Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Rooms 4 and 5 at the Laleena: Investigators returned on Friday

Phi Phi Riddle: Fresh Check at Laleena Guesthouse

Saturday, May 23, 2009
A TEAM of investigators went to the Laleena Guesthouse on Phi Phi on Saturday to probe the cause of the mysterious deaths of two women tourists on the holiday island.

The owner of the Laleena, Rat Chuped, said the team of about eight officers turned up without warning. She thought they were from the provincial Public Health office.

They took samples from ground-floor Rooms 4 and 5 at the guesthouse.

The two dead tourists, one an American and the other a Norwegian, fell ill in the adjoining rooms on May 2.

Jill St Onge, 27, from Seattle, and Norwegian Julie Michelle Bergheim, 22, showed similar symptoms and died within hours of each other at the local hospital.

''I was not told the officials were coming,'' Khun Rat said today. ''They did some work on the air-conditioning units and took away the filters, I think.''

Khun Rat has rejected a suggestion that she should close her guesthouse.

''That won't bring the two women back. As far as I am concerned, there is no problem with my guesthouse,'' she said.

''If I close Laleena, how am I going to put food on the table?''

Khun Rat says she has since slept in one of the rooms where the dead women were staying and is confident her guesthouse has no connection with whatever caused the two deaths.

Two guests remain at Laleena. They are relatively new guests, although at one stage earlier this month, Khun Rat said she would probably only keep the guesthouse open for the customers who were there at the time.

Speculation continues about the cause of the deaths. Toxicology tests on tissue samples taken from the bodies are being carried out in Bangkok.

Khun Rat told Phuketwan today that one of the investigating officers said on Saturday that the results could take many weeks.

Laleena has 10 rooms, five of them air-conditioned. Guests on the first floor, above Rooms 4 and 5, and in rooms at the rear, suffered no ill effects that day or night.

Khun Rat, her housemaid and two children slept in a room nearby, closer to the water recycling plant than the occupants of Rooms 4 and 5.

The plant has been targetted by some observers as a potential source of gas.

When Phuketwan last heard from American Ryan Kells, 31, who was travelling with Jill St Onge, he suggested via an email that he considered methane might be a cause.

But why were only the four people in those two rooms affected, not others? That remains part of the mystery.

Epidemiologists involved in the case told Phuketwan today from Bangkok that they had no knowledge of the latest check and were not involved.

Since the deaths, Ryan Kells has returned with his fiancee's ashes to the US while Ms Bergheim's younger, unidentified female travelling companion is believed to have returned to Norway.

This week the local newspaper in Los Altos, California, reported that Ryan Kells had returned to the town where he went to high school to be with his mother and father, Beby and John.

A report in the 'Los Altos Town Crier' said: ''Adding furor to the tragedy was the lack of responsiveness from authorities, according to Kells family members.''

John Kells was quoted as saying: ''Our objective is to make sure an investigation is thoroughly undertaken. Assumptions were made very quickly.''

At the time, the Kells flew flew to Bangkok to help their son cope with the ordeal.

'''We want to be very careful not to speculate,''' Mr Kells told the Crier. But both he and his son remain suspicious that the air conditioning carried a toxic gas.

Ryan Kells noticed a strong chemical odor when he and Miss St Onge checked in at the Laleena room on May 2.

Phi Phi, between the Krabi mainland and Phuket, is about 45 minutes by speedboat from Phuket and longer by ferry.

The Laleena opened a year before the 2004 tsunami swept over Phi Phi, killing more than 800 people.

Since then the island has fully recovered, with visitors continuing to holiday there in substantial numbers.

Phi Phi Mystery Deaths: The Room Maid's Account
Phi Phi Photo Album Thai guesthouse maids have a way of knowing what goes on and the maid at the Laleena on Phi Phi was close to two mysterious deaths. This is her account.
Phi Phi Mystery Deaths: The Room Maid's Account

Why Pursuing the Truth Matters for Tourism
Opinion/Analysis Does it matter if the truth is never known about mishaps that kill tourists on and around Phuket? It matters because of trust. Only once the whole truth is told can trust be restored.
Why Pursuing the Truth Matters for Tourism

Dead Tourist 'Pushed off Phi Phi': Boyfriend
Latest The boyfriend of an American who died in strange circumstances along with a Norwegian woman on Phi Phi has rejected suggestions that they argued.
Dead Tourist 'Pushed off Phi Phi': Boyfriend

Phi Phi Deaths: No Word on What Killed Women
Latest Inquiries were continuing today into the mysterious deaths of two women who occupied adjoining rooms at the same Phi Phi guesthouse. Several rumors have been discounted.
Phi Phi Deaths: No Word on What Killed Women

MediaWATCH: Tourist Death Theories Abound
Latest Internal Security Act coming for Phuket; International media seek clues to the deaths of two Phi Phi tourists; why travel is not dangerous; a swim to Burmese heroine Suu Kyi.
MediaWATCH: Tourist Death Theories Abound

Phi Phi Deaths: Paradise By Day, Party By Night
Take the Tour The deaths of two tourists on Phi Phi remain a mystery as speculation continues about the cause. The island, visited by day trippers in sunshine, also parties long and hard.
Phi Phi Deaths: Paradise By Day, Party By Night

Phi Phi Deaths: Cause 'May Take a Month or More'
Latest Relatives and friends of two women who died in strange circumstances on Phi Phi will probably have to wait several weeks before they learn the cause, and so will islanders.
Phi Phi Deaths: Cause 'May Take a Month or More'

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Phuket Wan omits info Ryan Kells and female Karina Refsth, companions to the deceased were taken ill too, but recovered.
If those rooms were air conditioned and thus sealed off from fresh air, and a sewage smell was reported (in the Los Altos report; http://www.losaltosonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=17619&Itemid=46 )
then perhaps it was chemical fumes from the drains.

Editor: The article says: ''But why were only the four people in those two rooms affected, not others? That remains part of the mystery.''

Posted by Steven Green on May 24, 2009 09:35

gravatar

Well it is about time that someone took some samples, who ever they are!

Posted by VFaye on May 24, 2009 10:23

gravatar

Saw that a person with bacterial disease legionellosis was recently in the South? Does this have any bearing on this case, I wonder.

QUOTE
""Meanwhile, the Public Health Ministry's Disease Control Department said it was notified by the Portuguese government of a suspected case in which a citizen came down with a high fever and fell ill upon his return from a trip to Thailand.

Dr Passakorn Akkharasewi, director of the department's Epidemiology Bureau, said the man was diagnosed in Portugal with the bacterial disease legionellosis.

Passakorn said the man took a direct flight to Thailand, stayed in two hotels in Bangkok and the South, and then flew back to Portugal before experiencing the symptoms.

Staff at both hotels have been interviewed and asked to sanitise the rooms in which the man stayed as a precaution, said Passakorn.""

LINK
http://www.nationmultimedia.com/2009/05/23/national/national_30103432.php

Posted by tc on May 24, 2009 16:35

gravatar

Speculation: Fumes from the drains were harmful ONLY in those rooms that were air-conditioned, thus sealed off from fresh air.
A " Sewage smell" is a very important clue and both survivors report it. Read the Los Altos report carefully

Editor: The Los Altos report is the first mention I've seen of sewage, as against a chemical smell, although Ryan Kells has referred to methane. The Crier report also says the women died at the guesthouse. They both died in hospital.

Posted by Steve Green on May 25, 2009 09:29

gravatar

Yeah, they both died at the hospital right after leaving the guesthouse. It sure wasn't the hospital that made them sick, possibly not the guest house either, but why 3 weeks before this team arrives at Laleena to investigate? That's one thing I want to know, the other is what was determined as the cause of death?

Editor: The results of the autopsies may take some time because toxicology is not a speedy process. It is unusual, though, to have a second search for clues.

Posted by John on May 29, 2009 20:05

gravatar

We still have no answers on the death of Jill St.Onge and Julie M. Bergheim. It has been 16 months and the families waiting to hear what went wrong, what took the lives of two young women on the island of Kho Phi Phi. Laleena guest house.(the name, we are told, has been changed since their deaths)

Posted by Beby Kells on September 5, 2010 07:38


Friday May 26, 2017
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter