Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Crowd of protesters and negotiators after the fatal Phuket crash

Since When is a Peaceful Protest on Phuket or Anywhere Else a 'Mob'?

Sunday, November 27, 2011
News Analysis

PHUKET: When shoppers in a North Carolina Wal-Mart are hit by police with pepper spray as they rush to buy discounted telephones, it's ''a disturbance.''

When people campaign under the Occupy Wall Street banner and the cause goes global, it becomes a worldwide ''protest movement.''

But when two villagers die on a dangerous bend in north Phuket and the locals, who have raised the matter of road safety there many times before, go out onto the streets, they are instantly labelled a ''mob.''

Phuketwan believes that even in the best governed nations of the world, there are times when the average person will consider himself or herself deprived of a voice.

At those times, there is only one choice: take it to the streets.

People who take disputes onto the streets are not necessarily a ''mob.'' That word has connotations usually associated with violence.

The Phuket villagers who blocked Phuket's main road after a crash last week that claimed the lives of two neighbors felt deeply aggrieved, and in our opinion had every right to express both their grievance, and their grief.

From all accounts, the protest was peaceful. There was undoubtedly anger but no violence, so we have been told, except for a small fire close to the vehicle involved.

For that reason, it's hard to understand how peaceful Phuket villagers could be labelled ''a mob.''

And there's a good chance that because the people went out into the streets to express themselves, a dangerous curve will - finally, finally - be made safe for all travellers, not just for the villagers.

If Phuket's authorities will not listen and act appropriately at the right time, especially when life and death issues are at stake, people on Phuket, as in all democracies, have the right to protest.

While the option should only be a last resort when all other avenues have been exhausted, Phuketwan believes there are times when street protests are justified - as in this case.

Only in repressed societies like China are street protests entirely prohibited. In democracies, they have to be tolerated. Gandhi did it, why not Phuket?

More power to this particular Phuket ''mob,'' and to all other ''mobs'' who think the way they do.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

I agree wholeheartedly with what you have said, which is why I commented in a similar vein on another news site. The use of the word mob implies disorder, not peaceful protest. If a few people were inconvenienced by the only way some people can draw attention to their cause, so be it.

Posted by Mister Ree on November 27, 2011 21:05

gravatar

A small fire? They tried to set the pick-up truck on fire. The same "peaceful" villagers have a reputation for beating up people who run of the road in "their" area. What else do you need before calling it an angry mob?

Posted by christian on November 27, 2011 21:17

Editor Comment:

Community concern about outsiders riding large vehicles through any village at speed, putting adults' and childrens' lives at risk, is hardly ''an angry mob.'' Prove what you say is true, Christian. Or are you one of the ''mob'' in the speeding vehicles?

gravatar

i seem to remember phuketwan reporting that the pickup involved was set on fire ay the villagers. are you saying you got it wrong?? or are you changing the story to suit your needs??

Posted by another steve on November 27, 2011 22:52

Editor Comment:

We're concentrating on analysing the issue of whether a crowd of grieving Phuket villagers is ''a mob.'' Feel free to quibble at the sites where nit-pickers are encouraged.

gravatar

isn't your whole article nit-picking and arguing semantics??
a crowd that sets fire to a pick-up truck can easily be construed as a mob.
if you don't want people to get this impression then don't report that they set fire to a truck..

Posted by another steve on November 28, 2011 08:08

Editor Comment:

So in your eyes, one person with a match turns a peaceful gathering of grieving neighbors into ''a mob.'' I thought you just attempted to make the point that getting it right is important. As with ''mafia,'' the loaded word ''mob'' is used too often to inflame the wrong kind of attitude.

gravatar

Ed

Driving through a village? Its the major arterial road connecting Phuket with the mainland, hardly a village road!

And one person with a match? I don't think a match can ignite a car on fire unless the driver unfortunately left the fuel tank open!

Posted by jimmy on November 29, 2011 00:14

Editor Comment:

I believe christian was referring to incidents off the main thoroughfare. Villages in this area and other parts of Phuket put out strips of rope to slow through traffic. And they do get upset if someone drives through at speed and causes harm.
What you say about the match is perfectly true, which is why the blaze was a sign of one person's anger rather than the destructive intent of the whole neighborhood.

gravatar

I'm not sure what the situation is with the villagers there. But, here in the US, it seems that whenever the media opposes a protest, they refer to them as an "angry mob". They often do that to the "Occupy" people.

Posted by dmbeast on November 29, 2011 01:43

Editor Comment:

Subjective descriptions do more harm than good. Blockades here on Phuket often are a last-ditch effort to right a serious wrong. While a street protest should always be a last resort, all blockades should be looked at as individual cases. To suggest that Phuket people should be denied the universal right to protest on the streets is plainly nonsense.


Wednesday November 6, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter