Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

A Phuket wanted poster for Lee Aldhouse, using a Phuketwan photograph

Phuket Murder: Aldhouse Held, Video Hearing Next

Wednesday, October 20, 2010
Phuketwan Updating Report

LEE ALDHOUSE, the British kickboxer wanted on Phuket over the murder of a former US Marine, has been arrested on an extradition warrant and will appear in a video link review hearing next week, a British newspaper reports.

The Birmingham Post says Aldhouse was remanded in custody at City of Westminster Magistrates Court. Thai authorities have lodged the extradition request over the death of Dashawn Longfellow on Phuket in the early hours of August 14.

Aldhouse, 28, allegedly stabbed Longfellow to death at the former US Marine's southern Phuket apartment after losing a fistfight at the Freedom Bar in the coastal village of Rawai.

The kickboxer is believed to have fled Phuket overland after the killing, leaving Thailand for Cambodia then travelling to Singapore, where he boarded a plane for Britain.

Officials at London's Heathrow Airport held Aldhouse because he had breached the conditions of parole for a previous firearm offence in Britain. Aldhouse originally comes from near Birmingham.

A video link would be unusual and possibly a first for an extradition case to Phuket and to Thailand. Phuket police are keen to have Aldhouse returned to Phuket as speedily as possible to face trial here.

Thai prosecutors are known to have been meticulous in compiling the case for extradition.

While some media outlets have raised the issue of whether extradition would be acceptable to a British court if Thailand maintains the death penalty for murder, informed diplomatic sources have told Phuketwan that the issue is unlikely to handicap the process.

What British authorities will require is prima facie evidence of the case against Aldhouse.

It is not known at this stage whether the video presentation is likely to include incriminating security camera footage of a man who appears to be Aldhouse picking up knives from the floor of a Rawai 7-Eleven store before Longfellow was stabbed to death.

For security camera footage of the alleged killer in a Phuket 7-Eleven store, brought to you by Phuketwan and CNN, go to:
http://edition.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/asiapcf/08/17/thailand.kickboxing.killer/?hpt=T2#fbid=j8b3WNTelG3&wom=false
Phuket Builds the Case Against 'Kickbox Killer'
Stabbing Update Extradition of a suspect from Britain to Thailand to face a murder charge probably hinges on the weight of evidence and the potential for support from US authorities.
Phuket Builds the Case Against 'Kickbox Killer'

Phuket Kickbox 'Killer' Caught at British Airport: Hunt on Phuket for Accomplices, 5 Million Baht Added to Bank Account
Update The man wanted for the murder on Phuket of US Marine DaShawn Longfellow has been arrested at a British airport.
Phuket Kickbox 'Killer' Caught at British Airport: Hunt on Phuket for Accomplices, 5 Million Baht Added to Bank Account

Phuket Farewells Longfellow on Final Journey
Manhunt Update Heading for Bangkok and a connecting flight to the US is the body of murder victim DaShawn Longfellow, returning home six days after falling victim to a cowardly knife attack.
Phuket Farewells Longfellow on Final Journey

Phuket Kickbox Killing: Cam Shows 'Man in Black' With Knives
PHOTO ALBUM Newly viewed footage from inside a Phuket 7 Eleven store shows a man who looks like hunted fugitive Lee Aldhouse demanding knives shortly before a fatal stabbing death.
Phuket Kickbox Killing: Cam Shows 'Man in Black' With Knives

How a War Hero Died in Phuket's Kickbox Killing: Stalker Struck in the Dark
Timetable to a Murder Police are continuing the manhunt for a muay Thai kickboxer and murder suspect they believe is still a fugitive, loose on Phuket.
How a War Hero Died in Phuket's Kickbox Killing: Stalker Struck in the Dark

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

So he should be. Terrible crime and one that should be dealt with. I feel so sorry for the poor victim's family. Sounds like a cowardly attack by someone who lost face to me. I hope justice prevails.

Posted by David on October 20, 2010 13:25

gravatar

[quote]Informed diplomatic sources have told Phuketwan that the issue is unlikely to handicap the process.[/quote]
Let's hope so.

Posted by Mike Boyd on October 20, 2010 16:04

gravatar

Maybe you should consult with the Thai and British authorities about the way you cover this case.
In this article, you state that the security camera footage is 'incriminating'. Could that affect a jury's decision?

Posted by John Crystal on October 20, 2010 19:04

Editor Comment:

Thanks for your advice. I am not sure, though, about your qualifications for giving it.

Do you really want the media coverage of crimes and the application of the law to be controlled and overseen, as you suggest, by Thai and British authorities?

Britain and Thailand are both proud democracies, embodying the principle of an unfettered, free media.

Where is the jury in this case? In Britain? Unless there has been some recent change in the law, not in an extradition application. In Thailand? No. Thailand has no juries.

We certainly don't aim to prejudice a fair trial. And we consider our coverage fair and factual.

Fortunately, judges and magistrates in both countries are beyond influence by the media - good coverage, or bad coverage.

And that's as it should be.

gravatar

My point is that you say that the cctv footage is incriminating, when actually it is not. The man shown could need the knives for something else.

Aldhouse could claim that he will not have a fair trial in Thailand, due to biased media coverage in Phuket.

During a potential murder trial, all media should report within appropriate guidlines which ensure fairness.

Posted by John Crystal on October 20, 2010 20:11

Editor Comment:

What we've reported is that the footage is incriminating if the man in the image who looks like Lee Aldhouse is proven to be Lee Aldhouse. The evidence of the staff at the 7-Eleven store and the people around the store will, no doubt, be heard in determining the question of identity.

As I've said, judges in Thailand are not influenced by the media. Nor for that matter are judges in most countries.

As I've said, our coverage is fair and factual. We've made no presumptions of guilt.

Whose 'guidelines' are we supposed to follow? I must say, you seem to be making this up as you go along. What are your qualifications?

Perhaps we should make it clear:

If you are a judge or magistrate in Britain reading this, please make you decision based on the facts and the fairness of the case.

Likewise, if you happen to be a judge in Thailand who will be determining this case, please remember to make your decision after weighing all the evidence, not on the media coverage.

Thank you.

gravatar

Even if the footage is proven to be Aldhouse, I would still not say that it is incriminating. You are saying that seeing a man pick up knives in a store is incriminating in a murder trial, I don't think so, on its own.

There is not a completely free, unfettered media in Britain, because that is balanced against the right to a fair trial. We have a Contempt of Court Act which does not allow publication of anything which poses "substantial risk of serious prejudice" to a fair trial.

My original questions to you came from my knowledge of this act being applied in Britain. I don't need qualifications to ask questions!

Posted by John Crystal on October 20, 2010 21:21

Editor Comment:

No, you certainly don't, and I am sure we agree on the need for an honest and just result in this case.

Please do tell me, though, where the issue of ''influencing a jury'' comes into it? You raised that, not me.

The point is that you seem content to make a presumption of media bias while attempting to make a case for freedom from presumption of guilt. Unfair, John.

Without wishing to question your integrity, you presume too much.

We have no aim to breach Britain's Contempt of Court Act, nor does fear of it influence the factual nature of our reporting.

And we're not really keen on pursuing an extended debate involving your theorising about the rights and wrongs of this particular case. That would be unfair.

gravatar

It seems that appearing in court via video link is a new idea in the UK. You can probably find an article in the Guardian newspaper "The horror of virtual courts is upon us". There was also an article in yesterday's Financial Times about them, "Jury still out on ''virtual courts" ( needs registration or subscription ).

Posted by John Crystal on November 5, 2010 03:16


Tuesday May 7, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter