Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Phuket Dive Raid Mixup Led to Bangkok Police Probing Shakedowns

Thursday, April 3, 2014
PHUKET: A police raid on dive instructors on Phuket that coincided with a visit by officers from Bangkok investigating extortion claims has brought the prospect of diving shaking off corruption.

The amazing coincidence was revealed yesterday as dive industry representatives met with Phuket Governor Maitree Intrusud to solve the work permit issue that causes the shakedowns and rip-offs.

On March 17, lawyer Pongsawan Sathatham, told the governor yesterday, police from Chalong went to the east coast dive centre's pier and arrested 17 dive instructors.

At the same time, in response to a request for help made by one dive company chief to her ambassador in Bangkok, police from the capital were waiting at a dive company office for the dive company chief to turn up.

When the Bangkok officers heard that the dive company chief was among the large number of arrests, they figured that what was going on was definitely worth investigating.

The Superintendent of Chalong Police Station has been transferred, an investigation by the Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission is underway, and yesterday Governor Maitree promised he would visit Chalong pier at the weekend to see how the dive business works.

Although transferred superintendent Colonel Krittapas Detintharasorn claims his officers say they have done nothing wrong, people in the dive industry maintain men in casual clothes who say they are police have extorted amounts of up to 20,000 baht from expat workers.

''The problem is that once a dive industry operator lifts an air tank, he or she is strictly in breach of their work permit,'' the governor was told yesterday by Khun Pongsawan and representatives from Association of Thailand Underwater Sports (ATUS), the new body that has replaced the Thai Diving Association.

At the meeting at the governor's house, Governor Maitree was keen to pursue the issue and said he would have been involved earlier if he had been told what was happening.

The documents of all of Phuket's expat dive industry employees are to be checked in coming weeks as the industry moves to shake off illegality and corruption and clarify the role of expats.

A new, more appropriate work permit is now the aim. Since the Phuket dive insudtry people first met to express their problems in public, Phuketwan has heard of similar extortion in the neighboring province of Phang Nga, and of police and Tourist Police seeking declarations from dive industry staff that they have never been involved in extortion.

The move to clean up the diving industry could be an important step towards making other aspects of the tourism industry on Phuket and in Phang Nga and Krabi corruption free, too.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Lets get rid of all foreign dive instructors, leave it to Thai's and then watch the carnage begin and another tourist industry die, as is there logic to ban double decker buses over driver training, no idea at all!

Posted by coxo on April 3, 2014 09:36

Editor Comment:

That's a strange request, coxo. There's no suggestion that anyone wants to get rid of expat dive instructors. But it would be great to have moreThai instructors trained up.

gravatar

So here is the solution:

Every farang dive instructor has a mandatory student that will not only do all the things that the farang is forbidden to do, but also become a dive instructor himself and replace the farang.

Farang solved

Posted by Farsolv on April 3, 2014 10:17

gravatar

How many companies is ATUS representing? In other words, how many companies are a member of ATUS?

Posted by stevenl on April 3, 2014 10:45

gravatar

exo

Strange, I dive all around the world and meet some intersting people from all over the world as dive instructors

Farsolv
They have same system in Brasil I spent two years instructing someone including trips overseas to improve language, I left and within two months he had ripped the company off, great idea but does not always work. A Thai divemaster is more likely to start up his own company and expat will probably only hand around a couple of years till want to go somewhere else

Posted by Michael on April 3, 2014 20:57

gravatar

As an ex-dive centre owner, I can tell you that the problem is this. THERE ARE HARDLY ANY THAI DIVING INSTRUCTORS. I would have loved to have employed mainly Thai diving instructors but even finding a Thai Divemaster is difficulty. The reason being, is that on my island there are simply not enough Thai's with good enough English and swimming ability to do the job. Let alone teach the French, Spanish, Italian, Czech and Russian in their own language. Unfortunately these foreign Instructors are a necessity and, of those that have worked illegally, most of them would love to work legally, but the system wont allow it. So they pay no tax, no social and the dive centre lives in fear of immigration and police. We need more Thai's with more language skills and the ability to get the western instructors legal, so at least they are paying tax. Most dive centres will happily teach a Thai for free in return for work, because they benefit in the end.

Posted by Lis on April 4, 2014 07:48

gravatar

"those that have worked illegally, most of them would love to work legally, but the system wont allow it. "

The system does allow it, but it is easier and cheaper not to jump through the hoops required. But don't start moaning if it gets required and illegal work is not being allowed anymore.

Posted by stevenl on April 4, 2014 10:51

gravatar

@Lis:
If, as you say, you have your own island why worry about nationalities of dive instructors? Can't you do as you wish?

Posted by Pete on April 4, 2014 11:56

gravatar

The Krabi office only allows a certain number, of work permits according to the size of company and the number of Thai staff. My business used those permits and paid all the necessary legal fees but we cannot get enough permits and this is where all these illegal workers come from. Whilst I had my business I worked within the law but the restrictions reduced our ability to serve more customers. This means that I could not have employed more Thai staff (ie because there was no point adding an additional boat as I could have no more permits for the western instructors I would need). I have always taken great lengths to be legal here and have never paid bribes because of it. But I do understand why some are driven to it.

Posted by Lis on April 4, 2014 13:00

gravatar

lis

If there aren't any thai diving instructors, or any at all, and the law s the way it is, then I guess there aren't supposed to be any diving industry or dive tourism in Thailand? It's not like it's ok to break the law because there are great potential for diving in a country, and people want to dive. They will have to go elsewhere for diving then I guess?

Posted by christian on April 4, 2014 18:20

Editor Comment:

When we last looked there were dive companies run by Thais and Thai instructors, just not enough of them.

gravatar

@ Pete - little facetious don't you think? For clarity, it is not my island, just the one I call home!

@ Editor - Absolutely, we have very few Thai diving centres, but the ones we have are excellent, oh and they have illegal western dive instructors!

Posted by Lis on April 5, 2014 08:09

gravatar

Dive operators in Phuket have given the perfect stick to get beaten by the Thai administration which loves compromise in any dispute.
Corrupted civil servants and dive operators will be investigated and the losers will be at the end the dive Instructors and dive operators which are using Thai nominees as Thai shareholders, Thai Directors and enough thai staffs to get a work-permit.

Anyway, the way many foreigners are speaking about Thai Divemasters and Instructors, i would agree with ATUS and the Thai Administration that it is the correct time to control and check all legal documents with foreign partners in Thai companies in Phuket, PhangNga and Krabi to clear off business all lawbreakers.

Posted by Whistle-Blower on April 7, 2014 16:49


Saturday November 30, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter