Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

One of the Phuket crash victims is covered before the coffin is sealed

Phuket's Burmese Coverup: Real Holiday Toll is Eight

Monday, April 18, 2011
BEING a Burmese on Phuket is never easy, in life or in death. The Department of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation today lists seven deaths on Phuket's roads in the Songkran ''seven days of danger.''

Yet there was an eighth death, a woman who was killed when she was run over by a vehicle outside SuperCheap at 10am on Saturday. Because she is Burmese and her identity is unknown, she is not listed as an official death. Ignored in life and overlooked in death, such is the fate for many.

Official or not, six of the eight people killed on Phuket's roads at the weekend were Burmese.

We watched last night as the final rites were carried out for five of them, and the luckless Thai driver of an out-of-control pickup that collided with a tourist bus on Big Buddha Hill on Sunday morning - Burma's New Year's Day.

The community from a construction site in southern Phuket gathered until late at Sansuk Temple in Phuket City to say farewell to the tragic six, killed when the pickup, carrying 20 people, careened downhill and failed to take a steep bend.

Today five of 14 other Burmese injured in the crash remained in Phuket City's Vachira Hospital, mostly being treated for head injuries and broken bones.

Similar pickups were parked in the yard of the temple last night, with many trays occupied by mourning workers from the Phanason construction site, where some of the dead had been employed.

Sitting nearby was A, aged 41, mother of the two young girls killed in Sunday's crash. Both girls, Chit, aged 12, and Nanja, aged 3, were Phuket children, both born on Phuket, in Patong Hospital.

A's husband, Sumai - the tragic grieving father pictured by Phuketwan in mourning at the scene of the crash - was later taken to hospital with neck injuries. He remains there today.

While Sumai, 42, took the couple's two girls to the Big Buddha yesterday to mark New Year's Day, A went to the market instead.

Soon after she returned to the Phanason camp at Baan Borrae in Vichit, she learned of the crash, and of the death of her daughters.

Phanason had allowed relatives of the deceased to not work today.

Last night, each of the six coffins was opened as friends and relatives said their final goodbyes. Prayers were offered, colored rugs and pillows were added before the coffins were taped shut.

A cremation ceremony is likely to follow on Tuesday or Wednesday for all except the youngest, three-year-old Nanja, whose coffin was kept separate last night.

She will be buried instead at Mai Khao cemetery, as is Burmese tradition for children under 10.

Thai Tongdan Pewjan, 41, driver of the pickup, was also farewelled last night and will be cremated with his luckless passengers.

The police officers who were pictured in Phuketwan carefully tracing the path of the pickup downhill into the killer bend are likely to press for rapid change to make the corner safer.

Police are usually the ones who point out road ''blackspots'' to authorities. An Australian tourist on honeymoon was killed 16 months earlier in a single-vehicle crash on the same bend.

Calls for change are also likely to come from the top of the hill. The not-for-profit Big Buddha Foundation has always made the safety of worshipers and tourists a priority and is likely to press authorities to widen the bend to prevent more tragedies.

The total Thailand tally of deaths for the ''seven days of danger'' was announced today by the DDPM as 271.

We know it was at least 272. We have no way of telling whether other ill-starred Burmese may also have been overlooked in death, as most of them are in life.
Phuket Walking Woman, Fisherman Killed in New Year Tragedies
Latest Phuket has suffered its first and second fatalities for Songkran 2011 with the death of a walking woman and an amateur fisherman in an airport road collision.
Phuket Walking Woman, Fisherman Killed in New Year Tragedies

Phuket Calls Mount for Quick Fix to Killer Bend
Latest Six fresh deaths on a killer corner on a Phuket hillside bring calls for change. A wider, safer road and a shuttle bus to the top are two immediate needs for Big Buddha Hill.
Phuket Calls Mount for Quick Fix to Killer Bend

Six Dead: Time for Action as Phuket Mourns Little Girl in Pink
Distressing Photos A little girl and five others are dead after a collision at a bend that authorities knew was capable of killing. But they did little to fix the problem.
Six Dead: Time for Action as Phuket Mourns Little Girl in Pink

Phuket Eyes Aussies as Voucher Deals Win Tourists
Latest Phuket resorts eye Aussies as the low season game ground shifts and voucher sites became new players in the tourism trade. It's game on.
Phuket Eyes Aussies as Voucher Deals Win Tourists

FC Phuket Demolish Chiang Mai 4-0
Photo Album FC Phuket returned home after two road losses with fear in the hearts of fans but concern quickly dissipated as the Hulks scored a convincing 4 nought victory.
FC Phuket Demolish Chiang Mai 4-0

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

A cover-up is a crime as it involves withholding evidence, incriminatory or not. Are you certain your heading is correct?

Posted by Pete on April 18, 2011 13:35

Editor Comment:

Are you certain your theory is correct? Please send us the relevant passage where the words ''cover up'' are used in Thai law. It depends what's being covered up. Most cover-ups are not criminal.

gravatar

From Wikipedia: ''A cover-up is an attempt, whether successful or not, to conceal evidence of wrong-doing, error, incompetence or other embarrassing information. The expression is usually applied to people in positions of authority who abuse their power to avoid or silence criticism or to deflect guilt of wrongdoing. Those who initiate a cover up (or their allies) may be responsible for a misdeed, a breach of trust or duty or a crime''. No theory there. Cover-ups are criminal. You mention Thai law, the law for the rich or the law for the poor? That's about all I know about Thai law, probably the same as you. I would never mention Thai law; it's as flexible as a rubber band.

Posted by Pete on April 18, 2011 14:11

Editor Comment:

As Wikipedia says, a cover-up can be ''a misdeed, a breach or trust or duty, or a crime.'' A falsified statistic is a breach or trust, but certainly not a crime.

gravatar

Thank you Ed. Your heading should therefore read 'Statistic falsified'.

Posted by Pete on April 18, 2011 14:31

gravatar

Thank you for covering this topic. I know how hard it must be to do without feeling emotionally compromised and letting that through in the writing.

Posted by Miller Williams on April 18, 2011 14:53

gravatar

I've often asked Thais who fail to see anything wrong in how Burmese, Cambodians or Laotians are treated here if they would want to live in Thailand as a Burmese.

For some strange reason they all cringe and usually don't respond.

People from these nations are treated as nothing short of modern day slaves here in Thailand and I'm glad to see PW is (and has for a long time)making an effort to bring it to the attention of the greater (foreign) public.

PW reported news are often included in Google news from Thailand so chances are good that they are read all across the world.

My heartfelt condolences to all the victims and their families.

Posted by Chris on April 18, 2011 15:28

gravatar

Yesterday, your report said that the pickup was carrying 10 people. Today, that seems to have risen to 20.

I doubt very much that you could squash that many people into the back of a pickup truck even by Thai standards, Misprint perhaps?

Posted by Xircal on April 18, 2011 20:05

Editor Comment:

Xircal, you need to learn how to read, how to correctly absorb information, and how to add up. A statement from Siam Safari said that a pick up truck ''with more than 10 passengers'' had gotten out of control. We've consistently reported that there were six dead and 14 injured. You clearly haven't reached adulthood yet, or seen a crowded pick-up. Grow up.

gravatar

One major point that seemed to have been missed so far, is the fact that if Burma/Myanmar was not run by its military dictatorship, the way it is run, these unfortunate people would not need to be here. It is also sad that some Thais have no respect for these people, who are doing jobs they would not do, for salaries they would not accept and live in quarters they would not keep a dog in.

Posted by Phuket Kop on April 18, 2011 21:44


Friday March 29, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter