Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Chutima Sidasathian and fellow panelists at the FCCT last night

UPDATE Trafficking Can be Stopped, says Phuket Reporter: Pakistan Joins Global Outcry

Thursday, June 4, 2015
UPDATING All Day, Every Day

THE LAUNCH of a report by Thai Lawyers for Human Rights on the human rights situation after the military takeover, scheduled for release at the FCCT tonight, has been cancelled by police acting for the National Council for Peace and Order.

Original Report

PHUKET: Signs were good that the region had a real chance to end the human trafficking of Rohingya and Bangladeshis, Phuketwan reporter Chutima Sidasathian told a meeting in Bangkok last night.

But she warned that interruptions to the pipeline in the past had always been followed by resumptions and changes in the way the trade in people works.

''Asean must press Burma to cease pushing these people into the sea,'' Khun Chutima said. ''It's a challenge the region must face up to now.''

Khun Chutima appeared at the Foreign Correspondents' Club of Thailand on a panel with Lillian Fan, Research Associate, Humanitarian Policy Group, Overseas Development Institute, Matthew Smith, founder and executive director of Fortify Rights, and Jonathan Head, BBC correspondent.

The previous day, the Royal Thai Navy's criminal defamation case against Khun Chutima and her Australian colleague, Alan Morison, was raised when the Australian Ambassador, Paul Robilliard, met with the Prime Minister, Prayuth Chan-o-cha.

A request has been made to the Prime Minister by the two journalists to suggest that the Attorney-General quash the case, which a growing number of people see as an unjust and inappropriate use of military might against the media.

The journalists say they cannot in fairness apologise for republishing a controversial paragraph, written by Reuters journalists, unless Reuters apologises first. The paragraph does not mention the Royal Thai Navy.

Phuketwan has been consistently reporting on the plight of the Rohingya in Thailand since 2008.

Awareness of the trafficking issue is growing worldwide, with leading Pakistan politician Imran Khan writing a letter to UN Secretary-general, Ban Ki-moon, yesterday calling on the organisation to end ''the persecution and genocide'' of Rohingya in Burma.

''It is time for the UN to act decisively,'' he wrote.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

It is pleasing to see that His Excellency Paul Robilliard was able to make representations directly to the Thai Prime Minister.

The Thai government really should assert its authority over a Navy that has so far refused to acknowledge that it needs to change course. The cases just attract more adverse attention as the trial date of 14 July 2015 approaches.

The sooner the charges are dropped the better it will be for the Navy and for a government that is trying to persuade the world that it is serious about tackling human trafficking.

Posted by Ian Yarwood on June 4, 2015 20:36

Editor Comment:

What the Navy appears not to understand is that killing this case, perpetrated by one misguided officer, is wise. Everybody makes mistakes. A bigger mistake would be to stick by the mistake made by one officer. This case is clearly unjust and a blatant attempt to shut down Phuketwan. In democracies, the media and the military both have roles to play. The Navy seems to have failed to acknowledge the onset of the 21st century. Bullying is no longer acceptable.

gravatar

A report on human rights blocked reveals it was not a positive one.

Might just as well have had it published.

Posted by Herbert on June 4, 2015 21:09

gravatar

Ed

I think they understand.

Your side should be creative on how to provide they will not be losing a face, like it or not. It doesn't mean compromise on substance, it menas to compromise on form.

I myself do not have clear ideas on that, but probably if focus on this aspect, then some viable solutions can be identified.

Posted by Sue on June 4, 2015 21:09

Editor Comment:

''Losing face'' is less important than supporting the truth and not giving in to bullies. As honest journalists, we are never going to take responsibility for the mistranslation by the Navy of a paragraph written by Reuters. They can kill us. They can jail us. But we will continue to uphold the truth.

gravatar

Maybe, just maybe the scale of human trafficking would not have exploded as it did if the media had been allowed to perform its role in a democracy without excessive interference.

Now damage has been done to thousands of lives that cannot be undone. Problems have been created that could have been avoided.

Posted by Frank on June 5, 2015 08:47

gravatar

I hope the charge the arrested general with damaging the reputation of the army, the country and also charge him under the Commuter Crimes Act!

Posted by MoW on June 5, 2015 10:25

gravatar

If I was the Thai Government, I would immediately drop the case. Thailand is already in the international spotlight for the wrong reasons, no point attracting more unwanted attention. If they did start throwing journalists in jail, there would be serious consequences, like possible sanctions?

They are already on a short leash, with a yellow card being issued by the EU. It is better for them to focus their attention on improving human rights, which must be surely a high priority.

Posted by reader on June 5, 2015 11:18

gravatar

MoW

I agree with all the comments but I agree 1,000% that if there the allegations against the general are true then the damage he has caused the reputation of the army and Thailand is monumental.

Posted by Frank on June 5, 2015 13:01

gravatar

reader,
Your ability to solve problems makes you unsuitable for any government position.

Posted by MoW on June 5, 2015 14:02

gravatar

MoW

Your talents as a comedian have been duly noted. It is good to read some very funny comments on an otherwise serious string of topics. We all need some comic relief at times, so thanks for making me laugh this afternoon.

Posted by Frank on June 5, 2015 14:47

gravatar

Well thanks Frank,
There are many good contributors on various articles and I find it interesting to read how people from different backgrounds approach and consider these issues.
My favourite is of course Sue but I have the feeling he/she is busy with his/her new friend Caitlyn.

Posted by Manowar on June 6, 2015 12:24

gravatar

It is time for the Royal Thai Navy to "advance to the rear" if it does not understand how to retreat.

During WW2 during the battles along the Kokoda Track there was an interesting development. The Japanese high command realised that Port Morseby could not be captured. They also realised that with setbacks in other parts if the Pacific War there was no longer any strategic purpose in capturing Port Morseby.

Given that the Japanese did not understand "retreat" the order went out to their units on the Kokoda Track to "advance to the rear."

The Navy does not have a serious chance against Phuketwan but even if the Navy prevailed it would be a phyrric victory that would only bring shame to the Navy and Thailand.

That shame might help cement a place for Thailand at Tier 3 of the US Trafficking in Persons Report.

Posted by Matt on June 6, 2015 16:31


Saturday November 23, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter