Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Frenchman Jean-Pierre Charles Dulary is transferred from Patong Hospital

Phuket Tourist's Body Washes Up: Frenchman Still in Coma, Fighting for Life

Tuesday, October 19, 2010
UPDATE

The body of 28-year-old Russian tourist Alexey Agapono was found by locals at Nai Thon beach at 4.30pm on Wednesday. French tourist Jean-Pierre Charles Dulary remains in a coma after a series of disasters on Phuket's beaches.

Original Report

A RUSSIAN tourist is missing, presumed dead, after a rescue operation to pluck him from rocks off a Phuket beach took hours instead of minutes yesterday.

By the time rescuers reached the rocks, three hours after they were called, the man had vanished.

The man's wife was reported to be distraught today after learning that, although the man had been spotted on the rocks, his rescue had failed and he was now presumed to be lost at sea.

That brought the number of people who have drowned, died or been lost at Phuket beaches to three in the space of four days - one seven-year-old Thai boy and two tourists from Russia.

A tourist from France, plucked from pounding Phuket surf, is narrowly clinging to life in a hospital in Phuket City.

The lifeguard catalogue of 64 rescues of swimmers along Phuket's popular west coast beaches in just one day yesterday highlights yet again the lack of proper warnings about dangerous conditions and currents during Phuket's April-November monsoon season.

Those 64 rescued yesterday included Chinese, Indians, Russians, Britons, French, Thais and Singapore-based expats.

But it was the disastrous failed rescue of Alexey Agaponov, 28, that brought into sharp focus all the flaws of Phuket's present warning and rescue system.

Phuket Marine Police Superintendent Panlob Pungpaga said today that the call for help from the lifeguards at Nai Thon beach, between Patong and the Phuket International Airport, came around 2pm.

A lifeguard spokesperson had told Phuketwan that the lifeguards had tried to get their dinghy to the rocks to rescue the man, but were in constant danger of capsize in the heavy surf.

Superintendent Panlob said that it took more than two hours to load a boat onto a trailer and proceed from the Marine Police depot in Phuket City to Nai Thon. By the time the rocks were reached, the man had vanished.

Superintendent Panlob said: ''This man's disappearance is not our fault. We have 30 members, five boats and one longtail. This is not enough to safeguard an island the size of Phuket.

''Everybody needs to make the point to tourists that the sea off Phuket can be unsafe at this time of year. There are always storms, big waves and dangerous currents. Phuket beaches can be dangerous at this time of year, even for the strongest swimmers.''

It is believed Mr Agaponov had been carried out by a current from the beach to the rocks. The lifeguard spokesperson said his wife also needed to be rescued.

The resort where they were staying, the four-star Naithonburi Beach Resort, had warned the couple that the beach was dangerous, the lifeguard spokesperson said.

The inability of Phuket's rescue system to deal with all eventualities was highlighted in March last year, when a dive boat sank off Patong, killing six tourists and the Thai cook.

Twenty-three survivors were left to float for hours within sight of Patong. An aerial survey would have spotted them within minutes. Instead, the survivors eventually managed to organise their own rescue.

While drownings in waters around Phuket have been reduced by half this year when compared to last year, there are still needless deaths occurring because of lack of thorough warnings, lack of properly trained or equipped rescue teams, or tourists ignoring warnings.

The lifeguard spokesperson provided Phuketwan with a list of Monday's rescues:

One Day On Phuket's Western Beaches


Nai Harn Beach
11.30am Russian tourist rescued after being pulled out by rip current
2 pm Frenchman pulled from surf, given CPR. Seemed to be ok

Kata Noi Beach
11am Expat of undetermined nationality pulled from the surf

Karon Beach
1. Russian, pulled out by a rip current, then rescued
2. Russian girl, about 30, pulled out, rescued
3. Three men rescued, in front of Thavorn Beach Resort
4. Close to Karon circle, Korean man, 26, pulled out by rip, rescued
5. Near landmark dragon sculpture, Russian man, 20, couldn't get back to the beach by himself. Lifeguard helps him back
6. In front of new Centara Grand Resort, Russian man, 26, pulled out by current. Given CPR then send to Patong Hospital, x-rayed, seemed ok

Bang Tao Beach

1. Lifeguard pod in front of Dusit Thani, Laguna Phuket
10am Russian man, pulled out by current
6 pm Young Russian boy, pulled out by current

Surin Beach

In front of the car park
11.50am Three expats from Singapore, pulled out by the current: named as Scott Foster, Kenneth Foster, Craig Foster
6 pm Two expats from China, helped back with a lifeguard float: named as Ms Jasmine Neale and Mr Ben Taylor

Patong Beach

1. Lifeguard pod in front of Ocean department store
12:30 pm Two Indian men rescued
12:45 pm One Russian woman helped from the sea
2pm French tourist rescued
3 pm British tourist rescued

2. Lifeguard pod in front of Soi Bangla
11.40am. Two Russian women helped from the water
1pm Four Indian men helped from the water
1pm Two Russian men helped from the water
1.15 pm One Russian woman helped from the water
1.20 pm A Frenchman helped out
2.20 pm Two Indian men helped from the water

3. In front of Loma Park (Jet ski people help a lot here)
11am Four Chinese men helped from the water
Noon Chinese woman helped out
Noon Five Thai people helped from the water
1pm One Russian man helped out
1.15pm Six expats, nationality unknown, helped out of surf
2.30pm Three Russian men assisted from the water
2.45pm Five Frenchmen helped. One is quite ill, requires CPR, sent to Patong Hospital and later to Vachira Hospital in Phuket City
3 pm Two Russian men need help

4 . Pod at northen end of Patong
Noon Indian man needs help
12:20pm Two Indian men require assistance
2.30pm Two young Thai boys helped from the water

Nai Thon Beach

Noon In front of Naithonburi Beach Resort, two Russians in trouble. Woman is rescued. Alexey Agaponov, 28, is missing
French Tourist Fights For Life: Day of Disasters
Latest One French tourist is fighting for his life in hospital, a Russian is stuck on an offshore rock, and two other Russians had a narrow escape from drowning.
French Tourist Fights For Life: Day of Disasters

Phuket Russian Rescues Raise Swim Alert Issue
Latest Safety in the water at Phuket beaches remains an issue even though latest figures show that the drowning toll on the island has been dramatically reduced.
Phuket Russian Rescues Raise Swim Alert Issue

Russian Tourist, Boy Dead at Phuket Beaches
Latest Two deaths at Phuket beaches inside 24 hours highlights once again the dangers in the water, with Russians especially needing rescue at two other beaches.
Russian Tourist, Boy Dead at Phuket Beaches

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

That is terrible, my heart goes out to their poor families. What a tragedy.

I do find it hard to accept that the fault lays with the Thais so much and their lifeguard system. I work in the bays and waters in Phuket and know first hand how little tourists listen to warnings and guidance, especially from Thai people.

Perhaps if these tourists respected the signs, the warnings then this would not happen. Instead they seem to think that they know better than the locals and go on in anyway.

At best its ignorance, at worst it could be construed as extreme arrogance and racism.

Posted by sailorgirl on October 19, 2010 15:40

Editor Comment:

Warnings on the beach beyond the signs are too late. All tourists need to be warned three times before they get to that point. Not too many people who reach the water at a Phuket beach are going to be dissuaded not to go ahead and do what they came to Phuket to do. It's basic human nature, not arrogance or racism.

gravatar

You need a portion of the marine rescue equipment stored on the north of the island for these circumstances, just like they do with the car crash equipment. It cuts the response time in half.

Posted by Philip on October 19, 2010 17:36

gravatar

What planet are you on sailorgirl? This has nothing to do with racism. Just ordinary people who are ignorant of the risks.

Posted by Mac on October 19, 2010 17:36

gravatar

Sorry Editor, Firstly sincere condolences to the families affected.
But I have to agree with some of Sailorgirl's comments as I have witnessed myself the arrogance of some tourists during my last visit to Kata in May 2010.

I felt extremely sorry for the poor lifeguards trying to do their job as they were being totally ignored by the tourists venturing into the surf, despite the red flags flying.

Even outside the Red flag ( safe area) area the undertow was very strong and we only went up to our knees and I commented I don't think we will swim here today and I am a good swimmer, as were the rest of my party.

Yes, the Lifeguards could use more training and equipment, and I did try and involve a certain sector of professional Lifeguards here in Australia to try and help and will continue trying.

But some of those same people who abused and ignored the Lifeguard we also observe treating some of the local vendors like second class people . . . So I tend to agree with Sailorgirl at best its ignorance.

Posted by Lozza on October 19, 2010 18:06

Editor Comment:

Or lack of adequate warnings at the right time, or a combination of ignorance and the desire to swim while on a beach holiday. Like I said, there is no turning people back at the water's edge. It just won't happen. That's human nature, not arrogance. Anyway, the outcome is the issue, not the motivation.

gravatar

Monsoon season in April ????

Posted by Frits on October 19, 2010 18:37

Editor Comment:

The day when the beaches change from being tranquil and relatively safe to rough and risky seems to vary from early to late. I am not sure the waves abide by calendars. Is there an expert who can tell us when the monsoon season begins and ends?

gravatar

Dear Editor,
You do have a point about a combination of ignorance and a desire to swim whilst on a beach holiday ... But if you choose to swim after being advised not to because you desire to swim just because you are on a beach holiday ... then is that not arrogance ?

And yes maybe there is need to be some form of leaflet hand out at the immigration checkpoint to incoming passengers printed in the languages by the most visitors that frequent Phuket.

And whilst that might help .. If you look at Bondi and Surfers Paradise in Australia there is many rescues each year despite all the warnings and they are not only tourists ... just people that are ignorant of the dangers of the beach.

Posted by Lozza on October 19, 2010 18:51

Editor Comment:

There are certainly cases of arrogance. But more often, the problem is ignorance. The system needs to remove both problems. If a tourist has been warned on the incoming flight, again on check-in, and again with signs at the beach, then Phuket has done its bit . . . except for the rescue. Tourists (and residents) should not be allowed to drown because of arrogance, or ignorance. A triple whammy on the plane, at the resort and on the beach is best. In my experience, pamphlets at Immigration are ignored. It's not a time when you pause to read and think. Australia is upgrading its warning system because of an increasing toll. They are planning to warn passengers in-flight.

gravatar

Maybe the answer is to have the Police order people out of the water. Otherwise this will always be a problem.

Posted by Antz Pantz on October 19, 2010 19:02

Editor Comment:

Phuket doesn't have enough police to take that option. There are only 1100 police on the island. Divide that by three eight-hour shifts, and you begin to understand the size of their task. There are probably some days, though, when some beaches should be closed. Nobody in the water, full stop. Who enforces that has yet to be sorted, because it's a measure nobody wants to see happen.

gravatar

Dear Editor,

Yes in flight warnings would be helpful .... Some resorts do post warnings but I think most would not because of the fear of losing customers.

And thank you for a constructive discussion ... Keep up the good work.

Posted by Lozza on October 19, 2010 19:24

gravatar

@Antz Pantz: I was ordered out of the sea at Karon about seven years ago by a lifeguard. He stood at the waters edge shouting and signalling me to get out. I did.

I don't know why it's such a problem now.

Are there not enough lifeguards now or don't they walk up and down the beach any more?

Posted by Mike Boyd on October 19, 2010 19:30

Editor Comment:

People who are ignorant of the system will swim where they choose rather than between the flags patrolled by the lifeguards. There will always be tourists coming who do not know the system - and some who have never even seen a beach. Hence the need to warn once on flights in the appropriate language, twice on check-in in the appropriate language, and a third time in international signage at the beaches.

Without clearly defined places to swim, long beaches would require scores more lifeguards. Even with defined places, there will never be enough lifeguards.

gravatar

Not every body can't swim, some of us came here to swim and surf and know what we're doing. Many of these people have also saved many people and brought back many dead.Yes monsoon has come in April and some times the storms have come in March. Each year the weather patterns change.

Posted by Brian on October 19, 2010 20:41

gravatar

One Day On Phuket's Western Beaches.

Wow. That is incredible. First hand information on what really goes on at the beaches. Great info. Thanks Phuketwan for caring.

Posted by Lena on October 20, 2010 02:28

gravatar

I don't understand how a warning on a plane, or three warnings anytime can stop people going in the water when they have already decided that they know best, they know better than the locals, and they want to go swimming.

I personally only believed how dangerous it was being almost in need of saving myself.

Are any of the signs in Russian? seems to be a lot of Russians pulled out of the water.

Posted by sailorgirl on October 25, 2010 11:56


Friday April 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter