarded policies and western countries must be confronted by their own civil societies: no normalisation with Naypyidaw when innocent men, women and children are being burned alive in their own homes.

This injustice needs to be known to the world and serious, organised and determined efforts must follow to bring the persecution of the Rohingya people to an end.

Ramzy Baroud ( is an internationally-syndicated columnist and the editor of His latest book is: My Father was A Freedom Fighter: Gaza's Untold Story (Pluto Press).


Comments have been disabled for this article.


It's the perception of refugees that has coloured everyone from daring to take them in: it means giving free food, sponsoring education, creating and portioning out jobs, building houses, providing healthcare, all out of tax-paying citizens contributions without knowing if these refugees will in turn be able to contribute economically back to host country. It's all about the money. Who wants to give away free money? Why is trafficking so pronounced for these Rohinyas, cos it's instant economic gain.
I mean it's not the perfect solution but for a president to offer anyone at all to take in these Rohinyas, it was an opportunity for these Rohinyas to get out without harm, UN has to be partly responsible for these atrocities happening to the Rohinyas because they declined to help.
So unless a neutral aid-giver is willing to economically sponsor these Rohinyas for their entire lifetime and the next and we know it will be a few generations since they reproduce like crazy and make it worthwhile for the host, humanity will just go on living in denial of these incidents that do not affect us directly. All boils down to economy cos that's what a capitalist system does to us all.

Posted by May on March 15, 2013 17:56

Editor Comment:

The Rohingya don't want to leave, May. They are being forced to go. It's called ''ethnic cleansing.'' It's one step short of genocide.

Your views are abhorrent and difficult for any right-thinking people to accept. Perhaps you don't know any?.


You don't seem to have read my comments correctly. I know they are unwanted and the Burmese president has warned that either UN take them or they will be forced to flee through locally caused atrocities of which the Burmese govt will turn a blind eye to.

And I think as someone who has had a capitalist education. We do nothing for free as it does not benefit us. I do feel for them and in my own small way I do contribute to help those that had landed here w food n clothes donation. Just as in your small way you keep reporting these incidents in your site so we would never forget them and the truth that this is happening.
But the bigger picture is no capitalist country will ever take them in and it's simply more "comfortable" for them just make some non-committal noise and delaying things. It's a terrible thought but with no "value" attached to these Rohinyas, everyone is simply just waiting for this problem to eventually "die out".

Posted by May on March 16, 2013 10:29

Editor Comment:

Where did you get a ''capitalist'' education, May? That sounds rather sad. Many of us sought a complete education. We were taught that money is of limited value. We were taught how to tell right from wrong. If you accept that everything must have a monetary value, you are part of the problem.

Only the racists and the poorly-educated are waiting for this problem to ''die out.'' Those who can tell right from wrong are trying to save lives and fight the ignorant and prejudiced.

Monday July 15, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa


Facebook Twitter