Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Phuket water quality: How Kamala (14) Patong (15,16,17) and Karon (18, 19) rate

Phuket Beaches: Some Cleaner, All Unguarded

Friday, February 12, 2010
LATEST figures for water quality at Phuket beaches show that Karon is the only six-star navy blue beach on the island.

The beach, also one of Phuket's longest, records six ''excellent'' ratings in measurements taken six times between October 2008 and August 2009.

It's the only beach in four years of testing to record what amounts to a ''perfect'' score.

There is just one problem: Karon is also one of Phuket's most dangerous beaches, with the drowning toll especially high during the monsoon months between May and October.

And even in high season when the waters are more tranquil, there are no lifeguards on Karon or for that matter any of Phuket's popular beaches. All beaches have been unguarded since mid-November because of a flaw in Thai law.

So in theory, if you get into trouble while swimming off Karon, you will know that you are about to drown in the island's best-quality sea water.

Black jokes aside, the latest figures on water quality, sampled from beaches all around Phuket, show a continuing decline in quality, with Karon as the most dramatic exception.

Dr Somkiat Khokiattiwong, of the Phuket Marine Biology Centre, attributes the decline in quality to construction projects with uncontrolled run-off, as well as household waste water that flows to the sea.

After rain, the water quality usually drops markedly because earth and waste are carried into the ocean.

December is by far the best month in which to swim, with 14 of the 23 beaches recording blue ''excellent'' stars at that time. Green ''good'' stars are still present on most beaches most of the time, although Phuket's west coast is generally better rated than the east coast.

Yellow starts signifying ''bad'' appear just three times in the latest measurement figures, once at Kamala in October and twice at the beach closest to Saphan Hin, the island's rubbish dump, in October and June.

Light blue stars signify ''mediocre'' water quality. So far in four years of testing, no Phuket beach has recorded a ''very bad'' red designation.

Three sets of measurements are taken on Patong beach, and back in 2006, Patong recorded three yellow ''bad'' stars out of a total of 18. However, there were only blue and green stars in the latest figures.

Generally though, Dr Somkiat says water quality at Phuket's beaches is in slow decline.

''Government controls on construction and household waste need to improve,'' he says. ''More attention needs to be paid to improving the quality of waste water.

''Some resorts are still not prepared to spend the money on the equipment they need to buy to preserve the environment so guests keep coming back.''
Phuket Beach Party to 'Aid Tourists in Trouble'
Latest Monthly beach parties are to be held in Patong from Saturday night on as part of a plan for the island to emulate Koh Phangnan's full moon parties and ''help tourists in trouble.''
Phuket Beach Party to 'Aid Tourists in Trouble'

Phuket Tuk-Tuk Leaders Oppose Fare Cuts, Meters
Latest Fare reductions and the introduction of meters are not likely to win the support of Phuket tuk tuk drivers, although taxi drivers may have fewer objections. Talks are to be scheduled soon.
Phuket Tuk-Tuk Leaders Oppose Fare Cuts, Meters

Phuket Jellyfish: Warning Cover 'Makes No Sense'
Latest A Phuket seminar on jellyfish is told that transparency is the wisest course. Warning signs on Koh Lanta in Krabi were painted over after the death of a young tourist there.
Phuket Jellyfish: Warning Cover 'Makes No Sense'

Phuket Jobs Safer Now But Recovery is an Illusion
Latest Record traffic through Phuket airport is a sign that crisis marketing and discounts are working. But the big spenders may not be back for another season and Phuket's excesses remain a turn-off.
Phuket Jobs Safer Now But Recovery is an Illusion

Phuket's Record High Sets Pace for Global Upturn
Breaking News Figures for Phuket flight arrivals and departures in January produce record numbers as the island's ability to recover from natural and manmade disasters shines through.
Phuket's Record High Sets Pace for Global Upturn

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Can we get a list of those resorts? Perhaps we can post them on Trip Advisor. Wasn't it previously mentioned that Club Med is one of those resorts? Just look at the back and see the sludge going into Kata!

Posted by VFaye on February 12, 2010 10:56

gravatar

"Some resorts" would be an understatement as I understand that most places just flush right into the sea. I hear that some environmentalists have tried to point this out in the past but were threatened with legal action and other misfortune.

A few years ago, near the end of a very busy high season, Phuket experienced a 40 mile red tide from Mai Khao to Chalong that biologists attributed to "human activity". Conditions are ripe for this to recur in the very near future.

And let us not forget the jellyfish and other nastys that thrive in less than clean water.

Perhaps Phuket Wan can initiate an inquiry into the waste-water disposal methods of some of the higher end hotels. I think that local environmentalist John Grey of Sea Canoe fame already has some data, and he would make for an interesting interview.

Posted by Treelover on February 12, 2010 13:50

gravatar

Guess they don't have a water to trash check. In the low season when the wind and waves start to come in so does loads of trash. In the high seas they get up early to try and get rid of the overnight trash that floats in.

Posted by mike on February 12, 2010 19:05

gravatar

So what are the tests measuring, fecal bacteria or just clarity of water? I know Surin beach has sewage emptying directly into the ocean, sure don't swim there anymore.

Posted by Horse Doctor on February 13, 2010 09:14

gravatar

"So in theory, if you get into trouble while swimming off Karon, you will know that you are about to drown in the island's best-quality sea water."

How crass.

Editor: Our priority is saving lives, not semantics. Most local media show indifference. We can't be accused of that.

Posted by Simon Smith on February 13, 2010 10:14

gravatar

I am a competitor to Club Med, but I know that they operate their proper and well maintained and well run waste water treatment plan, so before accusing them, check with them first.

The sludge going into Kata comes from the canal running into the sea, so why don't you follow the canal to find out where the waste water is coming from?

kata hotelier

Posted by kh on February 13, 2010 11:45

gravatar

Ed- any chance of a link to the full results? I would be interested to see how Patong featured.

Editor: The colored stars in the illustration show Patong did reasonably well. We don't think the information is posted online in full.

Posted by Mister Ree on February 13, 2010 21:09

gravatar

"Summer Season" without warning of the deadly " Summer Season" monsoon rip-tides, that is when the tragedies happen.

Posted by Horse Doctor on February 14, 2010 11:02

gravatar

What is missing from this report, BLARINGLY missing-is what are they testing for?
Lots of chatter," Yellow, blue, green..." Me thinks this is DISINFORMATION

How much s*** is in the water, Phuket?

I ask because every single neighbor, in their newly built firmly middle class homes or ramshakle tin hut - I count fifteen, has their toilet running directly into the stream.

Posted by Mustava Mond on February 14, 2010 11:10

gravatar

To Mustava Mond. In south african speak your name means - must have a mouth.
May I sugest that when swimming anywhere here in Phuket, keep your mouth closed and just go through the motions, ok ?

Posted by Graham on February 15, 2010 05:49


Friday March 29, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter