Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Phuket Journalists, Royal Thai Navy to Meet for Talks in Bangkok

Sunday, July 6, 2014
PHUKET: Journalists from Phuketwan are scheduled to meet a representative from the Royal Thai Navy at the National Human Rights Commission in Bangkok tomorrow.

It's the first time the two parties have met since a Royal Thai Navy captain lodged a complaint with Phuket police against reporter Chutima Sidasathian and editor Alan Morison alleging criminal defamation and a breach of the Computer Crimes Act on July 17 last year.

A mediation meeting was scheduled for May but the military took control of Thailand the previous day and the event was cancelled.

The trial of Morison and Khun Chutima has since begun at Phuket Provincial Court with three more days of hearings scheduled for March next year.

The court action concerns a 41-word paragraph from a Reuters special report on Rohingya boatpeople. Both the Reuters report and the Phuketwan article republishing the Reuters paragraph appeared on July 17, the day the Navy complaint was lodged.

Reuters and the two authors of the original 41-word paragraph have not been charged. The news agency and its reporters went on to win the prestigious Pulitzer prize and were honored at the Society of Publishers in Asia awards for their investigative special reports on the Rohingya.

The Phuketwan journalists shared two similar SOPA awards in 2010 for their work with the South China Morining Post newspaper in exposing the military pushbacks of hundreds of Rohingya from Thailand.

In June, Thailand was downgraded to Tier 3, the bottom level, in the US State Department's annual Trafficking in Persons report.

Reuters' coverage and the criminal defamation action by the Royal Thai Navy were mentioned in passing more than once in the TIP report.

Morison's Australian passport was confiscated by the court in April when Morison and Khun Chutima spent five hours in the court cells awaiting a decision on bail.

Although both are free on sureties of 100,000 baht each and Khun Chutima has since travelled to Australia, Morison remains effectively a prisoner in Thailand, unable to visit his 90-year-old father, his children or a two-year-old grandchild.

Morison's Immigration B visa has also been cancelled. When Morison's work permit becomes due for renewal in February, it will also be cancelled because his Immigration B visa has been cancelled.

This means that Phuketwan will be forced to cease publishing a few weeks before the trial resumes in March.

The military versus media court action using the controversial Computer Crimes Act and criminal defamation is unprecedented in Thailand.

Morison and Khun Chutima say they have done nothing wrong. They say that with warships at bases on Phuket and in the neighboring province of Phang Nga, they have always admired the Royal Thai Navy, especially for its rescue work with tourists, and even defended the service from accusations in 2009 that it was involved in the military pushbacks.

They say they intend to continue covering the Rohingya issue until Phuketwan is forced to close.

An offer for the Royal Thai Navy to express its view on the Rohingya issue or on the court case in Phuketwan, without editing or a response, has yet to be taken up by the service.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

ED, i would go see a lawyer because: If your visa is cancelled you are on an overstay. Are you allowed to work while on overstay ? Is your work permit still valid without a visa ?

Posted by FS on July 6, 2014 18:18

Editor Comment:

Immigration now extends my stay every three months, as the court requests them to do. The work permit remains valid. I am not likely to be deported.

gravatar

If the Thai Navy and the Government/Regime want to establish to the free world that they have any regard for justice, integrity and freedom of speech they will drop the charges and rather, investigate the issue as outlined by Reuters and republished by Phuketwan. Democracy is not based on shooting the messenger who tells you what you don't want to hear about the potential/real flaws in your administration/Government. Democracy and international credibility is based on confronting and investigating those flaws.
The treatment of Morison and Chutima thus far marks a stain on Thailand's international standing.
What individual - what nation - would trust a Thai regime/Government if Morison and Chutima continue to be treated as they are.
If they want international credibility they will address the issue and not simply shoot - in this case prosecute and jail - the messengers.

Posted by Patrick Boyce on July 6, 2014 19:10

gravatar

but you more than likely will have to cease working coming February. Will that be the end of PW?

Posted by ciaran on July 6, 2014 19:36

Editor Comment:

Too difficult to predict, ciaran. But if Phuketwan is forced to close, that would certainly be a black mark in next year's Trafficking in Persons report. Thailand's position on the international media freedoms list will also be reassessed later this year. As we have said, the Royal Thai Navy's decision to accept bad advice and sue Phuketwan can only be damaging to Phuketwan, to the Navy and to Thailand. Attempts to surround the Rohingya issue with silence and secrecy are doomed to fail.

gravatar

As much as we have banged heads in the past I hope you achieve a successful outcome in this case.

Posted by Mister Ree on July 7, 2014 09:14

Editor Comment:

Thank you.

gravatar

That they are talking, at last, is a harbinger of hope that voices of reason are beginning to be heard, and
heeded, within the Royal Thai Navy - or perhaps from on high. You and Oi should take considerable comfort from this. The tide - as I believe Canute once said - is turning. Also heartily endorse Pat Boyce's remarks (please send me an email, Pat, when you get a few moments): still kjhaley@bigpond.com). Truth will set you free, Alan: it's only a question of time.

Posted by Ken Haley on July 7, 2014 11:55

Editor Comment:

Thanks, Ken.

gravatar

Alan, did anything positive come from your meeting? Even Hinch gave you a mention last night while referencing the Greste case while filling in on Paul Murray Live

Posted by Manowar on July 8, 2014 04:55

Editor Comment:

Thanks for your interest. The meeting was positive. Nine Navy officers joined us, along with the National Human Rights Commission panel. Private talks with the Navy followed. We are now awaiting a statement from the commission.

gravatar

I see no reason for talks. All charges must be dropped, apologies issued, compensation paid and all future harassment subject to swift and sure punishment. Simple as that for a civilized country.

Posted by David on July 8, 2014 11:38

gravatar

It is good to hear that talks were in a positive direction.
Looking forward for further statements..

Posted by Sue on July 8, 2014 12:08


Friday November 29, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter