The two had been drinking in the same bar on Soi Bangla and both took a liking to one of the waitresses.
The American, a younger man, was solidly built and possibly favored his chances of winning the young lady's attention.
The Italian was an older man, aged 54.
However, according to police who interviewed witnesses in the bar, the American was ''impolite'' and used bad language.
The waitress decided to ignore him and chatted instead with the Italian, police were told.
The American left the bar.
A little later, about 9.20pm, the Italian left the bar. As he walked out, the American was waiting, barechested and apparently ready to fight.
Police Lieutenant Surasak Jaidee said the American beat up the Italian, using a knuckleduster on one fist.
By the time officers arrived at the scene, the American was still beating the Italian, he added.
An ambulance arrived and paramedics treated the Italian, then took him to Bangkok Hospital Phuket, where he was admitted to the Intensive Care Unit.
He was still in hospital today after having more than 20 stitches to wounds on his face.
Police Lieutenant Surasak named the men as Corey Dalee Daniel and Enrico Zarantonello.
The American has been charged with assault with a weapon.
He is being held and police will interview Mr Zarantonello when he is able before deciding whether to pursue charges.
MediaWATCH: Phuket Businesses Face 'Scrutiny'
News Digest Phuket crackdown on investment, resorts up for sale; Tourism back security clamp; China stocks edge higher; Obama marks Ramadan; Spiderman conquers KL towers; Gmail back.
MediaWATCH: Phuket Businesses Face 'Scrutiny'
Phuket Wins 2 Billion Baht Budget for 'Super Centre'
Latest Good things come to those who wait and after two decades, Phuket seems assured now of a conference and sports centre that will drive the island's development.
Phuket Wins 2 Billion Baht Budget for 'Super Centre'
Jet Phuket Takes Off for 6.3m Visitors Record
Phuket's Economy Forecasts are that Phuket will reach a record 6.3 million arrivals and departures this year, which means the boom is rapidly overtaking the gloom.
Jet Phuket Takes Off for 6.3m Visitors Record
Researcher Pursues '100pc Truth' on Ownership
Latest An academic whose research created a newspaper storm is actually as concerned about Phuket tourism and the environment as she is about property.
Researcher Pursues '100pc Truth' on Ownership
Drowned Russian Tourist Found on Karon Beach
Latest The body of the latest drowning victim has been found at Karon. Beach safety is essential at seaside resorts these days. The tragedy is that these needless deaths can be prevented.
Drowned Russian Tourist Found on Karon Beach
China Visitor Bucks Jetski Bid for 50,000 Baht
UPDATE Phuket's governor tells tourist horror stories of jetski operators in Patong and makes it plain that the era of the scams and ripoffs is coming to a close.
China Visitor Bucks Jetski Bid for 50,000 Baht
Disgraceful and as an American I am ashamed He will probably do less time in a Phuket jail then the woman who stole a bar mat and Simon Burrows. Let's see.
Posted by VFaye on September 2, 2009 12:17