Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Surin beach, looking attractive without masses of sunbeds

High Noon for High Season as Phuket Tourists Face Confusing New Beach Rules

Tuesday, October 27, 2015
PHUKET: Beachlovers bringing their own equipment to some of Phuket's favorite beaches will only be able to stay in the ''10 percent zone,'' Mayor Ma-Ann Samran said yesterday.

Beaches affected by this rule in Mayor Ma-Ann's Cherng Talay area include Bang Tao, Laypang and Surin - and probably all popular west coast tourist beaches.

Mayor Ma-Ann told Phuketwan that he believed the ''10 percent zone'' rule, a compromise to keep some vendors content, is against the law and confusing.

Despite misgivings, he was obliged to introduce it and enforce it.

''The beach arrangements are very difficult for authorities to implement and the 10 percent rule is unclear and does not benefit tourism,'' he said.

''If the Governor wants the 10 percent rule then it should be for the tourists only, not businesses. Tourists can sit on the beach anywhere, but if they want to use umbrellas or chairs then they must go to the 10 percent area.

''No business should operate in the 10 percent area.''

Mayor Ma-Ann said his main concern about the ''10 percent zone'' rule was its confusing nature and the many different interpretations still being discussed with the holiday island's premium high season beginning on November 1.

''The police, the military, the governor and the council have different ideas on what the 10 percent rule means,'' Mayor Ma-Ann said.

''Tourists need information on what they can, and can't do. We need to be clear on what 10 percent means. Phuket has to agree on this.''

Mayor Ma-Ann said he continued to urge Governor Jamleran Tipayapongtada to be strong enough to clean up the beaches and not have any business conducted on the beach.

Earlier this year, Mayor Ma-Ann ordered no business to be to conducted on Laypang beach.

Mayor Ma-Ann said he believed about 60 percent of workers who previously worked on the beaches now had new jobs. He urged hotel owners in Bang Tao and Laypang to help the others to find new jobs off public beach areas.

A decision on the way forward at Phuket's beaches has been in doubt since the military took charge in Thailand and ordered all illegal commerce cleared from public space along the sands and foreshores.

At that time, the strangest decision was a total ban on sunbeds and beach chairs, leaving veteran European visitors who have been visiting Phuket for decades, to make do with mats at sand level.

Tourists were also banned from bringing their own sunbeds, beach chairs and umbrellas, with former Governor Nisit Jansomwong declaring that only 10 percent of each beach could be used for umbrellas, mats and commercial activities.

With the confusing policy on sunbeds and umbrellas still unresolved, and all restaurants and beach clubs on the shorefront at Surin beach likely to be bulldozed by early next year, tourists are likely to react - either favorably or unfavorably - to the changes.

Meetings to discuss beaches in other districts on Phuket are scheduled for today and tomorrow. A final decision about Phuket's beach rules is expected on Friday.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

"Earlier this year, Mayor Ma-Ann ordered no business to be to conducted on Laypang beach."
Maybe he'd like to make the short journey from his office and see that there are a dozen businesses operating on Laypang beach.

Posted by sid on October 27, 2015 09:47

gravatar

Blimey !!

They are trying to regulate Sunbeams now ?? (Para 16)

Maybe they can use something to make sure the sunbeams only cover 10% of the beach as well so tourists unable to bring umbrellas can sit in their artificial shade ! What a fabulous idea !

On a more serious note, my mother who is in her 80s will want to sit on the beach at Christmas and will most certainly need a beach chair so she will bring her own. It will be a brave policeman or official who asks her to move. She may be old but is very handy with her walking stick !! :-)

Posted by Discover Thainess on October 27, 2015 10:07

gravatar

My understanding is that ALL public areas including beaches and parks are for the people... NOT FOR ANY BUSINESSES. So in other words, people can go to these public areas to relax and enjoy whenever / however they like so long as no business transactions are taking place on the public land. How this 10% deal ever came to fruition i will never know.

Posted by DG on October 27, 2015 10:59

gravatar

I'm guessing it will be the 'not so high' season this year. Peak season is always busy but it will fall away pretty quick after that.

I remember the days when older Germans and Scandinavians would roll up in November and stay until after Songkran. Not anymore it seems.

Posted by Arun Muruga on October 27, 2015 11:57

gravatar

And the foolishness continues. It continues to baffle me why something so simple can be made so ridiculous. And I think Ma-Ann has it backwards. Tourists should be able to sit wherever they please, and bring their own chairs and umbrellas...but NOT in the 10% zones. Business should be limited to the silly 10% areas. That way, if tourists want services, they can go get them...but if they want to be left alone and enjoy a beautiful day at the beach without being badgered by vendors every 30 seconds, then they should be able to do that.

Posted by Richard Vickers on October 27, 2015 12:42

gravatar

First and foremost the beaches are public land and no business should be allowed on it. Tourists should be free to bring there own umbrellas and chairs and sit where they like. The thinking on this subject has hit the unbelievably ridiculous. The Governor recently spoke about world class destination, asking people have they been abroad. Well i ask him what world class destination has this ridiculous set of bizarrely thought out rules. I would say none of them.

Common sense seems to have been abandoned in this whole fiasco and in the end the e only thing being damaged is Phukets reputation.

Posted by Ciaran on October 27, 2015 13:30

gravatar

Maybe Mr. Ma-Ann could ask these hotels to take over our stuff too.

It's not only the beach vendors, who have no work anymore.
We are sadly forced to discharge our room maids, because we only have 10 % bookings in comparison to the last years.

They worked for 15 years in our resort. Now they are even not longer able to pay their bills, like health insurance for their children and so on.

Janeeta
Ginis Beach Resort

Posted by Janeeta on October 27, 2015 13:40

gravatar

WHO wants to buy a jetski with me if you can not beat them join them. only way to solve this matter.

Posted by reg on October 27, 2015 14:14

gravatar

This whole thing is a joke!...How on earth can the gov't make going to the beach so complicated?...Geez! The average tourist needs a doctorate in physical logistics to be able to figure out when and where they can relax on a beach around here.

Posted by sky on October 27, 2015 15:29

gravatar

With these unfavorable decisions for us pensioners (68 and 68), we decided not to come to patong one month for the new season.
Reservations planes become too expensive if we wait, so we will go to Egypt where there are chairs and parasol
Sorry.

Posted by De Smet Dornez on October 27, 2015 16:13

gravatar

My 83 y.o. mother has decided to give Phuket a miss this holiday. She says there was little to entice her back after her April visit earlier this year. She will spend all her vacation in Chiang Mai & Korat from here on.

A profound statement from someone who has visited Phuket twice a year for the past 20 years for 1 month each time. One small tourist BUT it all adds up.

Posted by Logic on October 27, 2015 17:35

gravatar

Tourists should be disobedient and ignore these rules and enjoy the beaches for what they are, public beaches
Can you imagine thousands tourists being taken to Phuket jail ? never !

Posted by Paul on October 27, 2015 19:28

gravatar

The last thing tourists want to do when they come to an island surrounded by gorgeous beaches like Phuket is think. The only thing the want to do is relax. Phuket, your beach rules are just nonsensical and confusing. Tourists want to leave Phuket with a smile, not a headache. Richard Vickers, I agree with you. Allocate the businesses to the 10% area and let the poor tourists bring their chairs & umbrellas and sit where they like.

Posted by Paradise on October 27, 2015 22:17

gravatar

Indeed, tourists want to relax on the beach, by preference on a comfortable beach chair and without noisy beach clubs who ruin the beautiful sunset...

Posted by Vince on October 27, 2015 23:32

gravatar

Just back from time in Bali. Walked kilometes of clean beaches, no vendors, Jet ski,beach chairs or umbrellas, and lots of tourists.

Posted by Byron on October 28, 2015 13:16

gravatar

Is there here any beach goinger who ever have spoke at a beach with a thai authority person who is part of new beach ruling?
Sometimes I feel the Phuket authorities see the Phuket beaches as being a cinema without chairs.
They tell you were to sit, not to smoke, and don't step over the lines.
But cinemas get cleaned, the beaches not, Cinemas have free toilets, the beaches have not free toilets, ( if they have toilets, Nai harn Beach has no toilets, no showers).
Here is a task for Phuket authorities, upgrade your beaches ( clean them, provide free showers and toilets), before you regiment tourists how and were to sit.

Posted by Kurt on October 28, 2015 16:47

gravatar

It seems the vast majority of tourist want umbrellas and sun beds..

People on vacation do not want to have to buy and set up these things..
Vacations are for rest..

Not for having to invest in and carry around a bunch of stuff and then only to be able to set up on 10% of the beach.

We want to relax is that so damm hard
to understand...

Posted by Bob on October 28, 2015 19:33

gravatar

will there be a limit on the size of a had brim that provides shade next ?

Posted by mike murphy on October 28, 2015 22:20

gravatar

Wel said Bob!

Posted by phet on October 29, 2015 04:17

gravatar

Why all this beachrols when there is no police ho give a dam.

Posted by El marinero on October 29, 2015 07:31

gravatar

Well, there is still hope for Phuket beaches.
Phuket authorities in aircon offices make alien beach rules. That is for the paper, which is patient.
As the culture here is not to enforce laws, not even talk about rules, the 'soup will not be eaten as hot it is served'.
Do as the thai do, and feel free. Sit with your own stuff at the beaches were you want.
They will not arrest you and make themselves the laughing stock of the world in next day worldwide newspapers and tv stations.

Posted by Kurt on October 29, 2015 10:02

gravatar

This is just laughable, you could not make it up (unless you are in Thailand).
Sadly there will be mass confusion during the "high"? season,and no doubt many re thinks and policy changes during the season which will only add to the mayhem.
So 10% it is but the jet skis get 50% plus ? talk about double standards

Posted by LES on October 30, 2015 17:57

gravatar

The beach issues is important to Patong's tourism industry. I love in a tourism area in the USA and am well aware that tourists can find other places to go when the believe they are not welcomed by the tourism community. Get rid of the jet skis and psrasailing or make a 3 percent rule for them. Allow beach chair and umbrella rentals, but make the vendors put them in place at the time of rental and remove them as soon as a customer leaves. You should have a place for purchase of beer, soda, etc. Let beach gorrs bring their own chair and umbrella if they like. But get rid of the jet ski business!

Posted by Bill on November 9, 2015 14:33


Friday April 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter