Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Here's the way the Phuket dream was  sold to the public . . .

Hearts, Minds, Sunbeds and Tuk-Tuks

Wednesday, July 23, 2014
PHUKET: The future of Phuket is likely to be decided over the next few months as honest police and soldiers attempt to tame the taxi and tuk-tuk ''mafia'' and try to end the holiday island's addiction to corruption and graft.

After early success resulting in scores of arrests of taxi drivers and their alleged sponsors and the clearing of commerce from all of Phuket's beaches, the newly-arrived enforcers have begun to realise the enormity of the task.

Those who want a return to Phuket's old ways are quietly staging a rearguard guerrilla action, and time is on their side.

Beach vendors and the tuk-tuk and taxi drivers know that Phuket's regular enforcement processes are weak.

They are biding their time in the belief that the sudden upsurge of tourist traffic in late October and November will force the ''good guys'' to retreat.

Once the Region 8 police team and the Army pull back, it will be business as usual, they believe. In the middle are some local Phuket officials who will swing to support either side, as it suits them.

Phuketwan believes that Region 8 Police Commander and Task Force Chief, Major General Panya Mamen, is now reassessing levels of support among Phuket's police officers and redefining a strategy for enforcing the law more widely, on all fronts.

He is even beginning an operation by a Region 8 police team to target officials who allegedly conspired with fraudsters to steal tracts of land from Phuket's Sirinath National Park.

The major general's team is working independently of a Department of Special Investigation operation.

''We are going to arrest them all [the crooked government officials] for not doing their jobs,'' he told Phuketwan yesterday.

With Region 8 Police Headquarters shifting to Phuket shortly, it has become obvious that Major General Panya has no intention of allowing Phuket to be policed in the traditional Phuket way, with officers forced to concede whenever taxi and tuk-tuk drivers blockade the streets and with graft a regular accusation.

Having the Army take charge in Thailand just as a covert operation against taxi drivers on Phuket by a Region 8 team concluded led to a climax with scores of arrests that signalled the arrival of the ''good guys'' on Phuket.

Undercover team leader Major General Praveen Pongsirin says 109 cases involving Karon taxi drivers have now been moved to the Phuket Prosecutor and his focus is now Patong, followed by Phuket International Airport.

''What happened in Karon is likely to be the model for Patong and the airport,'' he said. ''These operations are like a big tree.

''We can lop all the branches, but we also have to deal with the roots that extend down to local authorities or the tree will simply grow again.''

He reckons that action will be seen to happen in Patong in about a month.

But in the meantime, Major General Praveen and Major General Panya will need to deal with recalcitrant tuk-tuk drivers who are now returning to park in spaces where they have been supposedly forbidden to park in Patong.

The two major generals will also be eyeing Phuket's local police to see whether they enforce the law the new way, or the old way.

It's within the capacity of the two Region 8 chiefs to transfer out those officers who fail the test and bring in replacements if necessary.

The local media, meanwhile, backs ''local interests.'' Hagiography remains a specialty.

Major General Panya and Major General Praveen are grateful for the support of the National Council for Peace and Order and say that they hope that local authorities will continue to keep Phuket's beaches and foreshores clear of illegal businesses.

''If they don't do their jobs, we are going to arrest them,'' said Major General Panya, in no-nonsense fashion.

The difficulty will arise in keeping an eye on every beach along Phuket's popular west coast. And once tourists return in numbers, that problem becomes more and more difficult.

Our forecast is for this kind of ''guerrilla warfare:''

ONE sunny November morning, locals truck in several pickups laden with sunbeds and umbrellas.

The sunbeds and umbrellas are quickly set out on a beach.

Tourists used to the service quickly pay 200 baht each and scores of them are laying on the sunbeds by the time that Region 8 police arrive.

Will the police organise for refunds to be made to the tourists, who are angry and do not want to budge, then arrest the sunbed operators?

Or will the officers retreat, leaving operators at all Phuket beaches free to adopt the same tactic and restore Phuket's old ways?

Major General Panya and Major General Praveen are determined police officers.

But Phuketwan believes they will need to enlist reinforcements from the Royal Thai Navy and have every Phuket west coast beach patrolled all day, from the beginning of the tourist high season for the foreseeable future.

If the ''New Phuket'' is really here, it will take the combined might of the military and police to make sure it stays.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Easy answer - take the sunbeds away & destroy them - IF the intention be that they never return!

Posted by Logic on July 23, 2014 11:46

gravatar

If Major General Panya and Major General Praveen want to succeed, they must have the support of the Phuketians to work as the sentinels of the environment.

The best would be to set up local Environmental Associations to be in charge to inform the National Council for Peace and Order (NCPO) of any wrongdoings and able to organize beach cleanup on regular basis as divers do it for the coral reefs.

Also to send a strong signal to rogue civil servants, it would be good to arrest and prosecute corrupt civil servants to deter others to continuous in that wrong path.

Posted by Whistle-Blower on July 23, 2014 11:52

gravatar

Good article ED and very realistic...my money says the bad guys retain their bad ways..best case scenario is there will be the usual "compromises" that basically will mean everything is status quo

Posted by sky on July 23, 2014 12:08

gravatar

What's the betting you won't be blowing your own trumpet when you're eventually banged up with the rest of the Phuket criminals and misfits etc etc ... ha5ha5ha5

Additional contribution reference:
"PLAY OF THE DAY ... EMAIL from a new Phuketwan fan: I am back home now and reading your reports daily I can't believe in all my years on Phuket I had not read your articles. Keep up the good work."
How could this have happened? Please send him/her my condolences but I suspect it will be another one-off Caroline ... ha5ha5ha5

Posted by Amazed in Thailand on July 23, 2014 12:57

Editor Comment:

All sane readers will find your nutcase comment as amusing as I do, Amazed in Thailand. Too much time on Thai Geezer, you poor, poor thing.

gravatar

'Hagiography remains a specialty'.

You've got me there Ed - do you know some saints on Phuket?

Posted by Pete on July 23, 2014 13:05

Editor Comment:

The local media finds saints on every corner, Pete.

gravatar

Surely it's the sinners they find on the corners!
You are part of the local media, so you're saying saints and sinners throng together.

Posted by Pete on July 23, 2014 13:18

Editor Comment:

Perhaps you've missed the subtler meaning of hagiography, Pete.

gravatar

Ill have what ever Amazed in Thailand is having - just so i can understand his comment!!!!

Posted by Ciaran on July 23, 2014 13:26

Editor Comment:

No way of knowing if AiT is a he or a she. Vilification is for everyone. Amazed in Thailand is just not very good at it.

gravatar

Phuket can (& should be) a 1st class international destination (read quality). Get this corruption sorted! BTW I was at JungCeylon yesterday and watched the surly, tee shirt/torn shorts, black taxi's drivers still trying to nick tourists. Don't ask about the tuk-tuk drivers.

Posted by Hotgem on July 23, 2014 13:29

gravatar

Tourists do actually want to lie on sun beds, and they NEED an umbrella to prevent burning. So there needs to be a local solution to that one.
The tuk tuk mob, and the touts on Bangla keep returning, so it'll need a task force out and about enforcing the rules.
This is going to be a long job. The army need to set up a permanent barracks on the island, send wrongdoers to prison or at least expel them back to their home districts, and retain a high profile presence otherwise it will be a return to "business as normal".

Posted by jimbo34 on July 23, 2014 14:32

gravatar

If we are going for root and branch reform, given the general's comments likening things to a tree, ship all the police from Phuket to Yala if they are found wanting. I'm, sure the cops down there would willingly do a swap. Do your job or pack your bags- wouldn't take long for the message to get through. Demands for tea money from non-traditional locations are on the increase now that other sources have been cut off- I know first hand a number of people who have been hit up for it for the first time in over ten years trading as the BiB feel the pinch.

Posted by Mister Ree on July 23, 2014 16:05

gravatar

@Mister Ree

Do you really think that policemen from Yala in general are less eager accept and inquire for presents?
I think that it is whole-country-spread problem, yes, some with volatility about scale , methods and tactics, but in essence it is the same everywhere.

That obviously is one of underlying reasons that led to "May Revolution"

Corruption is as wise-spread, profound and in the mind of general population, as , say, it was in Ukraine , that led to revolution of its kind, but much smaller than it is, say, in PRC, Russia.

Rotation would not help, but new pattern tough and non-selective application of law by military certainly would help to adjust a mind-set.

Posted by Sue on July 23, 2014 16:54

gravatar

I agree with trying to bring law and order back to Phuket, however, I am rather disappointed that the umbrellas, loungers and vending carts have been removed. As a tourist this was one of the main reasons for me visiting Phuket. Do you think that they will allow umbrellas and loungers back on the beach by December 2014?

Posted by Arthur on July 23, 2014 17:00

Editor Comment:

No. The ban is permanent. The best beaches in the world don't have sunbeds and umbrellas.

gravatar

did not read anything yet about targeting the payments by bars and restaurants to local officers. Back to the old days might also mean less customers in general. Are the bars, restaurants and even hotels going to survive?

Posted by Anonymous on July 23, 2014 19:22

gravatar

@Arthur - don't worry the beds will be back sooner rather than later. I think the best thing to do is ask the tourists what they want and not the expats living on the island. Without tourists Phuket would be nothing.

Posted by John O on July 23, 2014 20:24

Editor Comment:

Without beaches, Phuket will be dead. Tourists are not as important as they imagine, John. Don't kid yourself.

gravatar

"Amazed in Thailand" Just what are you amazed at? Are you amazed at how jealous you are of the editor? Because the editor gets things done you could only dream about? Because your stumbling blocks are just as big as back home? Because you laugh at other people's misfortune? Because you can't get laid without paying a 500 baht bar fine and then another 2500 baht and a couple hundred more for the short time hotel?

Posted by farang888 on July 23, 2014 21:56

gravatar

As an Australian I cannot recall a single instance where one of our world class beaches has ever had the wall to wall beaches lounges and umbrellas that I have seen around Phuket and we still get millions of tourists each year visiting those beaches.
As far as I am concerned the more Phuket's beaches are returned to a natural state the better.
By the way the comment by @Arthur on 23/07/2014 at 1700 was not by me.

Posted by Arthur on July 23, 2014 22:24

gravatar

There are some real strange posts appearing by individuals, well identified by PW, who don't seem to want reform to get this once great island back to where it was. Please go somewhere else as you are in the minority.

Now if the good General or his aides are reading this, please remove the non-Thai tailors & the farang time share touts next (though visa runs may take care of these unnecessary parasites).

Posted by Logic on July 24, 2014 00:01

gravatar

All that about TUK-TUK service and TUK-TUK Mafia. Would like to hear more about public transportation for fair prices. Hop on hop of. ;)

Posted by Danish on July 24, 2014 01:46

gravatar

Really look forward to a meet a public bus service working all around the beautifuul Pukhet Island in the future. Hop on hop off bus service all over the Island.

Posted by Lars Denmark on July 24, 2014 02:04

gravatar

Getting rid of the farang time share touts would be a great thing!! Sanuuuuk mak.. As a farang, can I call ( most of them ) them parasites of the lowest common denominator? Having listened to two or more of the shills over the years, their B.S. is almost as "over the top" as the poor guys who coined the phrase 100 years ago ( today ) in the trenches of no-man's land. Good riddance to the farang time share touts; they're just a tiny notch above the Gary Glitters of the world..

Posted by farang888 on July 24, 2014 05:41

gravatar

Tourist paying high prices for a hotel room expect chair & umbrella (especialy the older ones). now that the chairs are removed from the beach at night some resturant set diner tables in he sand!! During the day now somes guys have motorized food carts. What happen if i go to the beach and bring my own chair and umbrella? would i get fined. Can someone offers rental folding chairs and umbrellas from the back of his pick up truck? then the client bring it back at the end of the day ?? Is it illegal ??

Posted by James on July 24, 2014 10:38

Editor Comment:

No problem if you bring your own chair and umbrella, James. But a chair and umbrella rented on the beach would be illegal. It would be illegal rented in the street, too, because the issue is the use of public space for private profit. Many beaches in Australia were once dotted with bring-your-own umbrellas but most people these days no longer bother.

gravatar

All in all, a very realistic perspective on things. Certainly the destruction of the tuk tuk stations has only resulted in the same taxi and tuk tuk drivers gathering in the same old places and engaging in their same old tricks albeit under a temporary tarp as opposed to a fixed roof.
The answer lies in having an independent, adequately paid and adequately trained police force who are empowered to uphold the laws irrespective of local political influences. Police or other government officials who are found guilty of abuse of their powers should be fired, jailed or both ..... as opposed to simply transferring them to another posting elsewhere. Bad apples, even if relocated to another position in the crate, will eventually spoil the whole crate! Get rid of all the bad apples, install and instill professionalism in the ranks and hold everybody in politics, the police and the army to the highest standards!

Posted by Farang Ron on July 24, 2014 15:36

Editor Comment:

We expect the Army's decisions - made with Region 8 police leaders - will be enforced, or there will be changes.

gravatar

For years we come for 6 months to Naiharn . We like sitting on the beach on sunbeds under a umbrella for sunburn . De are 65 years old so we have to sit in the sand or we have to breng our own chairs and umbrella with. I thinck these is the end of Thailand for tourisme . I hear from friends that the beaches in Naiharn not clean everybody left there dustbin on the beach . I spook with a lot off friends here in Europ about these problem and a lot thinck off changing there holiday of a another country . Sorry Phucket or Thailand

Posted by malena on July 25, 2014 03:40

Editor Comment:

The decision is yours. One aim is to preserve the beaches for future generations of Thais to visit, and to see in all their glory, uncovered by umbrellas, sunbeds and baking tourists. Another aim is to uphold the principle that the beaches are for everyone to enjoy, not for private profit. The concept of darkening one's skin to look healthy remains odd to most Thais, and these days to many others as well. People who enjoy the beach cultures in Australia or California for six months each year manage perfectly well without actually living on the beach. For once, this is not about money.

gravatar

the hotels should buy x amount of small chairs that fold up.very light and fold up to carry.hotels could have a deposit on them that is reimbursed when leaving,no chair returned no deposit returned.that would put an end to sun- beds taking over the beach again

Posted by brian on July 25, 2014 05:49

Editor Comment:

People so far seem to be coping very well with towels, and the beaches all look magnificent. What the resorts may need to do before the high season makes the beaches crowded is to hire some of the vendors to act as beach guardians for the belongings of their guests.

gravatar

Interesting article and some very good points

Posted by Michael on July 25, 2014 07:14

gravatar

The best solution is to make the beach Lifeguards civil servants, with the authority to enforce the new beach regulations. Task the Lifeguards with upholding the new rules - they are always at the beaches and can see when the first 'weed' tries to take hold.

Posted by Beach Swimmer on July 25, 2014 09:53

Editor Comment:

Not enough beach lifeguards for that, unfortunately. The Royal Thai Navy is better equipped.

gravatar

Have any one been at the beach lately?
I was shocked when I went to Karon few days ago. It is filthy. So, we tried Kata, same story. Terrible! We also tried Patong...
Beaches are so dirty, filed with rubbish and who knows what. You sitting in the middle of the trash with your kids and not having umbrellas and sunbeds it making it so much worth. How can anyone like this?
At list beaches where so much cleaner before, 100baht for a bed is a very low price. In Europe they charge you 7euros.
Tourists need sunbeds and umbrellas. I can only imagine each tourist carrying their own sun bed and umbrella from the hotel, walking in the heat with family for even 5-10min.
Is that sound like a nice and relaxing holiday to anyone?
Maybe all of the tourists should rent a car for this very special and very important beach-holiday equipment?
Legalizing it one thing but how it is now, no good to anyone, especially for hi-quality tourism.

Posted by Anonymous on July 25, 2014 12:19

gravatar

The beaches probably appear dirty now because finally you can actually see some sand rather than the rows of lounges.
Given time authorities will work out how to best clean the beaches now the obstructions are removed.
There are many types of equipment available to skim the upper level sand, filter it and replace it with a freshly raked appearance

Posted by Manowar on July 25, 2014 19:17

gravatar

Does the new government really think the tourists will still come to Phuket if the beds etc are permanently removed. I am a long time regular visitor with a family and we will not come to Phuket if this move is permanent as part of the allure of the island is the beautiful beach vibe. I will also wager that the beaches that have been "cleared" look like refugee zones with rubbish poled high. Again if they are going to clear the beaches at least clean them properly.

Posted by David from Brisbane on July 27, 2014 13:01

Editor Comment:

''The beautiful beach vibe'' is much better without the sunbeds.

gravatar

"Does the new government really think the tourists will still come to Phuket if the beds etc are permanently removed."

Some will like it, some will not. I think more will like it than not.

Posted by stevenl on July 27, 2014 13:44


Friday April 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter