Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

Joshua Shane, the missing student from Arizona State University

Phuket Tourist Disappears at Patong: American Vanishes Taking a Swim After Dark

Wednesday, June 13, 2012
Today's Updating Report

PHUKET: Searchers were looking today for an American university student who disappeared last night while taking a swim at Patong beach. Another American student was admitted to hospital for treatment.

The missing man was named today as Joshua Shane, 21, a student in a party of 20 from Arizona State University who came to Phuket this week to offer suggestions on a sustainable transport system for the island.

The group had been working in Chiang Mai and Bangkok for a week each and intended to stay on Phuket for a week, one of the group said at a three-star resort in Patong today.

In the US, a spokesperson at the university said: "ASU is deeply saddened and we offer our condolences to the family and friends of Joshua Shane.

''We are focusing on counseling services for students and faculty participating in the program and those who may have known the student to help ease their pain at this difficult time."

Some of the group were being counselled at a hospital on Phuket today as Marine Police and jet-ski riders looked for the missing American.

It's understood that four students went swimming last night about 10pm, leaving one person in the group on the beach.

Once the alarm was raised, some of the other Americans went to the beach where a scuba diver and a jet-ski operator continued the search until after midnight.

It is not known at this stage whether anyone who went to the beach last night had been warned about the dangers.

Another person in the university group said today she had found out about the dangers of swimming on Phuket by chance, over dinner.

The group arrived on Monday and intended to stay a week, with next weekend due to be a holiday.

As well as sustainable transport, they were looking at improving the tsunami warning system and disaster prevention. The university has sent students on a practical mission to Thailand each year for about five years, Phuketwan was told.

Local Patong volunteers along the well-known beach on Phuket's holiday west coast alerted police by walkie-talkie that the man was missing about 10pm.

If the American student joins the growing number of tourists who have drowned at Phuket's beaches this monsoon season and in previous monsoon seasons, pressure is likely to grow for authorities to become more serious about an intense layer of warnings.

Promotion of Phuket as a year-round beach destination with the monsoon season deceptively described as ''summer'' leaves many tourists with a false inmpression about safety in the water.

To protect Phuket's reputation as a safe destination, authorities should consider making a video for all flights to screen on descent to Phuket, and with all resorts obliged to issue a verbal warning to guests on arrival.

Phuketwan knows of tourists who have gone for a swim upon arrival in the darkness, simply because they have come for a beach swimming holiday and have not been warned about the dangers.

Signs are of no value after dark. The three-star resort in Patong does not feature warning signs at reception.

There is a sign at the point where Joshua Shane went missing, saying ''Swimming Area''. There are no warning signs.

On beaches further south at Karon and Kata, where several tourists have drowned, warning signs have been installed.

However, Patong council has decided not to erect warning signs.

Phuketwan advocates the creation of a single Phuket Beach Authority to replace local councils and control every aspect of Phuket's beaches, including unwanted privatisation, environmental protection and sustainability, and tourist safety.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

Phuketwan knows of tourists who have gone for a swim upon arrival in the darkness, simply because they have come for a beach swimming holiday and have not been warned about the dangers.

AKA Darwinism at work....come on !..fair enough warning of dangerous ocean conditions, but warning not to swim at night????
Sorry for the guy and friends and family, but ''common sense'' or lack of, is the key word.

Posted by davidj949 on June 13, 2012 13:19

Editor Comment:

Why does darkness make a swim less safe? As long as you know where the beach is, whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety.

gravatar

@ ED Why does darkness make a swim less safe? As long as you know where the beach is, whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety.

From an Aust life guard recently..
''Completely avoid going for a swim during unpatrolled times, and particularly at night time because the conditions can't be fully seen, and there's nobody else there to help them," he said.
"There are also predators in the water that are active at night as well."

Well ED?..maybe you are joking..i would like to think so..What a ridiculous comeback from you..

Posted by davidj949 on June 13, 2012 15:36

Editor Comment:

"There are also predators in the water that are active at night as well." How does this apply to Phuket, davidj949?

Darkness is not the problem - lack of proper warnings is the problem. You are lost in the small print again.

gravatar

First when I read it, I thought, oh what an idiot. But then I remembered, what I did when I was young... swimming at night was one of them. Maybe only luckier then Joshua. Definitely the wrong season for that. RIP.

Posted by Lena on June 13, 2012 16:30

gravatar

"Why does darkness make a swim less safe? As long as you know where the beach is, whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety."

Are you serious Ed.? It's quite obvious that you always have to have the last word on each and every comment that is made on any published story, and woe betide the reader that offers a point of view that differs from your own.

I'm still trying to get over your retort to another reader regarding a recent article:

"Phuket motorists are, in my experience, also among the most safety-conscious and courteous."

You should get out of your office a bit more and see for yourself the crazy antics of most drivers on this island. Cheers.

Posted by Hugh on June 13, 2012 21:03

Editor Comment:

I went from the south of the island to the north today, Hugh, and didn't see you once. We stopped off at Patong, where a tourist had drowned, and again along the coast road, where a beer truck had overturned, looking around at Kamala, and at Surin, where the beach is still occupied by restaurants. We came back through Cherng Talay, Thalang and downtown Phuket City. Later we ate out in Samkong then shopped in Tesco. Where were you?

This is totally off-topic. A young man's unnecessary death is the concern. I am not interested in being told how an editor is supposed to behave. Get on-topic and don't waste my time, please.

gravatar

"There are also predators in the water that are active at night as well." How does this apply to Phuket, davidj949?

(moderated)

Posted by Joe on June 13, 2012 21:29

Editor Comment:

The question was addressed to davidj949, Joe. Not you. Don't waste your time and mine responding to questions directed to others.

gravatar

"The question was addressed to davidj949, Joe. Not you. Don't waste your time and mine responding to questions directed to others."

I will respond to whom I wish when I wish. Just as you will moderate my comments as you wish. I will especially respond when it comes to water safety when members of the general public make uninformed comments that can endanger the safety of others. I do not consider it a waste of my time, it is in fact my profession. Why you would moderate my list of potentially dangerous marine life that may be of increased concern when swimming in the sea at night is beyond me.

Posted by Joe on June 13, 2012 22:16

Editor Comment:

There are no real predators on Phuket, apart from the two-legged kind. Predators are carnivorous sharks, crocodiles and the like, not the marine creatures that bump into you or to whom you bump into by chance - and seldom on Phuket beaches. Phuket's beaches are not scary, even if you go swimming at night - provided you swim in the right place at the right time of year. Whether it's light or dark makes little difference. The point of the article, Joe, is that you and other ''professionals'' on Phuket in tourism need to make sure tourists are warned about the real dangers, the ones that can kill. The rips. Pity you're still so afraid of the dark.

gravatar

FROM Phuketwan's fanmail: Mandatory reading for anyone with even a slight interest in the island where readers can leave a comment and opinion whatever their view, your freedom of editorial amazes me . . . continue your unbiased approach to bring us the news with warts and all, it's very refreshing!

Yes ..hahaa right''where readers can leave a comment and opinion whatever their view,"
If only the EDcould leave alone the comments and opinions, what ever their view!!
Its only EDS views that are correct in his eyes..and he's never, ever wrong!!!

Posted by davidj949 on June 13, 2012 22:16

Editor Comment:

Not true, davidj949. I challenge the views of people who think they know. In most cases they respond not by dealing with the challenge, but by making the attack personal. Just as you have done.

gravatar

OK swimming a night is always more dangerous but the lack of warning signs at Patong Beach is the real problem here and please remember this was an American, from probably the most litigious, (hope thats spelt correct) society in the world. Patong council can expect a visit from a lawyer about this. They do deserve to be sued for that lack of fair warning.

Posted by Arthur on June 13, 2012 22:37

Editor Comment:

We have yet to hear - and we may never know - whether this group knew about the dangers. But what's certainly true is that resorts and local authorities need to act responsibly and warn tourists at every opportunity. Some ignore their duty of care.

gravatar

@Ed ..you said this;
Why does darkness make a swim less safe? As long as you know where the beach is, whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety.
And i posted this in part; From an Aust life guard recently..
''Completely avoid going for a swim during unpatrolled times, and particularly at night time because the conditions can't be fully seen, and there's nobody else there to help them," he said.
I think you are wrong. and the lifeguard is right...But?????as i said..Ed is never,ever wrong..even when he is...

Posted by davidj949 on June 13, 2012 23:09

Editor Comment:

This is coming from a lifeguard, davidj949, with a highly-developed sense of protection - which is why he then goes on to add the bit you left out this time (how forgetful of you): "There are also predators in the water that are active at night as well." He's talking about northern Australian waters, not Phuket. . . It's different here, where the rips are what people need to be concerned about, and warned about. The dark is not scary.

If you don't have anything to add about rips . . .

gravatar

Editor, you are completely wrong about being dark poses no more danger. you cannot see the beach condition (rips) and the is no lifesaver on duty and people cannot see you from the beach. so do you honestly think that darkness doesn't pose any danger! get real.

Posted by DAve66 on June 14, 2012 09:59

Editor Comment:

That's not what I said. I said ''Why does darkness make a swim less safe? As long as you know where the beach is, whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety.'' This is you first comment. I hope you'll do better in future. Try to move past this commenters' trivia to the tragedy and the important life and death issue of proper warnings about the dangers - day and night.

gravatar

@davidj949: I completely agree with you! The ed doesn't only moderate the comments, but he also hide them: a totalitarian news agent/agency!

Posted by Coralie on June 14, 2012 10:15

Editor Comment:

You mean your comment about ''the proverbial laziness'' of Thais or your more offensive one about the recent tragedy? You've had 16 out of 18 published, Coralie, and I saved you from embarrassment by not publishing the other two. This is a benevolent dictatorship, not totalitarian. Make sure you wave the Phuketwan flag, morning and night.

gravatar

Please everyone..dont give the Ed a hard time...really!!
He is displaying worrying symptoms of severe mental illneses...seriously!!!

Posted by davidj949 on June 14, 2012 13:02

Editor Comment:

How shameful that you treat the tragic loss of a life in this way, davidj949.

gravatar

Whether it's light or dark makes little difference" thats what you said and i merely pointed out here are many differences. can see a rip in the dark! i doubt it.

"whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety.'' you cannot be serious the dangers about night swimming at any beach in the world are obvious.

Posted by Dave66 on June 14, 2012 15:28

Editor Comment:

There are times and places when swimming at night is perfectly safe and other times and places when it's not. As with all decisions about swimming, care is needed to choose the right time and place. I am moving on, Dave66, and won't respond again.

gravatar

Oh my... it is so easy. ED says, when it is safe to swim at day it is also safe to swim at night. Of course not for weak panicing unexperienced swimmer who cannot stand drinking some salt water and the tickling sensation of movement in near darkness. These kind should stay at a pool at all time. Also do not swim, when there are rocks etc in the area. But that is not a problem at the wide Patong beach. It is an otherwise safe place to swim.

But to go for a swim, when at day there are warning signs and lifeguards trying to protect you, at night where neither of it is there, that is the different story. That is the story: No warning at night for new/inexperienced tourists who did not see the warnings at daylight.

At this season Phukets beaches are often not safe to swim even at days with lifeguards out there. But they did not know.

Posted by Lena on June 15, 2012 15:08

Editor Comment:

Lena, that's not what I said. What I said was: Why does darkness make a swim less safe? As long as you know where the beach is, whether there's light on the water has little to do with safety.

We do not know in this case whether the group who went swimming were warned because we have not been permitted to speak to them directly, but the university spokesperson says: ''Students participating in the study abroad program in Thailand did receive repeated warnings from their program leaders and local authorities not to swim in the water at Patong Beach, which poses significant dangers because of strong rip tides.''


Friday April 26, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter