Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Island in distress . . . the beauty belies the pollution on Racha, off Phuket

Phuket's Tourism Future As Healthy As the Raya Father Canal

Friday, February 8, 2013
News Analysis

PHUKET: How many governments does it take to halt the environmental degradation that will eventually destroy Phuket's tourism industry?

We don't know . . . we are still counting.

Yesterday's umpteenth official tour of Racha island, a onetime day-trip ''paradise'' just a short speedboat ride from Phuket, demonstrated once again what the problems are.

In no special order, those problems are: lack of will, greed, lack of enforcement, selfishness, lack of vision, and a tendency to compromise.

The only absolute rule when it comes to ''protecting'' the natural environment on Phuket appears to be ''whatever you do, pretend everything is all right.''

And so outright lies, self-deception and lack of transparency are piled on greed, lack of will, lack of enforcement etc.

This is a part of the world where the dive industry will hold an underwater cleanup once or twice a year, pat itself on the back, and pretend that Phuket's coral reefs and beaches are in perfect shape.

What yesterday's tour of Racha exposed was that this self-deception extends to other segements in tourism, particularly among resort managements.

For instance, Racha resident and environmental activist Sarid Jandi said that dive companies dependent on the Korean and Chinese markets were moving from Phi Phi to Racha - because the coral reefs at Phi Phi had already been ruined.

Of particular note are the diving businesses that allow tourists to ''dive'' wearing helmets, without lessons, and that expose the corals to the risk of greatest damage.

The five-star Racha Resort, which has previously insisted that it does the ''right thing'' environmentally, admitted yesterday that its water treatment plant needs upgrading.

Every time the plant overflows, it mixes with untreated fecal material from the Raya Father restaurant and washes pure piss and shit down the local canal to the sea.

Others do even less to protect the environment. The Baan Raya ''system'' catches the fat from kitchen waste but lets the rest flow to the sea.

The main Racha drinking water supply now comes from an open dam, which catches rainwater. Wells are now considered too risky in most places because of the toxicity from years of burying unsorted garbage.

Worst environmental breaches are at the Rayaburi, where the resort's restaurant now extends onto a once-public beach, where a canal has been reduced to a trickle, and where there is no access to the privatised Siam beach.

Racha history says the beach was named Siam beach after Rama VI fended off an ''invasion'' from Malaysians. Now the once-public space has simply been taken from Thailand for private use.

It's the success of Racha that's the problem. About 1200 people are now estimated to deposit waste on the island each day, either as day-trippers, residents or as tourism industry staff.

Garbage generated by the island's success as a tourism magnet will kill it in the end. Yet those profiting from Racha's popularity seem content to leave the problems to others to fix.

Those who should have enforced the law to protect the island's environment for their children and for other Thais have, down the years, done little, or nothing.

What's wrong with Racha is what's wrong with Phuket. The wrong people run the reefs and the beaches, the people whose only interest is financial gain, not environmental protection.

The willingness of Thailand's governments to allow the privatisation of Phuket's beaches and reefs is a slow-working but sure death sentence for tourism's most important natural attributes.

When Racha poisons itself with pollution, garbage and disinterest, Phuket will know: its turn is coming next.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Fantastic analysis. Well done K. Chutima.

Posted by Duncan on February 8, 2013 09:44

gravatar

This article needs to be picked up by a national or international outlet. More people need to be confronted with the truth about environment degradation in Thailand until they can't ignore it any longer.

Posted by fakename on February 8, 2013 09:49

gravatar

Excellent article. Keep up the fearless reporting.

Posted by cammo on February 8, 2013 10:02

gravatar

Very good article. Phuket is looking like a large rubbish dump, although there are groups of well meaning people clearing up rubbish this is not enough. A few weeks ago the pot holes near my house were being filled in and the bags containing the filler just thrown on the road side. The government needs to act now before its too late. People will not want to visit a beautiful island full of stinking rubbish with very large rats running all over the place. Education for everyone.

Posted by Granitebeetle on February 8, 2013 10:42

gravatar

The natural beauty that attracted and endeared so many to Phuket is fading fast. Very sad indeed.

The time is quickly passing, if it has not passed already, to reverse this trend of self-destruction. Phuket needs some real leadership to step up and sort out its issues. And it's need to be done now.

Posted by Relox on February 8, 2013 13:37

gravatar

Well written article that needs to be given as much exposure & publicity as possible (national & international) until authorities including the Thai government are forced into meaningful action, before it is too late, if not already too late.

Posted by Logic on February 8, 2013 13:56

gravatar

Excellent article.

Posted by Harald on February 8, 2013 15:12

gravatar

Well said, Khun Chutima!

Posted by Fritz Pinguin on February 8, 2013 15:25

gravatar

[quote]
... and washes pure piss and shit down the local canal to the sea...
[/quote]

Khun Chutima, you are straight-talking, and this is what we need in Phuket, rather than the woolly excuses and "it's
not my responsibility" whining that the vast majority of business owners and government officials seem content to blurt out.

When I built my 3 small hotels in the north of Phuket, I made very sure that my project was able to supply enough ground water to meet the needs of all guests.

How many hotels do you know in Phuket that rely on early-morning deliveries of water by tankers for customer showers and toilets? Those hotels should never have been given building permission if they only 'survive' by shipping in water on a daily basis.

For my hotel sewerage system, I made sure that every room had an adequate sewerage system, with waste being stored in septic tanks and grey water being diffused via soakaways - all in line with accepted design practices.

Any business that dumps untreated sewerage into the Andaman Sea should see their company director jailed - no excuses!

Now I live and work in Myanmar, where 'shit and piss' is an unfortunate way of life in these very deprived communities. But Phuket has no valid excuse for these problems, - and I hope you continue to name and shame those greedy businesses who are destroying Phuket.

Simon

Posted by Simon Luttrell on February 8, 2013 19:54

gravatar

Is there any way this article published in Thai language? Thai authorities in charge generally don't read English news. They are the ones who should be aware of this or should be told more often.

Posted by Hansa on February 11, 2013 23:50


Saturday May 18, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter