Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Phuket's Tsunami Wall and a memorial cemetery are drowning under weeds

Phuket's Tsunami Wall, Cemetery, a Wave of Weeds

Sunday, November 21, 2010
Phuketwan Opinion: Photo Album Above

TWO MAJOR memorials to the 5400 people who died when a tsunami struck the Andaman coast are now in a disgraceful state, with the sixth anniversary of the big wave barely a month away.

Phuket's Tsunami Wall of Remembrance is today a thicket of weeds, with no flags left on the flagpoles lining the wall. In some cases, even the poles are now missing.

North of Phuket at the Tsunami Victim Cemetery in Bang Maruan, markers above the graves of about 380 unnamed victims are drowning under weeds. Just a few can be seen.

The flags and the names of 39 countries are listed on a plaque at the cemetery gate. The nations are also listed along the wall on Phuket.

At last August's meeting between then-governor Wichai Praisa-ngob and some 22 honorary consuls and embassy representatives, the governor went to some lengths to point out that the Andaman tsunami warning system was in good shape.

However, since then, Andaman coast tsunami drills have failed to convince anyone that the system is functioning as it should.

Another real tsunami disaster in Indonesia that saw hundreds killed without warning has also done nothing to ease concern.

The fact that a series of drills is now scheduled this year, for the first time during the tourism high season, with the final tsunami drill on December 24, indicates that concerns are being taken seriously. The drill comes just two days before the tsunami anniversary.

But if the tsunami memorials to the 5400 dead are not being maintained, how can visitors be sure that a drill means that the warning systems are functioning properly?

Or will the weeds be growing over the warning system too, as soon as the world is not watching?
The Tsunami Toll One Year Later
The toll of the Indian Ocean tsunami is still misreported because of discrepancies that Phuketwan reporters discovered 12 months after the event. Here's what they wrote in 2005.
The Tsunami Toll One Year Later

The Tsunami: Week One Recalled
What was it like in that first week after the tsunami? Here one Phuket resident relates the story as it was reported in other places. This article has never appeared in print on Phuket.
The Tsunami: Week One Recalled

Tsunami Boats Now Attract Tourists
The village of Nam Khem, which means salt water, was a sad place during the tsunami but its fortunes have changed now. Tourists are welcome. Go to see the twin trawlers.
Tsunami Boats Now Attract Tourists

Killer Tsunami Raises Fresh Questions for Phuket
Latest People ignore the danger of a second big tsunami, hoping it will go away and trusting that officials have the warning system working. Hundreds of deaths in Indonesia indicate otherwise.
Killer Tsunami Raises Fresh Questions for Phuket

Phuket's Andaman Tsunami Nightmare Lives On
Phuketwan Opinion An exercise intended to show the world that Phuket and the Andaman coast are safe did just the opposite. It's high time the government got the tsunami warning system sorted.
Phuket's Andaman Tsunami Nightmare Lives On

Update: Phuket Tsunami Warning Buoy Floats Free
Phuketwan COMMENT In the latest blow to Thailand's tsunami warning system, the buoy in the protective frontline has broken free and then been recovered off the Phuket coast.
Update: Phuket Tsunami Warning Buoy Floats Free

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Good Story,

Think of all the help Thailand had from all the countries, groups and individuals around the world during that time and no respect is given to all the people that died during that time. Its a shame

Posted by Michael on November 21, 2010 18:40

gravatar

So, you think in order to be dramatic you have to link taking care of the tsunami memorial to the readiness of the tsunami warning system....No such linkage exists, shame on you! Journalistically and humanitarianly....And, the facts are that, even with an adequate warning system, there would not have been enough time for the Indonisians in the latest event to have reach safety...Sensationalism might sell newspapers, but it does not inform people....

Posted by Anonymous on November 21, 2010 19:09

Editor Comment:

Anonymous, we're not a newspaper. And you are drawing conclusions we don't make. If you can't see the connection between the 2004 tsunami deaths and an adequate warning system . . . we can't help you.

gravatar

Still no news on the state of the detection buoy that went adrift several months ago so apparently if no one takes care of that, it's unlikely that the memorials will be taken care of unless there is an important visitor.

Posted by Mac on November 21, 2010 20:13

gravatar

Thank you for pointing out the poor upkeep of an important site, hopefully someone will send in the gardeners. How much does it cost to clean up the place? I will sponsor some of it.

Posted by wm on November 21, 2010 20:36

gravatar

When I was the resident manager at the Phuket airport hotel, I used to cycle every afternoon up to the Wall of Remembrance and clear away the weeds and overgrown plants.

Unfortunately, I have been working away from Phuket for the past 18 months, but return on December 1 to restart my management of the hotel.

Since the Thai authorities do not seem interested, I will again be making it my priority to try to look after this important memorial.

Posted by Simon Luttrell on November 21, 2010 22:18

gravatar

Absolute disgrace

I'm sure Khun Wichai would be upset to see this deterioration. It would take one man, permanently employed, to re-paint, replace flags, and weed the site

This shows utter disregard for the feelings of the relatives of the deceased. AND creates a bad image of "Caring Phuket" to the world.

Posted by wellington on November 22, 2010 11:06

gravatar

You also forgot the several thousand Burmese that died and no one had asked for !
So shall we say min. 8000 deaht in Thailand.
The warning towers are made so lousy thst there is not even e alarm when some body steal the cables to them, that happend last year !
They can get GSM systems on each tower there gives alarm if something on each tower is broke etc. very simple !
But not in Thailand, they get a budget to install the system, but nothing to maintain it !
Look at the CCTV cameras at police stations, they installed a lot around the island, but how many is working now ?? 10% ?? Maximum !
It is a joke !

Posted by Karsten on November 22, 2010 16:56

Editor Comment:

The figure of 5400 is accurate. It includes the Burmese victims in Thailand - please don't rely on guesswork. We have spent almost six years examining the figures closely, and talking to everyone involved.

The warning towers are just one part of what's required to have an efficient warning system - and probably the least important part. Provided the next tsunami comes in daylight, radio and tv will report it, hopefully with sufficient time to do so. No problem. The real question concerns a tsunami that comes after dark, especially between midnight and 6am, when everyone is asleep. Who will warn you, Karsten?


Saturday November 23, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter