Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

The new tower going up at Surin may be affected by erosion quickly

Phuket Lifeguard Towers May Not Last

Friday, September 4, 2015
PHUKET: Lifeguards on the holiday island of Phuket are gaining some new towers - but there's concern about whether the towers will last more than one or two years at the most.

The new towers are going in at Karon Surin and Kata Noi beaches, places where previous towers have collapsed.

However, lifeguards are concerned that the new towers, if they are all built like the one at Surin on the sand, will quickly topple once the annual erosion of the monsoon season undermines the foundations.

''The tower is going in at Surin actually on the beach, not on the foreshore where the old tower was,'' said one lifeguard today. ''The old tower took many seasons to topple but it was safer back from the water's edge.''

The cost of 1.6 million baht is being met by the Phuket Provincial Administration Organisation, the PPAO tourism department spokesperson Nararit Touyon told Phuketwan.

''There will be three new towers and repairs to other towers at a cost of 300,000 baht,'' he said.

At Kata Noi, where lifeguard duties have been taken over by the Katathani Resort, the lifeguards are already using a smaller, mobile tower of the kind that can be transported along the beach as conditions change.

The new lifeguard tower going in there is in a fixed position, and may not prove as effective.

Contracts for the three new towers are to be signed off on October 2.

In recent years, the towers have been used more as places to store equipment rather than as a lookout.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

It is understandable that all fixed structure can not last longer than one year because the lifeguards' contracts is for one year only.
Also every year with a new tower to rebuild some decision-makers get their tea money as self rewards.

Posted by WhistleBlower on September 4, 2015 17:38

gravatar

They will be ok. If they start to be underminded, jack them up, relevel or repack and replace. Then they will be ok for a few more years.

Posted by MoW on September 4, 2015 17:51

Editor Comment:

We are not quick to rush to judgement MoW but the Surin rebuild looks like a project that has happened without consulting the people who will actually use the tower. They would be quick to say: ''Anything on the sand won't last more than one or two serious monsoon storm weeks.'' You would have to be off your head to imagine that tower will last more than one or two years at the most. It's a sign of Phuket conceit. Do the acting president of the PPAO and the Governor think this is appropriate use of taxpayers' funds? Get real, please, gentlemen, about tourist safety and security. Create a Phuket Beach Authority and ensure the future of Phuket's beaches - and tourism.

gravatar

The Kata Thani idea is good and probably a lot cheaper. And maybe a hut only on the foreshore to store there equipment safely at night and dare you say could be used to store defibrillators and other essential first stage medical equipment

Posted by Michael on September 4, 2015 18:20

gravatar

Alan,
i cant comment on the location or the intended use. Sand when used with a reasonable sized pad does provide a good foundation. Im sure that during storms the edges will be subject to sand wash away but as long as its limited to the perimeter it will also repack around these edges.

If the concrete pad was exposed to continual wave wash it will eventually sink into the sand as saturated sand will behave more like a vicious liquid. The further it sinks below the sand surface, the stronger the sand will pack around the base until it will no longer move. Whether the subsidence occurs equally and level is probably the biggest issue as well as the protection provided to the steel support frame. Unless it was galvanised after fabrication it will start to rust at the connection to the concrete base, at each of the welded joints and in 5 or so years will need to be replaced due to continual exposure to salt contaminated spray.

My previous comment was based on what the pictures in the article show, a concrete pad of approx 2.5m x 2.5m x 100mm thick weighing 1.5 tonne would not be difficult to relocate or relevel even if storms did undermine the whole base.

Sue and I could do it in an hour with me on the shovel and Sue making sure the level was calibrated correctly.

Posted by MoW on September 4, 2015 19:02

Editor Comment:

There is no provision to maintain the concrete base, MoW.

gravatar

I overwhelming support a Phuket Beach Authority. I would love to see some sign of authority.

Posted by Pinot on September 4, 2015 19:38

gravatar

Four well rings stacked, filled with sand and a concrete plate on top would do the job. Price less than 1000 bath a piece.

Posted by Sherlock on September 4, 2015 20:49

Editor Comment:

On the foreshore, where the old tower was, would provide improved protection from erosion.

gravatar

I am no expert on construction but I have seen the project at surin. It looks like bags of rocks in a metal netting as a base on the sand with a concrete slab on top. Today the stainless steel structure in the photos appeared and is bolted to the base.

I was horrified to see the concrete being laid onto the actual beach rather than the foreshore which would have offered some protection at least.

Not entirely sure why authorities here don't use the same tried and tested towers as used successfully in the usa for example, they withstand hurricanes each year with no trouble at all.

Posted by Discover Thainess on September 4, 2015 21:28

Editor Comment:

The point is, there is no need for these towers at all. Lifesavers have moved on to rely these days on portable towers that can be moved to where the swimmers are safe. The rip currents move . . . so the towers also need to move. Simple, eh? Storage of equipment is a different issue and if monsoons wash away the base of a fixed tower, the equipment can't be safe there. All that has to happen is for the people who provide the funding to talk to the people who save the lives of the tourists - and listen to what they say. Why is that so difficult on an island that relies on tourism and in return, needs to protect their safety? Conceited Phuket, you've done it again.

gravatar

Building costs appear to have escalated in Phuket. Even if they topple or rust away in the first year, and they help to save lives then it is money well spent

Posted by Paul on September 5, 2015 07:31

gravatar

Yet another poorly planned and ineffective project. The lifeguards will also probably miss the old days where they sat around smoking and eating and visiting with friends and playing Candy Crush on their phones.

Posted by Richard Vickers on September 5, 2015 10:05

Editor Comment:

Living in the past, Richard? Short of something of value to say, so a little doomsaying becomes the alternative?

gravatar

why not build them on a pontoon the whole thing would float on high tide and settle on the sand at low just tie the whole thing to the nearest tree

Posted by ayjay on September 6, 2015 03:09

gravatar

Every phuket beach local knows the beach goes from flat and wide, in the high season, to very slanted and narrow, within a couple weeks when the low season starts.

Posted by Anonymous on September 6, 2015 09:09

gravatar

Anonymous,
Do the headlands move closer together during low season? That would explain why there sometimes appears to be more jetskis.

Posted by MoW on September 6, 2015 10:21


Friday April 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter