Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Key lifeguard staff at the contract signing in Phuket City this week

Lifeguards Must Be Given Better Deal

Sunday, May 17, 2015
Phuketwan News Analysis

PHUKET: Many people will heave a sigh of relief when the lifeguards return to Phuket's beaches from Wednesday.

To have Phuket without safety patrols on the 13 key tourist beaches for almost eight weeks is unacceptable.

Governor Nisit Jansomwong and Phuket Provincial Administrative Organisation President Paiboon Upatising really must make sure such a needless absence never reoccurs.

The contract for the next 10 months was finally signed at the offices of the PPAO on Friday.

But who will take responsibility for ensuring that Phuket does not go without beach lifeguards again?

The Phuket Lifeguard Service has done an excellent job in lifting the standards of the lifeguards, creating greater awareness of the need for safety, carrying out thousands of rescues and generally making Phuket a much safer destination for swimmers.

The Phuket Lifeguard Service deserves to be acknowledged as a necessary part of the island's vital protective forces, just like police and firemen.

Their contract should come up for renewal once in every three years, rather than every year, so those who take up the task of protecting swimmers at the beach have a sense of continuity and do not fear losing their jobs when the contract ends each March.

It may be that some people in the PPAO see this as a money-saving exercise. Perhaps there are even some who take pride in saving almost eight weeks of payouts to the lifeguards.

That would be a false economy. Phuket needs lifeguards on its beaches every day of the year, and we hope Governor Nisit and President Paiboon take steps to ensure that happens in future.

The 88 lifeguards and their administrative staff deserve the support of everyone on Phuket.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

arrangements abt equipment, training and related standard of service ..? govt fails in setting and requesting proper standard

if that standard would be set, it would easily lead to an sea that procurement for a year is wrong idea

moreover , part or biggest part of the equipment should be bought by the government and given for a use to lifeguards like boats etc.

in addition proper protocols should be desugned between lifeguards , Marine police and further Army who has e.g. helicopters ,and also embassies and farang volunteers.

Posted by Sue on May 17, 2015 17:02

gravatar

TAT brags about the billions that tourist revenue brings to Thailand & they cannot afford a small percentage for full time lifeguard cover & training - absolutely shocking!

Posted by Logic on May 17, 2015 18:19

Editor Comment:

TAT is a marketing organisation. The money is not the problem.

gravatar

Indeed, TAT is airing often smth, erh, detached from reality.

Posted by Sue on May 18, 2015 01:22

gravatar

Ifor one am not happy about the return of the lifeguards. Will they onceagain be blowing their whistles incessantly at people going for a sunset swim after 6pm.This is a frequent occurence at Nai Harn.What next ? 24 hour beach patrols to keep people out of the water between 6pm and 6am. Stop the whistles1

Posted by shadowcat on May 18, 2015 04:51

gravatar

They should also set up a talks.in local schools about the dangers of rip tides etc.
Should start at a young age and keep going through the school years.
I was brought up on the coast of south Wales where they have the third highest tidal range of about 15 metres, we were taught all about that. Here they should be teaching about rip tides and Tsunami safety.
There was one beach in the north of phuket where a young girl saved a lot of lives as she had learnt about tsunamis in school and knew the signs when the water went out, so everyone evacuated from the beach instead of going to see the flapping marine life as at a lot of other beaches.

Education is the key.

Mind you I too do get bothered by those whistles especially when you are attached by a leash to a board. Never seen the headline about a surfer drowning in phuket

Posted by Michael on May 18, 2015 08:06

gravatar

This is unacceptable. I will be calling the NCPO and talking with media to protest many times...

"The contract for the next 10 months"?

What is this 10 months? We need 12 months.

Not acceptable...

Posted by J on May 18, 2015 09:37

gravatar

Phuket beaches are left without lifeguards two months per year. The average number of drownings that occur on this island every month is documented in the news. Phuket's governor should take immediate and permanent action! Thank you

Posted by Marco on May 18, 2015 11:21

gravatar

Shadowcat!!!! Are you simply stirring or are you being serious. Should you be unfortunate enough to find yourself in a rip, I have no doubt that the whistle blowing lifeguards will be most welcome as they swim out to rescue you.It is unbelievable that anyone could make such an inane comment.

Posted by Tom Ultmann on May 18, 2015 11:34

gravatar

Wow Tom !Chill out. I am an everyday swimmer who doesn,t like being hassled at sunset when I go for a swim. Tom do you think the beaches should be patrolled until nightfall with everbody being forced to leave the water at a certain time or not?.These guys are Australian trained yet aussies don,t close their beaches because it is late.You can swim early or late when the lifeguards are off duty no problem.I have been surfing for more than 30 years and use rips to my advantage. Perhaps the problem is that many people in Thailand have very little water knowledge.In the ocean one needs to take responsibility for ones own safety.I don,t think that I am the only one who finds that end of day whistling anoying.
Swimming lessons anyone ?

Posted by shadowcat on May 18, 2015 13:51

Editor Comment:

You sound superior and uncaring about the safety of the vast majority, shadowcat. Most surfers care about others and are happy to obey if it's for the best interests of poor swimmers. Why aren't you?

gravatar

I agree with Shadowcat. Blowing whistles, closing beaches & intimidating swimmers was not part of my life saving training.

Posted by simba on May 18, 2015 14:59

Editor Comment:

How odd. Most lifesavers have to close beaches when they become unsafe. You must be one of the few lifesavers to be lucky enough to work on a beach that was always open.

gravatar

shadowcat

Swimming under twilight at hazardous beaches - and the Nai Harn beach****IS**** the hazardous one, objectively is unsafe.

Giving the number of accidents at hazardous beaches, and that beach patrons routinely ignore safety warning of lifeguards even those that appeared with backward look, life/death related in a particular case, there is a choice of policy for Thai lawmakers opal a country or local level: whether to consider obeyance of lifeguard instruction mandatory , a.k.a. of police officer ; and, accordingly, whether a kind of penalties should be established for non-following such instructions.
This,of course, excludes execution of discretion by individuals whether to take their own odds against of hazardous beach risks instruction by lifeguards, but I am more and more leaning toward adoption of such policy in statutes, as public interests seems to prevail here giving all other circumstances of the situation.

Posted by Sue on May 18, 2015 15:50

gravatar

Ed thatsounds like me. Superior and uncaring. Ever pulled someone in trouble out of the surf have we?
; Most surfers care about others and are happy to obey'. Obey what? Some guy blowing a whistle telling them to get out of the water because he wants to go home.Go home and leave me alone.
I repeat. IN THE OCEAN ONE NEEDS TO TAKE REPONSIBILITY FOR ONES OWN SAFETY!

Posted by shadowcat on May 18, 2015 16:03

Editor Comment:

Oh, a lifesaver shouting the obvious. Swimming in darkness is unsafe, which is why the Phuket lifeguards do the right thing in ordering people from the water, whether you like it or not.

gravatar

Ed . Agreed most lifeguards have to close beaches when it is unsafe. Totally. The issue here is when it is safe that the lifesavers blow their whistles to get everyone out of the water at sunset regardlessof surf conditions. If its not safe why are people allowed to swim at NaiHarn at ^6am regardless of the surf conditions or lifesaver working hours.What is wrong with a perfectly safe sunset swim without the high pitched whistles.
Here is North Bondi surf clubs number.001161293651717.
I am not talking about dangerous surf conditions. Are you ?

Posted by shadowcat on May 18, 2015 16:49

Editor Comment:

We know of tourists who have drowned by going for swims after dark. It's not safe for the Chinese and others who haven't been taught to swim. It's good to know that the lifeguards are doing what they are taught - to save lives by taking proactive precautionary measures. To have one or two serious swimmers able to break the rules sets the wrong example for those who are more liable to quickly be in danger. Ignorance about beach and beach safety is widespread among many tourists. If they are being properly protected, that's great. You should be pleased. North Bondi is a bit different. Perhaps it's time you understood the task of lifeguards here. To any non-swimmer, knocked off their feet by a small wave in darkness, the surf is always dangerous.

gravatar

10 month contract is ridiculous. As previously stated should be minimum 3yr contract. Phuket tourism revolves around the beaches and has a lot of tourists from landlocked countries holidaying. These tourists don't have the water awareness and swimming ability to handle some of the conditions. A lot of the locals are the same. Should be a no brainer to have this service 12 months of the year and through on going training things can only improve.

Posted by Mark on May 18, 2015 21:11


Friday November 22, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter