Tourism News

Tourism News Phuketwan Tourism News
facebook recommendations

NEWS ALERTS

Sign up now for our News Alert emails and the latest breaking news plus new features.

Click to subscribe

Existing subscribers can unsubscribe here

RSS FEEDS

<i>Phuketwan</i> urges a corruption-free Phuket model for Thailand

Make Phuket a Role Model: End Corruption

Sunday, March 30, 2014
Phuketwan 'Brave Enough to Change' Campaign

PHUKET: Whether reforms precede the next national election or come after a poll, Thailand should now be fighting to end corruption - and Phuket must be turned into a role model.

This week's positive news has included the dive industry's move to stop extortion by rogue police, one man's campaign to make visa run vans safe and the sight of ugly wastewater running free across beautiful Karon beach.

Some people may see these issues as negatives but Phuketwan views them all, every one of them, as positives.

Only when people are made aware of the problems and then solutions sought will Phuket be saved for future generations of residents and visitors. Cover-ups and compromises won't work in the 21st century.

Unless action is taken now, corruption, environmental degradation and lack of safety on roads and beaches will kill Phuket's tourism industry within 10 years.

We don't hear anyone arguing that one.

Bear this in mind: there are already times of the year when on Phuket you will find more non-Thais than Thais. As Thailand's most international province, pressure for change will continue to grow in intensity on Phuket.

That's why the dive industry is rebelling, that's why visa run vans need closer controls, and that's why environmental degradation must be halted quickly.

Even with street protests continuing, the time could soon be right for the next government of Thailand to make Phuket corruption-free, then to use the ''Phuket model'' to clean up graft around the whole country.

We hear that all over Phuket, Phang Nga and Krabi this week, renegade law enforcement officers have been rushing to make sure their sources of extorted income are maintained, or at least won't blab to the Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission.

We hope people don't give in to fear. We hope people continue to keep blowing the whistle, not just in the dive industry but everywhere that illegal graft is being demanded and paid.

Now's the time for Phuket's chronic corruption to be overcome.

We know that's what the European Union ambassadors want. And we believe that also could be the aim of the Minister for Tourism and Sport, Somsak Pureesrisak, and the Region 8 Police Commander Major General Panya Mamen.

What we are urging is simple: Follow the Singapore example. Introduce incorruptible officers who can provide the foundation for a new beginning on Phuket.

Start with just one of Phuket's 10 police stations, fill it with honest officers and expand the corruption-free process from there.

Eventually, with 17 organisations or groups on Phuket known to be on the take, according to Patong business people, Phuket and Thailand are certain to be exposed and found wanting.

When the Asean Economic Community provides clean, corruption free competition from late 2015, how bright will be the future of Thailand and Phuket?

Both sides of politics should make ending corruption in Thailand an integral and essential part of their policies. The politicians who prove they are most sincerely are likely to be the winners.

And Phuket, the international Thai province, should be leading the way. After all, everybody knows who ultimately pays every baht of it in the end: the tourist.

Comments

Comments have been disabled for this article.

gravatar

With you all the way Ed. It's a vision for the future but sadly might be only a pipe dream.

Many want Phuket to change for the better or even simply back to what it once was.

But there are many with deep pockets & grubby mitts who like it just as it is.

Time will tell.

Posted by Logic on March 30, 2014 13:38

gravatar

But people like corruption when its to there advantage, its only when its not that people start crying and besides sometimes people have to learn the hard way..and is really having less tourists such a bad thing...less rubbish, less crazyness and less crime and thais who learn to apprechate the tourist dollars.

Posted by David on March 30, 2014 14:34

gravatar

''When the Asean Economic Community provides clean, corruption free competition from late 2015, how bright will be the future of Thailand and Phuket?''

Bleak is the answer. With a Dickensian education system, no geography and no history, imported English teachers with fake degrees or TEFL certificates, (I know of a few), the situation is hopeless. If the government mandated and checked that genuine college degrees and a TEFL certificates were the basic qualifications to teach in Thailand, this would rid them of most of the Western men here who aren't qualified to teach, but finding and keeping good, qualified Western teachers is not possible because of the ridiculously low salaries offered. Only the rich can educate their children by sending them abroad or to international schools. Remember the words of Nelson Mandela: ''Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world''. Thailand's education system now is a lost cause and the country will continue to fall further behind in the education game if that's possible as what comes lower than rock bottom? Without delving into the problems of corruption and inept politicians???fake degrees again???making matters worse, Thailand will most certainly be the lame duck of ASEAN.

Posted by Pete on March 30, 2014 14:59

gravatar

In the end, tourists pay only a small amount. The biggest share is being paid by Thais. Through less growth, white elegant investments, lousy infrastructure, tremendously lost potential, destroyed nature. Corruption or crony capitalism keeps Thailand indefinitely away from becoming a developed country.

Posted by Lena on March 30, 2014 15:03

gravatar

Quite right, Editor and Chutima.

Voranai Vanijaka of the Bangkok Post also said it well in a recent column:

"Thailand suffers from two ailments that are not mutually exclusive: corruption and incompetence. The virus that causes these two diseases is our outdated institutions. The cure is to reform these institutions."

Posted by Treelover on March 30, 2014 16:34

gravatar

I work in Education in Phuket. To present a fake document to a government official is a criminal act. I have seen many excellent students and many that go through the motions. It's no different in Europe. Look at the stats for educated Europe and see the unemployment figures for graduates. The facts are bar girls are vulnerable young women exploited by 'elderly sophisticated and educated' western men. Is that something to be proud of?

Posted by gee on March 30, 2014 16:35

gravatar

gee, a little eye opener, just for you. One reason there are two many "unemployed" graduates is that there simply is too many of them and not enough positions, same in Oz As for bar maids being "exploited" by 'elderly sophisticated and educated' western men, is not really true, many are exploited by their families who send/encourage them to move to Phuket, Pattaya, Bangkok etc, to earn money to send home. They know the girls will end up as "bar girls" or "massage" girls, but the baht is more important. If asked they deny where they work, most common answer is receptionist. So get off you pony and be realistic.

Posted by Laurie Howells on March 30, 2014 17:39

gravatar

imo an economic tsunami maybe the answer to the beginning of a new order in Thailand , ed i like the idea but the corrupt officials number far too many , the country needs to remove these leeches and to do that the money tap needs to be turned off , the poor will then realize the imbalance and change will occur ... hopefully with minimal bloodshed ..i doubt any one individual Thai or Farang has not participated in some sort of corrupt activity , think about it!! i for one have taken short cuts for a fee and i guess added to this ugly situation in Thailand ..... anyone else ? or am i alone ?

Posted by chris on March 30, 2014 17:40

gravatar

Yes, good idea to start somewhere in Thailand and see how far you could get...but to promote ASEAN as a corruption free example that is completely wrong, just been involved with Malaysian and Philippine businesses and both places have rampant corruption issues, and add hereto the big neighbor China where kickbacks can be exorbitant then there are not many good role models around here . The whole society and administration would have to be changed so I suggest look to countries where they do well with corruption, take advice from them , learn from then and Thailand will be on the right way.
But it will be a jumpy road and there will be many problems on the way and a lot of influential people will have to let go of their power and that is not going to be done without a fight.

Posted by Sailor on March 30, 2014 17:48

Editor Comment:

Sailor, which country is the most successful in Asean? That's right, Singapore. The next large SE Asian nation to embrace Singapore's lead will benefit substantially, leaving the others behind. As you may know, penalties for corruption in China are severe. Why you choose to live in the past beats me.

gravatar

@Gee- Even sadder is that educated women are turning to working in bars or something similar to exploit 'elderly sophisticated and educated western men'. I guess the opportunity to more than triple your salary is just too much to turn down.

Posted by Billy on March 30, 2014 18:31

gravatar

Bit flippant maybe but:
One has to wonder if there were no police force on Phuket ...what would change? Maybe for the better?
Firing the endemically corrupt locals and hiring a few "top cops" from Singapore or Lankawi or..as a cleanup crew?
Establishing an independent "island" force with it's own IA department.
Ditching the awful uniforms in favour of something more fitting like Bermuda perhaps.
Funded and fully equipped by local levies/taxes?
Could well be a viable solution?

Posted by david on March 31, 2014 08:56

gravatar

I guess an "softly softly" interim solution would be an "uncorrupted" totally independent, in depth audit of ALL governance as to interests and associations to "businesses?",rellies etc..in short total transparency.
Sorry just a-dreaming..

Posted by david on March 31, 2014 10:03

gravatar

If the double triple or more pricing system doesn't kill it first, if you said to a Thai visiting your country ''we are going to charge you double because your are Thai'' would they find that acceptable.

Posted by slickmelb on April 1, 2014 00:17

gravatar

Way to Go Phuket Wan! Keep our hopes high! Every little step counts. One can either see a glass 'half full' or 'half empty' - the half full people are the ones who manages to keep sane and live their life to the fullest.

Posted by Silver Surfer on April 1, 2014 14:31

gravatar

Corruption is rooted in human wishes. Funny to speak about it in a buddist country. But... Every producer needs to sell its production, even if people really doesn't need it. Many ways were invented to give people false feelings, that they want something through tv, internet, billboards, etc.
But economic development of many countries, and Thailand is among them, doesn't let many people to get as much as they want. How to do? Work hard and get something at 60, or look for another, easier way and get everything quickly?
Low education level and cultural tolerance gave the way for second choice in many countries, including Thailand. Result is growing corruption. It is useless to fight corruption. People need ability to understand what they really want to get in life, what they really can get and how they can get it in a right way. But governments and big companies need consumers, not asketics...

Posted by Stranger on April 1, 2014 22:40


Thursday April 18, 2024
Horizon Karon Beach Resort & Spa

FOLLOW PHUKETWAN

Facebook Twitter