Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Glade runners have gathered to protest about the  movie museum plan

Phuket Glade Saviors Say 'Hollywood Movie Museum' Not Suitable for Shorefront

Saturday, November 14, 2015
PHUKET: The Governor of Phuket is being asked to intervene and cancel a plan for a ''Hollwood movie museum'' that has been proposed for a precious natural shorefront at a Phuket beach.

Residents remain angry at plans to axe a glade of trees on the popular Nai Harn shorefront to make way for the concrete and glass construction.

Any talk of a compromise is likely to be howled down.

A less intrusive building is being proposed but already a network of locals and expats is in place and prepared to respond immediately to save the trees if constructors with chain saws are spotted.

''There is no possibility of compromise,'' one expat activist said, preferring to remain anonymous. ''We don't want this tacky movie museum on Nai Harn's beautiful foreshore.''

Budget for the 40 million baht project was made available earlier this year by the Tourism Ministry.

The idea of destroying an internationally-renowned beauty spot for a movie museum has added a local element to the enduring arm-wrestle between developers and nature lovers.

Activists are asking whether the government in Bangkok understands that Nai Harn's present appeal to people who love nature would disappear under the museum's floorboards.

Thirty-two trees have been marked for destruction at Nai Harn, which earlier this year was listed among Asia's Top 10 Beaches by the popular travel site, TripAdvisor.

How the movie idea won the support of the Tourism Ministry and got so far that contracts are reported to have been signed for construction remains a riddle.

Even with the number of trees to be axed reduced, opposition to the project remains strong.

Rawai Mayor Aroon Soroj, who is said to have approved the site for the museum, has become difficult to contact but according to one unconfirmed report, aims to call a meeting of residents next week.

Local village chief Boonsom Ponlob said yesterday: ''If Phuket tourism is something these people wish to support, they could start by repairing the toilets, improving the car park and making everything safe and clean.''

He has sent a letter about the protest to Phuket Governor Jamleran Tipayapongtada and the governor's Facebook page has been deluged with protest messages.

''A movie museum may well be something that Phuket should have - somewhere else,'' said chief Boonsom.

Talk of a compromise was out of the question, he said.

''It's not something we need at Nai Harn. Once the budget has been spent, who will take care of this? We all know what happens with these projects. Look at the Gateway.''

[The 50 million baht Gateway, build near the Tachatchai checkpoint entrance to Phuket, fails to attract more than a trickle of visitors.]

''We want this thing moved and we will resist any attempt to chop down any of our trees.''

The project has been given the go-ahead by Phuket authorities despite talk that Phuket needs to aim for a more natural appeal in future.

It confirms suspicions that the people now in charge of Phuket's beaches and shorefronts have little idea how to properly protect and manage them.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

(moderated)

Posted by Elephants Gerald on November 14, 2015 09:31

Editor Comment:

If you don't like our reporting, Elephants, lumber off somewhere else. We're not interested in nit-pickers. Add value or you won't be published again.

gravatar

it would be better if the tourism ministry earmarked the B40 million baht to help pay the lifeguards instead of having contracts expire and tourists along with locals drown.then the ministry would be promoting tourism which it's name implies.

Posted by Anonymous on November 14, 2015 10:02

Editor Comment:

A proposal to have a lifeguard centre at Nai harn was rejected by the local council some years ago. One can only speculate why the movie museum is more acceptable.

gravatar

Mr Santi of Tourisme better look alone by himself how to improve the present deteriorated state of NaiHarn beach.
No public toilets, 2 miserable shower stands without waterpipe connection, never completed.( but the budget was approved!)
Everywhere around the temple it is dirty and roads need to be done.
The playground on the island in NaiHarn Lake is a shame. ( according Rawai Mayor, as he said last April, no budget to repair/replace the playground Swings).
There is so much to do at NaiHarn beach to make the beach more attractive and beautiful.
If they not able to keep up the existing things, what could we expect of something new, what after completing will be forgotten, as it will not become a place of interest.
Suggestion: put this movie museum on the grounds of the tin mine museum, space enough.

Posted by Kurt on November 14, 2015 10:06

gravatar

I agree Kurt, 40M baht for what , a few shop type stalls, install or repair the necessary infrastructure and install more rubbish bins which are emptied at least twice a day with the money would attract more people both Thai and tourists.
The showers Kurt mentioned under the trees they want to cut down have not been in a working condition for years

Posted by peter allen on November 14, 2015 10:45

gravatar

Forget the museum... spend the 40 million baht on the beautification of Nai Harn. eg: 3 sets of public clean toilet blocks and showers, repair foreshore steps and wall, pave car park area, supply more rubbish bins, repair the rotunda, repair all safety warning signs with signs that are weather / high wind proof.

Posted by DG on November 14, 2015 10:51

gravatar

I had a lot of time for Khun Santi... but not so sure now. Up until he had appeared to be doing a good job in difficult inherited circumstances, but this movie museum appears to have come from the Ministry and something he is behind. Mmm...

Posted by Duncan on November 14, 2015 11:03

gravatar

You have to wonder how they make the decisions of how money is spent at Nai Harn beach
They recently installed expenses gym equipment on the south side of nai harn lake which is hardy ever used.
IF they had spent the same money on updating and improveing the children's playground on the island in nai harn lake they would have had a magnificent playground, but they people in power never seem to have the necessary money to do this, I wonder why

Posted by peter allen on November 14, 2015 11:22

gravatar

That idea of Hollywood museum in Phuket looked idiotic on the facet at inception,still some people here appreciated that on initial announcement.

Actually eexactly the authorities who should cared for the quality of environment as their fiduciary duty toward lcal popoulus and as a professional matter - the local council and dept.of tourism - simply stabbed in the back with a knife:

the ehole set up completely sick: precious public fund for real estate that can and should be only subject of private investment,

- apparently to overcome restrictions on use of the land,

- a building that simply unfit to an environment, and have effect of degrading of the environment - and yes no need for a very complicated study,just an honest assessment,

- this all in a huge contrast of state of care of the beach amd environment like in a fourth world. More poor African countries do care more occasionally.

However,they surely did everything in accordance to a letter of law,as most probably laws do not capture such situations to address atub
if hearings,EIA etc.

Moreover what can be and what can not be built is defined in local planning and zoning rules,that are review once in few years - and yes,once it is there,then on general nothing can stop a construction from happening. In most cases general public even if alerted ignore hearings on change of planning and zoning rules, as they don't aporeciate it as a major law on what construction is allowed,wrongly assuming it is evalutaed on a case by case with a high degree of leeway.

And local council - as so many elected organs in country - represent a wealthy or well off people, who elected themselves in,and they don't give a fXXk to local peasnats opinions - part of them anyway are from Isaan and don't vote hetr,and even more the same treatment to expats.

The governor role in this case is unusually powerful as it is what he can influence : he has budgetary allocations powers and so can influence to some degree investments (and ms-investments) of subordinated councils - however he by far doesn't hold a veto power on individual projects

Posted by Sue on November 14, 2015 12:23

gravatar

Of course there is no money for the playground. It's all spent on useless and hence switched off traffic lights. Right now they are installing huge electric speed limit signs. How much was the unnecessary re-paving of all the roads last year? Good friends can make you happy!

Posted by Kohrup on November 14, 2015 14:43

gravatar

Nai Harn has the potential to be the best beach in Asia with just a little forethought and planning.
The very thought that a movie museum is more appropriate than a lifeguard center shows that someone is not thinking very clearly.

Posted by Arthur on November 14, 2015 15:48

gravatar

This sort of tourist attraction doesn't belong on or near ANY BEACH in Phuket. Somewhere like Patong would be far more appropriate. The suggestion to put it on the grounds of the Tin Mining Museum makes a lot of sense as well, as there appears to be a lot of room and no one using the facility. I'm glad that locals want to protect the natural beauty of the foreshore at Nai Harn Beach. Officials need to scrap the idea of this ridiculous museum altogether and look at providing much needed regular maintenance of the area. As already suggested here; garbage cans, showers, public restrooms, landscape maintenance as well as maintenance around the temple, repair of foreshore stairs, parking lot maintenance, children's playground maintenance etc. The local village chief is a wise man and officials need to listen to him and to seriously rethink this one. Do officials realize this is one of the most beautiful beaches in the world? Take care of it!

Posted by Paradise on November 14, 2015 17:37

gravatar

Was memorizing today the amount of money for that film museum.
40 Million thb!!!
A enormous budget for something what will be deteriorated in 5 years time due to the monsoons rains/wind and salty air and expected non maintenance.

Is there in Thailand ( Bangkok) a independent Government accountant department to check these local budgets?

In Rawai and Naiharn are the last few years budgets spent on unneeded projects, such as installing traffic lights ( they never in operation), these funny speed ribs on the roads ( they don't make people to slow down).
Huge speed limit signs are now the latest, which is clearly out of a fun budget.

But I am puzzled why the waterfront site of Rawai Beach never get renovated, why not make it pleasant again for thai in habitants and foreign tourists?
It is a popular area.
The whole stretch looks so bad, dirty, poor and shabby, while is has so much potential.
I not understand the Rawai city hall priorities in money spending.

Posted by Kurt on November 14, 2015 19:23

Editor Comment:

Exposing an important 40 million baht tourist attraction to the effects of salt is yet another reason why this is a foolhardy project. Good point.

gravatar

At Naiharn Beach, Phuket Lifeguard Centre Sala is falling apart.

Until a few days ago I never knew it was a centre ( sala) of the Life guards, never seen a single life guard around there.

What was actually the thinking when this open sala was built?
One couldn't store there any equipment or things like that.
I thought it was a wrong-located picnic place.

Anyway, it is a good example of how a film museum there will look later, about 5 years after building.

Posted by Kurt on November 15, 2015 09:30

Editor Comment:

It never was a lifeguard centre, Kurt. That was the proposal, but it was rejected. I suggest you read about it in the links at the end of this article. But no need to comment about it again . . .

gravatar

Phuketwan played a crucial role in getting this story out before the chainsaws arrived. I shudder to think what might have happened if PW had not been there. I fear we might find out the hard way after Dec. 31. You will be sorely missed by many, even by some who don't yet realize it.

Posted by Treelover on November 15, 2015 10:55


Tuesday April 30, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter