Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

The killings of two Aussie yachtsmen may finally be avenged in Cambodia

War Crimes Charges at Long Last Over Murders of Aussie Yachtsmen

Wednesday, March 4, 2015
CAMBODIA'S UN-backed Khmer Rouge tribunal has charged one of the murderous regime's commanders with crimes against humanity that includes the torture and murder of two Australian yachtsmen.

The move to charge Meas Muth, the former Khmer Rouge navy chief, defies Cambodia's strongman prime minister Hun Sen who opposes the partly Australian funded tribunal pursuing any more prosecutions.

Mr Hun Sen warned in a speech last week that if the tribunal targeted more defendants it could incite former Khmer Rouge members to start a civil war.

Meas Muth, in his 70s, was navy chief when his men captured Australians Ronald Keith Dean and David Lloyd Scott after their yacht had strayed into Cambodian waters at a time in the early 1970s when the world was unaware of a reign of terror under fanatical Khmer Rouge leader Pol Pot.

Dean, a 35-year-old Sydney hotel and club worker and Scott, believed to be about the same age from Western Australia, suffered extreme torture at Cambodia's notorious Tuol Sleng interrogation centre, possibly for months.

Both men signed false confessions saying they were CIA agents in an apparent attempt to avoid their executions.

A guard at Tuol Sleng told the tribunal that one Western man held at Tuol Sleng, possibly one of the Australians, was taken by guards to the road outside the centre, had a tyre placed over him and was set alight and burned alive.

Meas Muth, who rose to the rank of general in Cambodia's military after defecting from the Khmer Rouge, was for years believed to be a high-level adviser to Mr Hun Sen's Defence Ministry.

Some of the accusations against Meas Muth relate the torture and killing of Vietnamese, Thais and other foreigners captured at sea or on disputed island territory during the Khmer Rouge's rule of Cambodia when an estimated 1.7 million died from starvation, execution or disease.

The tribunal has also announced charges against Im Chaem, a Khmer Rouge district commander who headed a security centre in the country's north-west where an estimated 40,000 people died.

But the laying of them has escalated tensions with Mr Hun Sen, a ruthless former Khmer Rouge cadre who throughout three decades of rule has often dealt ruthlessly against those who oppose him.

Neither Meas Muth nor Im Chaem could be reached for comment.

Mr Hun Sen has issued a number of warnings about the tribunal pursuing more than five of the Khmer Rouge's top officials.

"The value of peace and the cost of human lives have to be considered," he said last week.

Some tribunal observers believe Mr Hun Sen will move to block the prosecutions against Meas Muth and Im Chaem going ahead.

The charges must be accepted by the court's senior judges before the two are indicted to face trial.

Tribunal spokesman Lars Olsen said the two were charged in absentia to expedite the legal process by not seeking arrest warrants beforehand.

"Decisions on whether these cases will end up with indictments or dismissals are expected next year, and the charged persons are presumed innocent until proven guilty through a final judgement," he said.

The tribunal that has cost more than $150 million has been dogged by walkouts, strikes and allegations of political interference by Cambodia's government.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Anyone who has committed war crimes, never gets punished until they know the person is old and almost dead.

Waste of every bodies time. Should just be charged for murder and be done with it. All this prancing around when even if convicted of one murder you would get 25 years.

Posted by Tbs on March 4, 2015 17:57

gravatar

anyone who has visted Tuol Sleng interrogation centre or the killing fields or has spoken to survivors would never question that these criminals should be charged and tried for their atrocities in Cambodia, just as Nazi war criminals should be bought to justice

Posted by Shwe on March 4, 2015 20:56

gravatar

Shwe

it's a matter of "retributive justice" vs. "restorative justice":

the first is about applying punishments for the crimes,

the second is about restoration of initial state of victims. In the case of grave crimes at scale, it means reconciliation with victims via reconciliation forums, where perpetrator acknowledge their crimes and listen to account of suffering given by victims.

Retributive justice should be merely applicable for crimes "against state", but for crimes against persons, normally restorative justice should be in place.

In general, criminal justice in the world is overwhelmed with retributive justice, and it's not good, as it leads nowhere, fro smaller or grosser crimes.

So for Khmer Rouge crimes restorative justice is more appropriate. Hun Sen himself is former Khmer Rouge.
What he talks about Khmer rouge problem solution direction is right as he points to the way of restorative justice. However, probably he is not very sincere about it, as his proposition is just removing retributive justice mechanism, and simply no further actions - restorative justice doesn't mean , of course, simply forgetting.

And there is quite succesful examples of restorative justice in action, e.g. Rwanda

http://goo.gl/JH1sgM

Hun Sen & Ko probably need to get an advice of what restorative justice is, and how it can happen in Cambodia for these crimes. regardless of all the Hun Sen's regime vices, that is the current regime, it should be dealt with, also for Khmer Rouge proper resolution.

Posted by Sue on March 5, 2015 00:46


Friday April 19, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter